Recommended Posts

Posted

Let me start by saying I’ve been a cabinet maker slash normite woodworker for 20 years. The last five years I’ve discovered hand tools and I’m trying … REALLY TRYING to become more of an artist. To that end I’ve incorporated a lot of hand tools into my arsenal. There is something kind of magical about a well-tuned hand plane with a sharp blade.

 

Okay, having said that, I don’t want this to be another LN vs LV debate. I buy from both companies. But I have a little extra cash burning
a hole in my pocket, and a gift card to get me about half way there. With the number of tenons I’ve been cutting lately, I’m looking for a good tenon cleaning plane that could serve additional purposes as well. So the main purpose of this plane would be to bring tenons to their final dimension, but of course I’d like some versatility as well. It should be noted that today I use my Veritas Medium shoulder plane for this purpose today and it works well, but is only just under ¾” wide.

 

So, I’m planning on adding a plane to my collection and I’m actually trying to decide which plane to get next. Here are my leading contenders:

1 – Veritas Skew Rabbet Plane – Seems really versatile and Man, it just looks
cool!

 

2 – Lee Nielsen or Veritas skew block plane – Looks great, I like the scoring spur that makes a lot of sense to me. Only real issue here is that I’ve already own 3 block planes, but none of them are a skew block plane.

 

3 – Lee Nielsen’s Rabbet block plane – This is the tool I’ve seen Marc use for this task. Only real issue here is that I’ve already own 3 block planes, but none of them are a rabbeting block plane.

 

4 – Veritas Large Shoulder Plane – I love LOVE my medium shoulder plane. It is one of the planes everyone should own. The larger brother seems like a logical next step.

 

5 – Veritas Jack Rabbet Plane – It has a fun name and it looks awesome. It’s about 75 to 100 bucks more expensive than any of the above options.


Of course I realize this isn’t the most critical topic in the world. Believe me I do appreciate the fact that there are those out there with greater problems than adding another plane to my collection. So, I do count my blessings that I’ve made enough good decisions in my life and have a supporting enough wife to support my hobby/side business/obsession whatever you want to call it.


Having said that I find that with both LN and LV their products are such a pleasure to use that they are almost addictive. … Did I say almost? They also hold their value really well. I’ve found that if I get one of their products and don’t like it, I can get about 80% of its new value in resale.

 

So, I’d love to hear your thoughts. Remember I’m not starting a LV vs LN debate. And dang, this is a much longer post than I originally planned.

 

Posted

The rabbet planes aren't technically made for working tenons, and I think they'd be a little too big and awkward for that task...not that it couldn't be done.

 

Skew block planes are a great idea, but I'd personally feel weird buying just one and not the other, since it would only then be advantageous for half of your tasks.  Buy both, you double the cost.

 

You already have a shoulder plane...how much more versatility would a large add to your medium?

 

Me in your shoes...LN rabbeting block plane.  Easy choice...if a plane for trimming tenons is what you're after.

Posted

Eric,
I should have mentioned that these would be larger tenons. Picture the breadboard end of a Roubo.

I still like my shoulder plane for little tennons. So, really this isn't a plane I need, as much as a plane I want. Again, money is just burning a hole in my pocket.

So to some degree I'm looking for versatility.

Posted

I was somewhat in the same situation some months ago when I was looking at the Woodriver low angle block plane an really wishing it could do more, then one of the WTO episodes they briefly mentioned that, frequently, power tool users find the joinery planes to be the most useful. Flash forward a birthday, xmas, and some spare change and I have the LN rabbeting low angle block plane and the right handed LV rabbeting skew block plane.

 

Specifically, this one:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=65373&cat=1,41182,48942

 

and this one:

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?sku=60_5R

 

The skew block plane really saved my bacon when I was trying to level a bubinga joint and the exposed grain was just going the wrong way to work on well (keeping in mind that I've got around 1/10th the experience you have working against me as well), but the skew with an adjustable mouth and rabeting on one side, wow, with very light passes it saved the day in ways that regular low angle plan just cant. It also feels much, much better on end grain. The down side is that it has a definate handedness to it (left or right) and there have been cursing it's lack of rabeting on the other side. My opinion, the lee valley skew planes would work best as a set and I'm actively saveing for the other one, albeit it's much lower on the list. Oh, and the optional fence is super cool and useful as well. I've only used it once or twice (probably unnecessairly) but it was simple, smooth, and easy to use.

 

The Lie nieslen rabbeting block plane is another one which can jsut be described as the most expensive $150 tool you'll ever buy. It doesn't suffer from the handedness issue, nickers on both sides, great tool as we all know. It's relatively new in my tool case and, in point of fact, not 20 minutes ago I was using it to level a mahogany inlay (of sorts) in some plywood. Were I to have only one block plane with no plans to get another, this would probably be it. With the exception of an adjustable mouth, it can do almost all the block plane tasks I've needed it for, and it seems like it would be perfect for what you're after at $200 less than than the veritas set. It also seems like the LN block plan it a smidge wider than the Veritas planes. I'll post a picture of them side by side later tonight when I have the chance.

 

I too have the 3/4 shoulder plane and, honestly, I wouldn't get the 1 inch to side a tennon. Shoulder planes are made for working the end grain of the shoulder, as Shannon and Swchwarz often say, and are not really great at working the cheek. For what I'm getting you're after, the 3/4 it's probably more than adequate.

 

As for the Veritas Skew Rabbet Plane and Jack Rabbet Plane, never used 'em, but to my amature eye it seems like those a much larger tools and would prevent you from really working the cheek of smaller tenons as well. No clue if that's true, but I'd be reluctant to go after a 1" tenon with a plane that big in my  clumbsy paws. There is, however, a great deal of other stuff you can do with it I suppose.

Posted

Eric,

I should have mentioned that these would be larger tenons. Picture the breadboard end of a Roubo.

I still like my shoulder plane for little tennons. So, really this isn't a plane I need, as much as a plane I want. Again, money is just burning a hole in my pocket.

So to some degree I'm looking for versatility.

 

Then I'd get the LN rabbeting block plane AND the Veritas skew rabbet plane. :D

Posted

Hi Chet - if that money is really bothering you, feel free to let me take it off your hands. :)

 

I've been having the debate with myself about which 'good' planes to get.  I already have a good block plane and an "eh" Stanley #5 jack plane.  I am thinking a smoother, but I am definitely going to get a router plane - for exactly the reason you mention (among several), tweaking and finessing tenons.  A rabbetting block plane would suit your needs for larger tenons, but I hope a large router plane makes it onto your list.

Posted

Hi Chet - if that money is really bothering you, feel free to let me take it off your hands. :)

 

I've been having the debate with myself about which 'good' planes to get.  I already have a good block plane and an "eh" Stanley #5 jack plane.  I am thinking a smoother, but I am definitely going to get a router plane - for exactly the reason you mention (among several), tweaking and finessing tenons.  A rabbetting block plane would suit your needs for larger tenons, but I hope a large router plane makes it onto your list.

 

Now John, how would that feed my hand plane addiction?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 44 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,008
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Bob44
    Newest Member
    Bob44
    Joined