Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Help with bad stain/sanding job

Featured Replies

I have a veneer table that I am refinishing.  After stripping and sanding it I used the conditioner then stained it.  Right off I could see all kinds of scratches from my sanding job.  I then sanded it down again making sure to smooth out the scratches and started over with the conditioning and staining.  Now the stain is really blotchy and there are a few swirls from the sander that show through.  I am worried that if I try to sand it down again I will be out of my veneer layer.  Are there any other solutions to fix my mess?  The table is also very difficult because the wood goes all different directions :-(

post-14490-0-71566800-1378429000_thumb.j

post-14490-0-02175500-1378429001_thumb.j

post-14490-0-38875300-1378429001_thumb.j

First off, Trisha, we'll need a little more information before an educated answer can be given. First, what species of wood, if you know? Second, how fine of grit paper did you sand it with and how did you sand it? Third, what stain and finish coat are you using? Table tops are a bummer to refinish because the light shines across them and shows every defect. Getting it "perfect" is sometimes impossible due to past abuse, however, there are ways to hide a lot of the flaws and still come out with a decent job. Giving us the above details will tell us where our starting point is.

 

Welcome to the forum, BTW. Hope we can help.

  • Author

I am fairly sure it is oak.  The first time sanding it I used 100, 150, 180, 220 all by hand.  The second time I used a corner cat finish sander with 120 followed by 220.  I am using minwax wood finish stain in dark walnut and I used the minwax pre stain wood conditioner. 

Trisha, it looks like you have sanding marks that are going across the grain. When you sand, always sand with the grain. The veneer layout on your table is challenging to do this with anything other than a lot of tedious hand sanding or the use of a random orbit sander. Since all you have done to this point is stain, I would first try to wipe the table down with mineral spirits to take as much of the stain off as you can. Buy or borrow a random orbit sander and lightly sand with  320 grit until you get the scratches out. Then stop sanding. Make sure when you get close to the edges that you go extra light on the sanding, as it is easy to sand through veneer around the edges.

 

Once you have sanded it to your satisfaction, wipe it down with spirits again and it will show you how good a job you have done, as well as pull any dust out of any open pores. Once the table is dry again, determine if any touch-up sanding needs to happen and then go straight to stain after the touch-ups. Oak normally doesn't need a conditioner as it should take stain very well. Make sure you use a soft cotton cloth to apply your stain, wiping with the grain, and wipe off any excess stain with a clean cloth before it dries. Allow the table to dry for several days after the staining, before you attempt a top coat.

 

I would suggest you use a wipe-on poly, satin finish. This is a very forgiving finish and you can build it with additional coats until you achieve the luster you want. After the first two coats, use 0000 steel wool to lightly sand the "nubs" off, dust off with a damp spirits rag and continue coating. Allow each coat to dry before you proceed and wipe your hand over to see if you've picked up any dust while it was drying. You may need to use the steel wool between each coat, but go easy with it or you can take too much off.

 

Last of all, wait for a couple of others to chime in here and then assimilate all of the info before you proceed. There are lots of finishing "secrets" to be shared here, by some folks that do awesome work. Best of luck on your adventure.

No, that's a brush on. I use regular oil based poly and mix it 50/50 with mineral spirits. Or, you can pay four times the price and buy Minwax wipe-on poly. Mix it using a measuring cup so it's an accurate ratio and only mix as much as you think you will need for the coat you are on. On the header at the top of the page, you will see a link on the left hand side to WoodWhisperer.com. Marc has some great videos on how to use wipe-on finishes.

==> A random orbital sander (ROS) is definitely the tool for the job, it leaves a random scratch pattern that is difficult to detect when you move with the grain.    It is well worth the investment if you see more projects like this in the future. 

 

While this is generally good advice, you have to be very careful using a RoS on veneer...  One of the key advantage of RoS is fast/efficient stock removal...  Veneers are highly susceptible to burn-through using RoS.  If you decide to use RoS on veneer, then use it on a low setting.

Hey Trisha

 

I have a few things to add. Always finish sand by hand and never depend on staining behind a machine. You will have to orientate your sanding with the grain. Its fine if you cross the seam a fuzz and cross grain the the mating piece as long as you clean up the cross grain scrathes when you finish sand the next section. For instance, I would start sanding in the diagonal areas first and cross onto the banding a tad. Next move to the bandings that are traped between other banding. This would be the banding that is split in two that runs side to side. Then move to the center piece that runs toward the leaf. After that sand the perimeter pieces that are between the perimeter banding that run the full length. Then the full length banding last. This will give you a nice progression that will move you outward and clean up all cross grain marks form crossing the seams. I hope you can make sense of this.

 

Minwax sucks @$$! See if you can locate a place to get Zar, Lenmar, or Old Masters. These are all good penetrating stains with substance and not colored water. Also, the coarser the paper for your final sand the darker your stain will take. Finishing with 100 grit is pushing boundries, but exceptable. Try for at least 120 if possible and up to 180. 220 in my book is only good if you are going with a natural finish with no stain.

 

Tr has some good ideas to remove as much stain as you can prior to more sanding. No conditioner needed.

 

Practice all processes on scrap. Including choice of finish. Get your plan and pull the trigger.

 

Best of luck

  • Author

This is great info everyone! I really appreciate it! I have hope :-)

@grain guy would you recommend using the ROS with the super fine grit to fix the damage I have caused and follow that up with hand sanding with a 180?

Just to add some techno babble.

 

 

With factory veneered objects like tables you have to think ahead, its not as fragile as one would think. The average veneer thickness is .025". The shop or factory that made the table took their cut out of that usually about 50% leaving you with .012. Your share is 50% of .012 if your lucky. At least half of the .012 is going to be glue saturated and will not uptake stain. Your left with about .006 which happens to be the average scratch of 150g sand paper.

 

You can test the surface roughness with a bright light, a good pair of eyes and a hard sanding block. Knowing what you already know about the veneer a 220g average scratch is .004. Find your surface imperfections and just swipe the 220 across the grain and look closely if the scratch does not hit the bottom of the imperfection move up to 180. If the 180 scratches below the imperfection you need to rethink your finishing options. 180 is .005 of your .006 share of the veneer, but all is not lost you may just have to move to a tinted finish rather than a stain or dye. The good part is once you hit the area that is glue saturated it is rock hard so you can go ahead and sand it all the way up to 320.

 

Now the bad that you cant tell in advance. Some shops will take the veneer down to the glue area for the purpose of saving finish and speeding the finishing process. You have a real good chance this is the case on stuff made from the 80's to current. I do this all the time it makes my life easier but prevents any refinishing down the road. Below is a sheet I just layed up, the veneer started off at .025 and now is .008 after going through the sander. .008 is where it just starts to bead water and wont suck up the finish. I'll hit it with 320 before spraying but nobody will ever be able to sand to refinish again.

 

 

 

does that mean that the lighter areas are light because they may be glue soaked and won't take the stain?

 

Very well may be, drip a drop of water in a couple areas and see if it absorbs. If it sucks it down its wood if not its glue or old finish.

should I restain with a gel stain when I get to the restaining point?

 

Somebody else will have to answer that one. All I use is spray stains , dyes, glazes and tinted top coats, no real experience with gel stains.

If it were me, I would move forward with hand paper. Start with100 and stop at which ever grit is going to give ya the color you are after. It may take a little more time, but a safer option.

The light spots could be places where the veneer is getting thin and the paper backing is keeping the stain from soaking in. If this is the case it's going to be hard to get stain to take at higher grits. There may come a point when you just need to cross your fingers and stain. If you still have those spots you can tint some finish and focus a little touch up to those areas. But seal the table first.

 ==> should I restain with a gel stain when I get to the restaining point? 

 

Once prepped, you might not want to color the wood at all...  Unless there's some reason you need to...  Natural Oak is quite pleasing...  You should get some cutoffs and experiment...

 

Gel stains work on Oak veneer fairly well, but as PB mentioned, how well is going to depend on the veneer's thickness and where the glue line falls...  After your prep, there might not be much veneer between the surface and the glue-line, so it could be risky to attempt to color the veneer directly...  you may end-up with uneven absorption -- even with a gel... A less risky approach may be toning or glazing.  

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.