Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Brand New at Finishing: Is Maloof's Durable?

Featured Replies

I am on the finishing stages of completing a refinish of a dining table set for my wife. I have gone with a two-tone finish. The base of the table and chairs are painted with a gloss oil-based paint. The table top and sitting surface of the chairs are stained and finished. 

I have had to redo the finish 3 times now. I originally intended to go with shellac over stain. My first attempt went bad when I brushed on the shellac, as it became "lumpy" before I could get an even stroke across the table. There was no cure for this, so I stripped it, restrained it, then sprayed on the shellac. This coat went on very thick. After 24 hours dry time, the shellac was very soft. I was told by a supposed woodworking friend to put tung oil on top, as shellac is not a hard enough top coat. I used Formby's Tung OIl Finish (Which I just learned has no tung oil at all), putting on about 5 coats, with the recommended 12 hour dry time in between, followed by buffing with very fine steel wool between coats. After the final coat dried for 24 hours, I thought the table was ready to use. The first meal resulted in several indentations made by plates and cups, as well as fingerprints (as it was a gloss finish). I didn't learn about long cure times until after I had ruined all my work.
I have once again stripped it down to bare wood, sanded it to 320 grit, stander it with two applications of gel stain, and gone through the directions for use of Sam Maloof's Poly/Oil Blend (4 wipe-on/wipe-off coats with 24 hours in between) followed by two coats of Sam's Oil/Wax Blend. In fact, I will be putting on the final coat tomorrow. I plan to let it cure for a week.
I have a few questions based on the above scenario: Should I let the final coat cure longer than 1 week, as this will be my family's main dining table (We are a family of 5, with 3 young girls, age 4-12)? Also, is the oil/wax finish durable enough, if I use placemats? If it is not durable enough, is there a hard finish that can be put on top of the Oil Wax Blend finish? I would go with a satin finish, this time around (I learned my lesson about using high gloss on a dining table stained dark, and mainly used by kids).
I have a Rockler's nearby. I found their quality and knowledge of their products far better than the big-box stores, like Lowe's. Are there any other retailers anyone would recommend in Southern California?

 

For a dining table my preference would be.

 

2k

conversion varnish

catalyzed lacquer

wb poly 

 

In that order 2k being the better of the bunch. I think that I would use the Maloof stuff for just about anything else like a rocker or table that gets no abuse but a dining table is to much to ask.

  • Author

Can I put a Water-Based Poly over the top of an oil Based finish like Maloof's?

  • Author

Woodsap, 
           Thank you for the advice on staining. I think I will Just go with the finish I have, instead of starting over, or getting too crazy with sealing, then finishing with something durable. I guess one good thing about the finish is, it's easy to apply subsequent coats if it starts to wear. 
Also, thanks for the tip about the grit, as it relates to staining, versus clear finish.

One last question, since I used a gloss oil-based paint on the base of the table and chairs, do I need to put anything clear on top of for protection?
Thanks

I just saw this , and have to be out the door, but I can help .. Will respond in the am .. but the short answer to the Maloof finish being durable is  NO .. :wub:

Maloofs finish , is simply a BLO, varnish oil and Mineral spirits . It looks great when it goes on, because it produces a nice sheen and depth . The issue I found with it , is it dries out , and has to be re-newed .  In researching for a book, we tested as many finishes as we could get our hands on. My personal critera  for a wipe on finish,  (oils) was it had to dry relatively fast, and be durable . When we tested the finishes we , used a weak water base dye to see if the finish was indeed sealing the wood .. The Maloof as well as several others allowed the dye to get into the wood , it had dried about 2 weeks , and we had done  3 coats .  Later after it had dried about 3 months it lacked alot of the luster . While the suggest a wax  coating , that would help the sheen to a degree , but again would have to be re-newed.  Having to re-new a finish is not something I can afford to do , or expect my clients to do. Being a professional woodworker/finisher, our products go all over the place, so the finish has to hold up .

 

In our testing we found that Arm R Seal by General Finishes,  Minwax wipe on poly , Waterlox  , proved to do the best job.  This is not to say there are not other good products out there , because their are ,. The gel top coats seemed to do well . The finishes we found the least effective , were the pure oils,  Tung, BLO , and so forth.

  One of the things we noted especially in the pure oils was compared to older versions they dried super slow . Many of these products have been reformulated to meet VOC regulations , they are the same as in times past. 

  Bottom line is the Varnish oils, did a much better job and were as easy  to apply .

 

   To answer the question can you put a water base coating over the oil  , you can , but it has to be throughly dry , and if you have put the oil/wax.. then is has to come off, I woul dfurther suggest with the Maloof mix, to do a 1lb cut of shellac coat , just to be sure  prior to the water base .

 

   I think your issues is the shellac was old,  shellac has a shelf life of about 6 months , Zinnzer Seal coat will last alot longer . You always want to test the shellac by putting it a hard surface like glass , if it isn't drying in 30 to 45 min , might want to rethink . Also using thinner coats will help .  Shellac is an evaporative finish, meaning the alcohol has to evaporate out. When you applied the Formby 's   ( its another good one)  , you sealed the shellac  off and really slowed its ability to dry. Thus the soft finish . 

  Personally , I were you , I would allow the table to cure for a couple or 3 weeks , then clean it with some Naphtha, or mineral spirits, to remove the wax,  ( hopefully) , then  apply 2 coats of the Arm R SEal as a more protective coating , and be done .

  • Author

Charles,

Thank you for the advice. I think I will follow the final suggestion. I will have to make a trip to San Diego in order to do it, but I think it will turn out much better. Since my wife is getting anxious about the table, I think I'll put it in service for a couple weeks before I do that though... Maybe that will prove to be a bad idea, but I am no stranger to stripping it down and starting over. ;)

I look forward to learning more...

How long has the Maloof been on the table and have you applied the wax... Trying to determine if we can "fast forward" to the Arm R Seal

I use an Antique Paste Varnish when I'm finishing something like a kitchen or dining room table that's going to get a lot of traffic.

I love the idea of the paste as you apply it by hand and that gives me a lot of control. However, if you find the finish is a bit too thick to apply, keep some mineral spirits close by and dip your cloth in it to get an easier application.

This finish is great for its resistance to heat, water and alcohol. 2-3 coats is the best way to go, leaving 24 hours between the coats.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.