Recommended Posts

Posted

OK, it is time for me to scale up and get a decent jointer. I have been saving in prep for this buy, so I have a little bit of budget, but I do have some questions about what features/designs people think are worth it. Let's say my budget would allow for either:

 

1) An 8-inch jointer with a helical/spiral cutter, or...

2) A 12-inch jointer with straight knives

 

Perhaps worth knowing, I have 220v in the shop, and I have a DeWalt 735 planer with the Byrd Shelix head. I work mostly with domestic hardwoods, including a fair amount of figured cherry, maple and birch, but relatively few tropical exotics.

 

Do people find they need more capacity than an 8-inch jointer? Maybe I should get a straight knife 8-inch and save some of the budget towards a drum sander? Help?

 

--James

 

Posted

Since your planer has a spiral cutterhead, I'd go ahead with the 12" jointer...you can always clean up both sides on the planer.  I have an 8", and I've wished I had a 12" many times...I've never found myself wishing I had a 6".

Posted

I wouldnt get cought up with width, lenght is just as and many times more important. Rarely if ever you will need a 11+" finished board. Think about the geometry of a jointer. You dont joint a 12" wide board with a cup and the rip it down to 6" that is wasting lumber. You would rip first then face joint to preserve thichness.

The same goes for length. A quick rule is max board length is bed length. Optimum board length is infeed table length for max lumber yield.

This is were the pro combo guys get lost with the real short beds. Short beds are a euro thing but sliders are also a euro thing and they go hand in hand because a slider will straightline without jigs.

You will hear guys say they face joint 12ft long boards all the time. This simply is not possible if the board has any flex under its own weight.

For a cabinet shop doing mostly face frame cabinets a 12" jointer is about perfect because of the lenght even though you would never joint to full width. Even if your doing dining tables your not really going to need 12" 12" boards are overly subject to cupping thus why we glue up smaller boards. With the 12" you get the lenght to properly joint 84" boards without wasting a whole buch of material to wedging.

I think the mindset with jointer manufacturers is that they need the mass of 12" width to make a long enough to accomadate longer boards. Width and length really need to be looked at seperatly when making the buying decision.

Posted

I would recommend the 8" or 12" jointer with straight knives and a drum sander.  I have a Powermatic 8" jointer (3 knfe cutterhead) and it serves most of my needs.  I also have the DW735 with Shelix and a Performax 16-32.

Posted

I'm not much of a help because I'm new to rough stock still. I just bought an 8" Grizzly jointer. It has a 4 blade cutterhead, and leaves a glassy finish.

I went from a 6" bench top jointer that was 34" long to a 8" industrial jointer that is 72" long. The bed length, in my opinion, is more important than the width. I had to rig up a jig to add on some length to my bench top jointer. I'm sure a 12" jointer is longer than 34" - but you get my point.

I am a +1 for the 8" jointer.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

As usual, its always about the "length". 12" wide boards are bound to have a cup and to flatten the wood you could be removing a great deal of stock. Rip them and then glue. I switched to the 8" helix and love it. Like all machines, nothing is perfect, there is setup and maintenance, but the interval on maintenance is much greater. This leads to more building time in the shop that fixing time. Plus as I got older, I was having a harder time with the joiner blade setup. The inserts are much easier on the older eyes.

Posted

I just can't agree with the "length is better than width" theory.  I'll take more width any day.  In 25 years I've never face jointed a board over 8' and you can easily do that on a short bed jointer.  By short bed, I mean 64".  If a board is too cupped or bowed it should be cut into thinner or shorter pieces anyway.  When using rough sawn stock, it more often than not comes in widths too wide for a 6" and very often too wide for an 8".  I've had a 6", an 8" and now a 12" and if I can joint a 12" wide board I'll do it and then cut it to size.

Posted

I just can't agree with the "length is better than width" theory.  I'll take more width any day.  In 25 years I've never face jointed a board over 8' and you can easily do that on a short bed jointer.  By short bed, I mean 64".  If a board is too cupped or bowed it should be cut into thinner or shorter pieces anyway.  When using rough sawn stock, it more often than not comes in widths too wide for a 6" and very often too wide for an 8".  I've had a 6", an 8" and now a 12" and if I can joint a 12" wide board I'll do it and then cut it to size.

Its not a theory its a fact. You will yield thicker finished lumber with a longer bed than an shorter bed. If you joint a 12" board and then rip it to a 6" board all your doing is wasting thickness.

Posted

Its not a theory its a fact. You will yield thicker finished lumber with a longer bed than an shorter bed. If you joint a 12" board and then rip it to a 6" board all your doing is wasting thickness.

 Or if the board is pretty cupped, and requires you to rip it in half anyway.

Posted

I dont think length is off the topic at all. Jointers increase in lenght with width the only way to get a decently long bed is to increase width wether you ever need the width or not.

Stock yield is actually more of a pain in the A$$ for the hobby guy. Mills are thinning down their stock especially places that sell to hobby folks. Wood working stores are terrible and the only choice for many. Rockler and woodcraft sell wood so thin if if you dont watch every mm of stock your going to end up with wood to thin to use. To believe your buying flat no cup or bow stock is delusional so with the way mills are ripping off hobby folks today length is probably more important than width. Taking the tid bit of information from a production level is not off the subject by any means. Its information that can be applied to the home shop to net better results on a micro scale.

As to straight vs helical. Thats a personal thing mostly based on the type of wood used. Helical will only cut under 1/8" max so if your like me and do all your tapering on the jointer the helical would be a pain. Figured wood does better on a helical for sure and if thats your thing then go helical. But its again just a personal choice with both having their own merits. If your shopping for the best then id say neither and go with a tersa. :)

Posted

Its not a theory its a fact. You will yield thicker finished lumber with a longer bed than an shorter bed. If you joint a 12" board and then rip it to a 6" board all your doing is wasting thickness.

 

 

 Or if the board is pretty cupped, and requires you to rip it in half anyway.

As I stated, if the board is too cupped or bowed it should be cut into smaller pieces before jointing.  If it's reasonably flat you save work and lose no thickness with a wide board.  I've done it too many times.  If I'm building a rocking chair seat, I'll want two 12" boards.  Longer is better than shorter but wide and long is best.

Posted

Its not a rip everything down and glue it back together approach. Its a rip everything down to close to final dimension then joint and stop wasting material approach.

If you need a 12" board in full form then by all means joint it wide. But if you only need 6" why would anyone choose to make more sawdust than needed along with loosing thickness of the material. Besides the waste is x2 for the planer side.

This is why factories gang rip first, jump cut, plane, mould then final jump.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 43 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined