Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

starrett square age and restoration, stanley plane age and restoration

Featured Replies

Hey guys,

I picked up an older looking, rusted over, square from the local thrift store for $1.50. the ruler says hardened on it... and considering it says The LSS CO ATHOL MASS USA, i'm assuming i picked up an antique starrett square for a whopping $1.50. i didnt see this until i took a picture and zoomed in! so i'm very excited about this find.

now. it doesn't appear to be square any more... how do i restore this tool and get it square once again? I do have a new starrett coming in that i can check it against.

post-6574-0-37890900-1338123561_thumb.jppost-6574-0-26421200-1338123610_thumb.jp

the next is a #5 bailey/stanley plane that was left at our house by the previous owners... how old is it and how do i restore it? i assume the #5 is a jack plane? however, the blade itself is not curved at all, and i havent seen any other blades in the house (i also havent looked hard)

post-6574-0-16983300-1338124132_thumb.jppost-6574-0-50448300-1338123793_thumb.jp

I don't know much about the squares, but I've dated several stanley planes that I've bought at flea markets. I've used this site to do it.

http://www.hyperkitten.com/tools/stanley_bench_plane/start_flowchart.php

It's a great site with a lot if information. It goes through and asks several questions to determine which "Type" it is, which will lead you to the date of manufacture.

As for restoring it, I would clean up any rust on the blade using whatever method suits you(rust removal liquid from home store seems to work good for me) and then regrind and sharpen the blade, make sure the back of the blade is flat as well. The japanning on the body looks like it is in decent shape, so you shouldn't have to do anything there, as long as there aren't any cracks in the body, the only other thing you should do is make sure the sole is flat. You can clean up the marks on the sole using increasing grits of sandpaper on a truly flat surface (granite slab, cast iron table, etc), this is also how you would flatten the sole if needed.

I will mention that I've never had to flatten a plane sole as the ones I've found have been it fairly decent shape. Somebody else may be able to throw some input in speaking to that aspect more.

Post back and let us know what you've found. It's always fun finding tools.

On the subject of de-rustification, I've used very hit water and a scotch brite pad before on an old plane. Did a grand job of getting the rust off. I blasted it with WD-40 immediately afterwards to get rid of the water. I suppose I could have used WD-40 from the beginning instead of the water but it all worked out.

now. it doesn't appear to be square any more... how do i restore this tool and get it square once again?

I dunno the answer to your question, but I did have a thought. First clean it up and then see if there is still a problem. It could be that there is some dirt or rust or something that's preventing the blade from properly seating in the head when it's assembled. If that's all that's wrong, then cleaning it up would make it square again.

-- Russ

I've dated several stanley planes that I've bought at flea markets.

Lookin' for love in all the wrong places.

-- Russ

From looking at the second picture of the square it looks like it is missing a chunk from the head. If that isn't an optical illusion I doubt that you will have all that much luck ever getting the blade to lock down very well. Strange thing is that it looks like the missing area is perfectly flush with the bottom of the blade slot.?

Don't know much of anything about planes old or new.

For cleaning rust proir to restoring I have always done electrolysis with great luck but curiousity got the best of me after hearing others rave about Evapo-Rust I got a bottle the last time I ordered from LeeValley, will be trying this weekend:) As for dating the plane there are a few great sites but I also use http://www.hyperkitten.com/tools/stanley_bench_plane/

It walks you through how to date it and if you need any help feel free to ask here and someone will surely help. For tuning it up there are countless blogs and videos out there that will get the job done, here is the first one I found in an online search and it shows the basics of it http://woodtreks.com/how-to-tune-up-a-hand-plane/19/. I actually one a video a few years ago (the only time I have ever one anything) and it was Rob Cosmans Handplane Revival http://www.woodcraft.com/product/2080819/29479/rob-cosman-the-great-hand-plane-revival.aspx. It is a great video and I picked up a couple little tricks even after restoring many planes previously. He also covers it in his online workshop, along with everything else handtool related. Getting the tool ready to use is the easy job, learning to use it is the rest. Don't let it scare you because it can really take your skills to the next level if thats what you choose but there are many that get turned off by it (as I did for several years) because you don't get the results you want or expect. I learned after a LOT of trying and playing around but Rob really helped my refine my skills making me a much better handtool woodworker. You can pay by the month ($19 or $20 a month) or by the year. You get two 30 min. videos a week as well as access to about 90 videos that are already on the site! It is Rob and his son and son-in-law that do everything and you get a real "in the shop with him" feel. I am not linked to Rob in any way other than being a very pleased as a customer. Just something to think about.

For the square I agree with Russ about getting it all cleaned up first and then move to the next step if needed. If it isn't square it is a simple process of using a file and removing some of the cast from the offending area that the ruler sits on, little at a time until you get it perfect. After you get it square set the ruler in on the area you filed and make sure that it's flat, not that it has a high spot in the middle. The toughest part is finding a file narrow enough to get in there to do the job but I am sure most suppliers will have one. Let us know how you turned out.

Good luck,

Nate

  • Author

From looking at the second picture of the square it looks like it is missing a chunk from the head. If that isn't an optical illusion I doubt that you will have all that much luck ever getting the blade to lock down very well. Strange thing is that it looks like the missing area is perfectly flush with the bottom of the blade slot.?

you're certainly right. it wasnt until after i took the pictures and took a closer look at the edge where it's broken did i realize that it was in fact broken. i'll still clean it up and test it for squareness. as it, it seems to lock down well, but there may be some pull on the blade that is causing it to come out of square. good thing i just received my brand new starrett combo square yesterday!

i figure, i at least have a somewhat matching 12" ruler now.

For cleaning rust proir to restoring I have always done electrolysis with great luck but curiousity got the best of me after hearing others rave about Evapo-Rust I got a bottle the last time I ordered from LeeValley, will be trying this weekend:) As for dating the plane there are a few great sites but I also use http://www.hyperkitt...ey_bench_plane/

It walks you through how to date it and if you need any help feel free to ask here and someone will surely help. For tuning it up there are countless blogs and videos out there that will get the job done, here is the first one I found in an online search and it shows the basics of it http://woodtreks.com...-hand-plane/19/. I actually one a video a few years ago (the only time I have ever one anything) and it was Rob Cosmans Handplane Revival http://www.woodcraft...ne-revival.aspx. It is a great video and I picked up a couple little tricks even after restoring many planes previously. He also covers it in his online workshop, along with everything else handtool related. Getting the tool ready to use is the easy job, learning to use it is the rest. Don't let it scare you because it can really take your skills to the next level if thats what you choose but there are many that get turned off by it (as I did for several years) because you don't get the results you want or expect. I learned after a LOT of trying and playing around but Rob really helped my refine my skills making me a much better handtool woodworker. You can pay by the month ($19 or $20 a month) or by the year. You get two 30 min. videos a week as well as access to about 90 videos that are already on the site! It is Rob and his son and son-in-law that do everything and you get a real "in the shop with him" feel. I am not linked to Rob in any way other than being a very pleased as a customer. Just something to think about.

For the square I agree with Russ about getting it all cleaned up first and then move to the next step if needed. If it isn't square it is a simple process of using a file and removing some of the cast from the offending area that the ruler sits on, little at a time until you get it perfect. After you get it square set the ruler in on the area you filed and make sure that it's flat, not that it has a high spot in the middle. The toughest part is finding a file narrow enough to get in there to do the job but I am sure most suppliers will have one. Let us know how you turned out.

Good luck,

Nate

how do you go about the electrolysis, is it worth getting something set up to do that? will take a look at evapo-rust. my father in law has a sand blaster and glass beader available and is willing to shoot this stuff. figure i'd go with the glass beading to clean it all off, though, i'd really prefer to handle the entire restoration for my own pride.

I don't know much about the squares, but I've dated several stanley planes that I've bought at flea markets. I've used this site to do it.

http://www.hyperkitt...t_flowchart.php

It's a great site with a lot if information. It goes through and asks several questions to determine which "Type" it is, which will lead you to the date of manufacture.

As for restoring it, I would clean up any rust on the blade using whatever method suits you(rust removal liquid from home store seems to work good for me) and then regrind and sharpen the blade, make sure the back of the blade is flat as well. The japanning on the body looks like it is in decent shape, so you shouldn't have to do anything there, as long as there aren't any cracks in the body, the only other thing you should do is make sure the sole is flat. You can clean up the marks on the sole using increasing grits of sandpaper on a truly flat surface (granite slab, cast iron table, etc), this is also how you would flatten the sole if needed.

I will mention that I've never had to flatten a plane sole as the ones I've found have been it fairly decent shape. Somebody else may be able to throw some input in speaking to that aspect more.

Post back and let us know what you've found. It's always fun finding tools.

thanks! it's looking like a type 15... but i'm going from a rusty memory. it's apart and in a plastic bag in my home office, and i'm at work. will have to take another gander when i get home.

  • Author

question: as this hand plane is a No 5, does that automatically make it a jack plane? even though the blade is straight, and not curved.

The choice to sand/glass blast is yours but it would not be what I would do for two reasons. First is that you will loose the patina, the look of old metal, which I love on the old planes but thats a preference. The second reason is a bit more important, all the numbers and markings will most likely be lost making future dating impossible and really hurting the value. It's your plane and your call I just thought I would let you know.

Electrolysis is very quick and simple as long as you have a few materials. First you need a battery charger (I know i read somewhere that an old laptop cord works too but I have never tried it and am not sure there would be enough juice), a couple pieces of scrap steel, a bucket, and some washing soda (I use arm and hammer laundry soda with great results). There are tons of articles on the web that walk you through it, here is one http://lumberjocks.com/David/blog/2191. I have done this several times with my kids and we had a blast. I have taken a plane that was completely rusted and removed all of it within a short time and very little elbow grease. Some will say that the gas that is produced by the process is dangerous but I did some reading and found that the amount is so small it is harmless. I think the fears come from the places that have 100 gallon tubs and dunk big objects, then it might be more of a concern. Keep us informed and ask any questions you have.

Scapegoat: The term Jack plane relates more to the size of the plane rather than the shape of the blade. So, yes, the No 5 is a Jack plane no matter what the blade shape is. If you wanted the blade to be curved you could regrind the blade.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.