Isaac

Members
  • Content Count

    992
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Community Reputation

605 Excellent

About Isaac

  • Rank
    Journeyman Poster

Profile Information

  • Gender
    Male
  • Location
    Illinois
  • Woodworking Interests
    Furniture, Hobbyist, Practical, cabinetry, turning,

Recent Profile Visitors

3,422 profile views
  1. Isaac

    Triton Dual Dowel Machine

    Its all good. I was just surprised to be questioned on it so much when it is pretty widely held belief, so it is not just my belief. On the other hand, I'm not just parroting someone else here, I've already made a specific case for why I think it is notably inferior connection to other common options. A dowel jig is cheaper than a biscuit joiner. It is better than nothing. No one is disputing that.
  2. Isaac

    Triton Dual Dowel Machine

    I just chose Marc because this is his site. If you google around you'll dig up lots of articles from various magazines and such making similar claims to Marc. If you dig even harder, you'll probably find someone claiming biscuits are the strongest connection available. I've already made my case. I think a single biscuit has poor grain orientation for a rail and stile joint compared to common alternatives. Adding a second biscuit will strengthen the joint, but doing so does add time and you certainly need to get the depth right to get a good fit.
  3. Isaac

    Triton Dual Dowel Machine

    I don't think anyone would really argue they are better then having no connection at all save for glue. I also agree with a point that you often make that many of our connections do not get fully stressed, so many connections will probably suffice. That being said, most biscuits I have seen have the end grain running along the length (from tip to tip of the football, so to speak) or at something close to 45 degrees. For that reason, they are easily friable when folded and torn in half when bent along this axis. Unfortunately, that is the same axis, or close to the same axis, that coincides with the joint line. If you get the grain running perpendicular to the joint, you'd have a skinny, loose mortise and tenon, and I'd agree, that has the potential to be a fairly robust joint. Alternatively, you can double up biscuits, which also increases the strength. but that also doubles the time invested. Anyhow, I don't think this is just an internet thing, and it is certainly not a crazy Isaac thing. This is the consensus I've seen from established woodworking experts: https://www.thewoodwhisperer.com/articles/are-biscuits-strong-enough/ So take it up with them I guess?
  4. Isaac

    Triton Dual Dowel Machine

    Long joints between sheet materials is where biscuits are primarily used. Of course long joints like that are strong with just glue, so adding the biscuits won’t hurt. Do you actually use biscuits for things like connecting the rails and stiles of a door frame? That seems like a really poor technique to me. The problem is the biscuits themselves have minimal strength and can be readily split by hand along the grain which coincides with the very same plane which will span between the two pieces of base material that are being joined. The same cannot be said for a dowel, domino, or mortise and tenon.
  5. Another option is a Fuji sprayer. This is the one I opted for. Certainly did the trick when I finished my baby boat crib last year. https://www.amazon.com/Fuji-2203G-Semi-PRO-Gravity-System/dp/B00D4NPPQY/ref=sr_1_3?keywords=fuji+semi+pro&qid=1552331658&s=hi&sr=1-3
  6. Isaac

    Avoiding "puddles" of dyed epoxy

    Good question, I've dealt with this a bit as well. Curious to see what others have to say.
  7. Isaac

    Triton Dual Dowel Machine

    Can't say about the Mafell vs. the Triton, but I can say that a dowel joint is different than a biscuit jointer. The biscuits really provide very little strength, and are most useful as alignment guides for glue-ups, not for strength. Also, based on the price I'm seeing for the Mafell, I think many here would guide you towards a comparably priced Domino joiner from Festool.
  8. Isaac

    Popular Woodworking

    I listened to a recent FWW podcast with Mike P. He made a great point. Most of the woodworking magazines look for various projects to fill each issue, trying to hit a certain level of complexity or so. FWW Doesn't take that approach. They are in touch with many top furniture designers around the world, and they find out what these top designers are already doing, and look to see if documenting their build would make a good piece for the magazine. So it is not just coming up with pieces to fill a magazine. It is documenting pieces already being made by masters. I think that is why FWW pieces consistently have the little nuances and details we all come to appreciate. Things you can’t always put your finger on initially, but which reward careful examination.
  9. Isaac

    Hand tool cabinet in maple

    Makes perfect sense to me. One figured cabinet board among a wall of straight grain would look odd.
  10. Isaac

    Bench Dog brand planes

    Sure looks like one! plus a bunch of Narex Chisels and rasps. Those are Czech, aren't they
  11. Isaac

    Harbor Freight DC with mods vs Grizzly G0548ZP

    Yes, I've got a poor mans separator built with a barrel and opposite facing elbows attached to the lid. It actually performs alright, but once it reaches about 2/3 full, you risk material bypassing the barrel altogether.
  12. Isaac

    Harbor Freight DC with mods vs Grizzly G0548ZP

    I think I don't quite understand how these systems are set up. With option three, how does material get to the bag at the very end? does that bag do anything?
  13. Isaac

    A Roubo from beams?

    That is interesting. I've generally had good success staining red oak. It seems to readily accept penetrating stains, and I don't seem to have blotchiness issues.
  14. Might you be able to re-cut it a 1/4" smaller around the perimeter, re-shape and salvage it?
  15. Isaac

    Indoor Herb Garden

    Haha yeah, It was literally the first image i found, just to be clear what I was referring to. I suppose a person could make it with a slider top and bottom, though that starts sounding really bulky/ugly. You better try it and let us know how it turns out. We're right behind you.