Thanks all! Some great comments. I just purchased some 6/4 sapele for a different project. It's great, but it costs an arm and a leg here in the northeast. I think Ash might be the way to go based on the suggestions here. Poplar will be way too soft. I think I'll employ a finishing schedule as Mike and Steve suggested. I'll spray a dye coat, followed by a top coat. I was planning on spraying Target2000 as my topcoat. Not sure if that will be compatible over an alcohol based dye coat. (If I spray shellac, it'll bring the dye back up, right? Other advice here is appreciated.) Either way, after a top coat, I'll use the Java gel stain, followed by spraying the Target2000 waterborne alkyd after plenty of time to dry. Any other comments or criticisms are welcome. I worry I'll start to outsmart myself soon!