Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

My review of the MLCS Cast Iron Sliding Router Table

Featured Replies

Okay, so I bought a new router table. I got MLCS cast iron model with the sliding table.

http://www.mlcswoodworking.com/shopsite_sc/store/html/smarthtml/pages/router_table_2.html#precision_table_anchor

This is actually the 4th router table I've ever owned. It is replacing a quick and dirty section of counter-top with a router plate droped in and an inexpensive fence, which I built in like an hour 3-1/2 years ago. (It was supposed to be temporary.) Before that I had a cast iron leaf on my contractors table saw that worked fine. But when I got my cabinet saw I had to throw together a router table and now I've finally replaced it. The very first router table I ever had was a benchtop Bosch which was about 10 years ago, before I got the contractors saw.

So with that background information complete, here's my review.

Assembly Instructions: Not only did the table come with the worst assembly instructions I've ever seen for a tool. These were the worst assembly instructions I've ever seen. You are better off, watching the on-line videos and assembling the thing from the color picture on the web-page. The only saving grace is that all the reviews I’ve seen of this product said that the assembly instructions suck, they are correct. But at least I knew this going in so I didn’t expect good instructions.

Operation: This is where this table shines. The cast iron top leads to super-solid performance. I didn’t think my old table vibrated, but when I run this one it “feels” really really solid.

The Sliding Table Feature: As anyone who knows me is aware, I am a cabinet maker who is trying to become a woodworker. I’ve made tons of raised panel doors. I can tell you this table absolutely excels for making raised panel doors. If you make a lot of raised panel doors, you will love this table. So far I cut one raised panel in MDF, I made the door styles and rails. Dead nuts! Super Smooth operation!

Dust Collection: Surprisingly good. There’s only the above-the-table option right now. I plan to build a box or even an entirely new router table cabinet, but even without that it was better than I thought it would be. I’m still going to build a box with a dust port below the table, but you could probably get by without one if you don’t mind shop vac-ing out the area under the table after each use.

Things MLCS could do to improve: Over-all, I’m really very happy with the table.

But MLCS could really help themselves out by learning how to make instruction manuals. (Look to SawStop as the Industry Leader when it comes to this area.)

Also, there’s no router plate with this table. I find that’s great for me because I have a router dedicated to hanging under my table. But if you have only one router and plan to take it off and put it on, forget this table. It took me a good hour to get my Freud 3-1/4HP router properly hung on there. With practice I bet I could get it down to a ½ hour. It is still way too difficult.

The other thing is if you want to adjust the router height from above the table, you’ll be drilling your own hole in the cast iron to do so. Again this isn’t a problem for me. Similarly, if you want to use a pin.

Things MLCS got right: Once again, over-all, I’m really very happy with the table.

The sliding table works great for either making door rails or for raised panels.

It has air assisted pistons which help raise the table to access the router. These work great, a small complaint is the system for locking the table down is a threaded T-nut. It works fine , but they is like an inch worth of threads so it takes a lot longer to screw them in then it needs to. I’ve already gotten to the point where I only screw them in about 10 percent of the way.

The cast iron table was dead flat out of the box. With no plate router insert it is all very accurate, all very flat right up to the bit.

I also found the weight of the cast iron top to give the table a great feel. Solid, no vibration at all. As a side note, the table height is slightly lower than my old table and I actually thought that was a good thing. It felt good to use.

Lastly, the table makes great use of the area it has. The table top is fairly large for a commercial router table, one of the larger ones out there. But in addition, the router is positioned near the rear so that you get a lot of usable space.

Over all, once you get the thing set up, it really is a great table, especially if you are a person who makes a lot of raised panel doors.

Awesome, I love reading honest reviews from users. I think I have compared every table out there, and I still can't make up my mind. I will have to dig this back up six or eight months from now and beg for a follow up.

Great unbiased review! thanks for taking the time to do so. it's reviews like yours that make make this place tick.

Chet-

I've been herniating over which router table to buy for a while now, and this one is on my short list. One question: I have the same router you are using, and wonder if you find the thickness of the cast iron top a problem with getting adequate bit height?

Carl

  • Author

Chet-

I've been herniating over which router table to buy for a while now, and this one is on my short list. One question: I have the same router you are using, and wonder if you find the thickness of the cast iron top a problem with getting adequate bit height?

Carl

It is no worse or better than any other router table I've mounted my Freud in. I've had my Freud for quite a while. It is the oldest of my three routers. However, I did modify it to help with putting it under the table. 1st I removed the set-stops. I took out that center screw that holds the three alan-head stops in place. For me that just got in the way. I also cut the tube guards off the plunge-tubes. It seems to allow the router to plunge deeper that way. After that I have no trouble with it in this or any other table.

Two things: One is that I only use 1/2" shanks, no 1/4" shanks in my bit collection. The other is as I mentioned in the reveiw it is no easy task to get the Freud, or any other router for that matter, properly mounted in this table. So if you only have one router (especially if you only have one base) do not buy this table. But, once you get it in there and set up, no problem with depth.

Let me know if you have further questions.

Take care,

Chet

  • 2 weeks later...

Okay, so I bought a new router table. I got MLCS cast iron model with the sliding table.

http://www.mlcswoodworking.com/shopsite_sc/store/html/smarthtml/pages/router_table_2.html#precision_table_anchor

This is actually the 4th router table I've ever owned. It is replacing a quick and dirty section of counter-top with a router plate droped in and an inexpensive fence, which I built in like an hour 3-1/2 years ago. (It was supposed to be temporary.) Before that I had a cast iron leaf on my contractors table saw that worked fine. But when I got my cabinet saw I had to throw together a router table and now I've finally replaced it. The very first router table I ever had was a benchtop Bosch which was about 10 years ago, before I got the contractors saw.

So with that background information complete, here's my review.

Assembly Instructions: Not only did the table come with the worst assembly instructions I've ever seen for a tool. These were the worst assembly instructions I've ever seen. You are better off, watching the on-line videos and assembling the thing from the color picture on the web-page. The only saving grace is that all the reviews I’ve seen of this product said that the assembly instructions suck, they are correct. But at least I knew this going in so I didn’t expect good instructions.

Operation: This is where this table shines. The cast iron top leads to super-solid performance. I didn’t think my old table vibrated, but when I run this one it “feels” really really solid.

The Sliding Table Feature: As anyone who knows me is aware, I am a cabinet maker who is trying to become a woodworker. I’ve made tons of raised panel doors. I can tell you this table absolutely excels for making raised panel doors. If you make a lot of raised panel doors, you will love this table. So far I cut one raised panel in MDF, I made the door styles and rails. Dead nuts! Super Smooth operation!

Dust Collection: Surprisingly good. There’s only the above-the-table option right now. I plan to build a box or even an entirely new router table cabinet, but even without that it was better than I thought it would be. I’m still going to build a box with a dust port below the table, but you could probably get by without one if you don’t mind shop vac-ing out the area under the table after each use.

Things MLCS could do to improve: Over-all, I’m really very happy with the table.

But MLCS could really help themselves out by learning how to make instruction manuals. (Look to SawStop as the Industry Leader when it comes to this area.)

Also, there’s no router plate with this table. I find that’s great for me because I have a router dedicated to hanging under my table. But if you have only one router and plan to take it off and put it on, forget this table. It took me a good hour to get my Freud 3-1/4HP router properly hung on there. With practice I bet I could get it down to a ½ hour. It is still way too difficult.

The other thing is if you want to adjust the router height from above the table, you’ll be drilling your own hole in the cast iron to do so. Again this isn’t a problem for me. Similarly, if you want to use a pin.

Things MLCS got right: Once again, over-all, I’m really very happy with the table.

The sliding table works great for either making door rails or for raised panels.

It has air assisted pistons which help raise the table to access the router. These work great, a small complaint is the system for locking the table down is a threaded T-nut. It works fine , but they is like an inch worth of threads so it takes a lot longer to screw them in then it needs to. I’ve already gotten to the point where I only screw them in about 10 percent of the way.

The cast iron table was dead flat out of the box. With no plate router insert it is all very accurate, all very flat right up to the bit.

I also found the weight of the cast iron top to give the table a great feel. Solid, no vibration at all. As a side note, the table height is slightly lower than my old table and I actually thought that was a good thing. It felt good to use.

Lastly, the table makes great use of the area it has. The table top is fairly large for a commercial router table, one of the larger ones out there. But in addition, the router is positioned near the rear so that you get a lot of usable space.

Over all, once you get the thing set up, it really is a great table, especially if you are a person who makes a lot of raised panel doors.

I have one of those tables. I got mine many years ago when Woodline Arizona was selling them. You are 100% correct about the instructions they blow. The switch well it looks like they made some improvements on the switch. I took the switch off my old PC RT to use ILO of the one that came with the table.

But The tojan heel of the entire system was the fence .

Mine was horrible.

There was something going on with the adj screws for the split fence.

I ended up making my own.

Also mobility, I had to come up with something to set it on and move it around the shop.

If you have the room and se it as a stationary tool then its great.

The bottom line question for me is:

Is it a good RT?

I'd say yes.

Would I spend the money and buy another one?

Id have to say no I wouldnt.

But I got it, I use it.

it does a good job.

Just like you said it accells on raised panels and rails and styles.

Good review, Chet. I must say the lack of a mounting plate is a deal killer for me, but it sounds like a nice table for those who can go without. Thanks for letting us all know.

  • 3 years later...

Chet,

 

I'm looking into getting this brand MLCS, but I cant decide on the "Heavyweight" or "Precision" model.

http://www.mlcswoodworking.com/shopsite_sc/store/html/smarthtml/pages/router_table_2.html#heavyweight_table_anchor

I originally had a homemade router with a formica/plywood router top.  It had average results. but raised panels and stiles was lacking.  I wanted a iron table top, so I got a shaper.  It excelled at raised panels/stiles, but because of its slower speed (10,000 rpm's) I found it would take chunks off of long pieces of wood. OK I sold that(I might revisit a shaper by itself if I ever have the room in my garage in the future) and now I am looking for either one of these models.  I'm wondering what the trade-off's are with each.  The Heavyweight well ...........has more weight.  While the Precision with the sliding top has less sturdiness because of the sliding aluminum top.  If I go with Precision, am I sacrificing sturdiness and getting more vibration?  After having this for a few years now, how it is doing?

  • 1 year later...

I have one of these tables. As stated the cast iron table is robust, but for attaching the router, it is not to my liking. You have to deal with a limited area for the router base, screw down clamps and you have to center the router as best possible. I have read some people have had the mating area machined to accept their router with tapped holes to screw it down.

The sliding table is ok, although the sliding portions stands proud about .050" over the cast iron table. When you are using the hold-down clamps on the sliding table, it tends to flex because that portion of the clamp will be .050" proud as well, so when adjusting your bit you will have to take this into calculation. The sliding mechanism is extruded aluminum, so as you get wood chips in the slide, it will cause friction until it is cleared. Over time, this area will wear as well.

The fence is a joke, at best. The design is 3 pieces held together with small bolts. Then trying to keep the 3 pieces flush and tighten at the same time... well good luck with that. File 13!

Too bad the designers couldn't have thought through this to make it a great table. Its there, just pure laziness in the design. I agree that I would not buy another one, such as this design. A solid cast iron table, with robust configuration to attach routers, and a good fence. Maybe take this and redesign for a new patent????

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.