Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dust Collection In Steps

Featured Replies

I have a one-car garage sized shop, with a tablesaw, benchtop 9-inch bandsaw, scroll saw, drill press, miter saw, a soon-to-be-replaced dysfunctional lathe and a router table. I'm building a dust collector, but due to budgetary issues I'm going in steps.

This is actually my parent's shop, so the situation is temporary, but since my Mom has asthma and my Dad is very interested in learning to turn, somehow or other I intend for their to be a proper dust collector when I leave (which may be soon), so my Dad can play with the lathe to his heart's content.

Right now, I'm building a blower with a 14.5'' aluminum backward curved impeller, and a, ahem, 1/3HP motor. Do I actually need to buy the full 5HP motor recommended on Bill Penz's website, or for a shop this small can I buy a 3HP motor, or even a 1.5HP one?

Also, I'll probably vent the air outside the shop. Do I need to do anything special for filtration, or can I just put two or three furnace filters in a box? Will one work? Finally, is it true that aluminum impellers explode easily, or is that pretty rare? I doubt I'll find a steel one; I was lucky enough to find this one at a military surplus yard.

Anyway, thanks for any help.

Joe, let me throw a different ball at you....consider looking on Craig's list. Dust collection units are everywhere for $100-$200 that would fit your space and take care of dad. Many are almost new, it's ready made, and portable if necessary. Besides, when you've put $10 here and $20 there into the project, your performance is probably lower than a ready-made unit and the cost will be more to make it.

  • Author

The cost is lower, I think, mostly because I've been able to source the more expensive parts from scrap yards or relatives. Still, I'm starting to agree; so far, I think I've duplicated a $300-$400 1.5HP dust collector, and the goal was a Bill Penz style 3HP type. I'm not sure if this is worth the trouble, to be honest.

Just a couple of things for you to consider.

First, you will need something between your blower and the shop to seperate out the bigger chunks (dust - chips). I reccomed a 55 gallon drum. You can find them for almost nothing at a scrap yard, and they are nearly as effective as fancy "Cyclone" extractors. This way your motor is not coming in contact with the big stuff. If your dad is into the lathe, you will have TONS of shavings/dust. So you won't want to just eject them outside or you'll have a real mess to clean up out there. If collected there are actually quite a few uses for wood shavings.

Second. If you are going to exhaust your collector outside, be sure to use a damper of some sort. These can be very inexpensive ($3-$5) at a big box store. This way you won't have critters trying to nest in your dust collector. Mice do mean things to motors, and love the comfort of saw dust.

Third, if the budget allows, I reccomend setting up a fixed ducted system with blast gates. I still haven't gotten to this point because of the cost, but I curse everytime I move from machine to machine and have to drag the hose with me.

Good luck

  • Author

Thanks Chris. I want to do fixed ductwork and blastgates as well, but like you I'm also worried about the cost. For the separator, I bought a 55 gallon trash can, but it's pretty cheap. My dead-simple separator lid (simply two six-inch holes in the lid) isn't quite working, and I may end up building (or buying) one of those baffle things.

What about hose diameter? Do lathes need 6-inch hoses, or would a 4-inch hose work?

I actually use 2" hose which is weird, and I don't reccomend it. I use the 2" because it fits the make shift collector I have (refurb central vac) and I had access to lots of super cheap tubing that was 2". (I work for a company that sells all kinds of residential ventillation equipment, and one of those are central vacs)For your seperator, I have a piece of scrap wood fastened to the bottom of the lid perpendicular to the holes, that forces air to go down, and then back up. This really helps generate the cyclone type air flow. Sorry for the crude paint scetchup, but I hope this makes sense.

post-7224-0-36123400-1354044274_thumb.jp

  • Author

I actually use 2" hose which is weird, and I don't reccomend it. I use the 2" because it fits the make shift collector I have (refurb central vac) and I had access to lots of super cheap tubing that was 2". (I work for a company that sells all kinds of residential ventillation equipment, and one of those are central vacs)For your seperator, I have a piece of scrap wood fastened to the bottom of the lid perpendicular to the holes, that forces air to go down, and then back up. This really helps generate the cyclone type air flow. Sorry for the crude paint scetchup, but I hope this makes sense.

Thanks.

  • Author

Joe, have you looked on Craig's list?

I've not; by the time you made that suggestion, I was pretty far along in this project. I just did a quick look (not on Craigslist; people use the local radio station's website for classifieds here more than they use Craigslist), and there are some interesting options. But, at this point I can't really justify the expense.

Joe, I noticed your updated photo's in the gallery. Have you tested your DC through the seperator yet? I am curious how it holds up to the pressure. It looks like its plastic, and I know my metal drum pops and compresses a bit, so I didn't know if the plastic will hold up.

I would love to swap to a plastic can so I don't have to haul the metal up and down the stairs when it fills up, but I assumed the plastic would not be strong enough. (You know what happens when you assume!)

Either way, I know homemade solutions are often not as good as the commercial ones, and usually more headache than you plan for, but I always love to see what people come up with. Even if it never runs right, you at least get the education along tha way! Good Luck!

  • Author

Joe, I noticed your updated photo's in the gallery. Have you tested your DC through the seperator yet? I am curious how it holds up to the pressure. It looks like its plastic, and I know my metal drum pops and compresses a bit, so I didn't know if the plastic will hold up.

I would love to swap to a plastic can so I don't have to haul the metal up and down the stairs when it fills up, but I assumed the plastic would not be strong enough. (You know what happens when you assume!)

Either way, I know homemade solutions are often not as good as the commercial ones, and usually more headache than you plan for, but I always love to see what people come up with. Even if it never runs right, you at least get the education along tha way! Good Luck!

It seems to work, at least in the tests I've done so far. But I won't really know until I stress-test it.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.