Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Need a better tabletop finish

Featured Replies

I'm relatively new to woodworking and very new to finishing although I recently purchased and viewed "A Simple Varnish Finish" from this website which was great.

 

My wife and I recently purchased a new 36"x80" dining room table (picture attached) that we absolutely love although we knew from reviews when we purchased it that the finish is not very durable and prone to leaving water rings.  The top is solid sheesham (Indian Rosewood) with a very matte finish which we also like that is listed as "Water-based clear lacquer sealant".  Since it is a brand new table, I don't want to strip it to bare wood but rather build up a more durable matte finish over what is there. After watching Marc's video, I definitely want a rub-on finish and if doing a varnish, would probably add little boiled linseed oil to give myself a bit more working time on this large a surface with my lack of experience.  Does anyone have any suggestions or product recommendations that would work well for this?  

 

Specifically I guess, can I use something like a General Finishes Arm-R-Seal Urethane Topcoat (http://www.rockler.com/general-finishes-arm-r-seal-urethane-topcoat-satin) directly over what is there following the steps Marc uses in his video?  Should I build up a couple of coats with the Gloss first and just use the satin as a final coat?  I'm worried about the new finish playing nicely with the original finish.  

post-14884-0-87450100-1386773769_thumb.j

You hit the nail on the head. You really don't know exactly what is on the table. Water-based lacquer can be really anything. The word "lacquer" is only a marketing term. So if you guess wrong - your going to have to strip the table and start over.

 

My advice is to strip the table and get it down to the wood. Stack the cards in your favor, nothing worse than incompatibility of finishes. Sometimes that doesn't happen right away. Could take up to several months then you see your finish starting to lets go!   

 

-Ace-

  • Author

Please elaborate how a little alcohol will tell me enough about the existing finish to know if an oil varnish will work over it or are you enjoying a little jab at my expense? If so, I'll just chalk it up as a less-helpful version of the previous post and a vote to strip the existing finish.  Respectively of course since you have over 3,000 posts.  Also, I may not have been clear as our table has not been used yet and is sitting in my shop.  I'm looking to add a more durable finish as a preventative measure rather than a corrective measure.  

 

The sum total of my finishing experiences are non film-forming oils on Cedar, Cumaru and Ipe which I have to do annually but are very simple with no prep other than a thorough cleaning.

 

Would the best way to strip it be to just go at it with a random orbital?

if denatured alcohol makes it sticky it is probably shellac.

if lacquer thinner makes it sticky it is lacquer. but like Ace said there is Lacquer (the real stuff) and there is lacquer (basically any clear finish a marketer wants to call lacquer).

you can put varnish over shellac. if the shellac has wax in it it could be a problem but there are mixed real world views on that.

i don't know what you can put over lacquer. a coat of dewaxed shellac then poly would probably work.

if it were my table i would just get some coasters and see if i still want to refinish a year from now.

Not trying to be less than helpful :) if that was directed to me. :D:D:D I have refinished furniture for many years. I always strip and refinish. New tables or old tables doesn't matter.

Maybe you should use the table. Be careful and not let moisture sit on the table. Get down the road. If the finish gets crappy, deal with it then. Are you not going to drive a car for fear of having an accident? The finish is probably ok as it is. No finish is water-proof, some do better against moisture than others

-Ace-

  • Author

Ha, "just see what happens" may be the best advise of all but this is very helpful information, thank you.  I've certainly got my hands full at the moment wrapping up a gut renovation of the house this table is going in (going on 14 months) and my wife is growing very impatient with my side projects which is why she just bought the table to begin with.  Finishing is really a mystery to me and I was hoping to begin to ease into it a little here but I can strip it just as easy after a little wear and tear I suppose.  Marc's video was very helpful but I feel like I need a good book on the subject as well.  Are there any books considered the "Bibles" of finishing?

Please elaborate how a little alcohol will tell me enough about the existing finish to know if an oil varnish will work over it or are you enjoying a little jab at my expense? If so, I'll just chalk it up as a less-helpful version of the previous post and a vote to strip the existing finish.  Respectively of course since you have over 3,000 posts.  Also, I may not have been clear as our table has not been used yet and is sitting in my shop.  I'm looking to add a more durable finish as a preventative measure rather than a corrective measure.  

 

The sum total of my finishing experiences are non film-forming oils on Cedar, Cumaru and Ipe which I have to do annually but are very simple with no prep other than a thorough cleaning.

 

Would the best way to strip it be to just go at it with a random orbital?

 

Sorry didn't mean that to sound so short. Its probably water based shellac. Your table is a product of india. Water based shellac is used as commercial sealant although not a great one on woods in india for many years. You can test a spot on the under side chances are pretty good that pretty much anything will stick to it just fine. 

understanding wood finishing by Bob Flexner is the bible.

Stick is one thing adhere/bond is another. :)

I hear Charles Neil has a new book out. Starting to hear some reviews. Just do a Google search - Charles Neil finishing book "Simply Put"

-Ace-

Stick is one thing adhere/bond is another.   :)

 

I hear Charles Neil has a new book out. Starting to hear some reviews. just do a Google search - Charles Neil finishing book "Simply Put"

 

-Ace-

 

If its shellac it will "adhere/bond" just fine. Its just a matter of a simple alcohol test. There is only one way to find out. 

==> I hear Charles Neil has a new book out. 

 

My signed copy arrived last week... It's been sitting on my desk unread... I'll crack-it-open over the holidays... I'll post a review then...

  • Author

Thanks everyone for all of the really helpful info!  I'll do an alcohol test this weekend and see what I'm up against.

I'll also get a feel from my wife about how long I can have this table out of commission as well and I'll go from there.  

 

In addition to picking up a few of these books, I'll post a follow-up whichever way I decide to go.  

This thread might turn into a rather amusing saga, complete with pictures, if I decide to proceed.  

If its shellac it will "adhere/bond" just fine. Its just a matter of a simple alcohol test. There is only one way to find out. 

 

If its lac shellac ok. Water-based shellac, that's a different story, not up on the water-based stuff.

 

 

 

-Ace-

==> I hear Charles Neil has a new book out. 

 

My signed copy arrived last week... It's been sitting on my desk unread... I'll crack-it-open over the holidays... I'll post a review then...

 

 

Looking forward to the review.  :)

 

-Ace-

If its lac shellac ok. Water-based shellac, that's a different story, not up on the water-based stuff.

 

 

 

-Ace-

 

A lot of the C&B and of course other imported stuff from India is and why their finishes are trashed with ammonia based cleaners. Ammonia is used to dissolve Shellac. Some of their stuff is a real acrylic lacquer the only way to know is to test. But the real lacquer stuff usually doesn't leave water rings real easy.

A lot of the C&B and of course other imported stuff from India is and why their finishes are trashed with ammonia based cleaners. Ammonia is used to dissolve Shellac. Some of their stuff is a real acrylic lacquer the only way to know is to test. But the real lacquer stuff usually doesn't leave water rings real easy.

 

Huh :huh:

 

-Ace-

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.