dramhadhmad Posted December 26, 2013 Report Posted December 26, 2013 I am considering purchasing a downdraft table, probably either the Grizzly H2935 or H2936. I cannot find many reviews on these units online, and wondered what the collective wisdom of woodtalk might be able to come up with. My motivation to purchase a downdraft table is to deal with sanding dust. For about half the year, weather allows sanding outside, which is my preferred option. When sanding inside, I cannot always contain the dust at the source (e.g., belt sanding, some of my ROS, even hand sanding). I would be curious to hear the pros and cons of downdraft tables, and whether I should be looking at other units. As a final point, I have considered building one, but realistically, it is not going to happen (too many other projects to do). thanks. 1 Quote
Alan Bienlein Posted December 26, 2013 Report Posted December 26, 2013 Mine is 48" x 60" and I should have built it years ago! The only con I can see is having to clean/ replace the filters. Other than that everything else is a plus. I even let mine run just to help clear the air when running other tools in the shop. Mine also serves as the out feed table for my table saw. Quote
tim0625 Posted December 26, 2013 Report Posted December 26, 2013 Dram....do you have a dust collector? Quote
dramhadhmad Posted December 26, 2013 Author Report Posted December 26, 2013 TimWood - I do have a dust collector. I am wondering whether you are wondering whether I could use this to capture sanding dust. I have thought about this, but have not tried it for a few reasons: the shop setup would make it a little difficult; the dust collector is absolutely maxed out in current setup, often with two users; and finally, I thought I read somewhere that the airflow from a dust collector is different from the type used for a downdraft table (I could be completely wrong about this...). I guess a better way to have posted originally would have been to ask how people manage the fine dust from sanding...I guess the dream answer would be to convert to Festool sanders with integrated dust systems. Alas, the budget, and more importantly, the second shop user, would not allow this. thanks for the reply. Quote
tim0625 Posted December 26, 2013 Report Posted December 26, 2013 Dust collection depends on suction and a certain amount of velocity to keep the line from getting clogged with chips or dust that settles in the lines along the way to the collector. Having said that, DC for a downdraft table would work. I've been toying with it for a couple years - so I've not actually done it but i believe it will work. I look at the 4" line collecting the dust and the 3/4 downdraft/ dog holes in a bench and calculate the areas of each. I haven't recently figured the # of 3/4 holes needed but I believe you could pretty much equal the two or go with more holes (more area than the 4" collection hose) and it would provide good downdraft and good velocity through the 4" line. The other thing I've contemplated is using a squirrel cage out of a HVAC system. I have a few of these and think that would work too. A woodworker working mostly with traditional hand tools may not like treating a bench like this but I am a hybrid woodworker who has limited space (21x27 garage). If I can get one station to do many things I'm better off. My vision is to have a 30x60 bench that's very sturdy - Christopher Schwarz "Workbenches' book - sturdy, that has a downdraft box build underneath, with 3/4 dog/downdraft holes with a leg vise, and an end vise. It will have adjustable foot length to account for a slightly uneven slab and to adjust to the table saw that sits in a dolly because the bench will also be an out feed table. It will have drawers underneath to maximize space, and will be built out of cost effective lumber like SYP but will have a few other woods like (maybe) padauk, purple heart, blood wood and/or walnut for accents. Reality starts with vision....I have the vision but now I have to walk by and say 'no' to my new mistress to get to the shop....my new 19' center console boat that LOVES to go to Winyah Bay and catch fish!!! Quote
dwacker Posted December 26, 2013 Report Posted December 26, 2013 If you have ever used a real down draft table you will understand there is quite a difference. You have to decide what it is you are trying to accomplish and what it is you are sanding. For small objects DIY solutions may be an option. For larger things like chairs you would want much more. The further from the table surface you work the more you need. Quote
tim0625 Posted December 26, 2013 Report Posted December 26, 2013 That's understood....the farther you are away from the collection points you are when you create the dust, the greater the flow has to be to collect the dust. The ultimate dust (not chips....dust) collection in this case looks like a combination down draft table and commercial range hood over a stove that would hang over the bench. When you sand something, it collected at the work surface or from above the work. Hey, if a range hood removes airborne particles like smoke, it would do the same for airborne dust. It would be high volume air flow and would remove a lot of air from the shop if not filtered and vented back into the shop. It's some of the same type of concept that some of the guys have here for their chop saw. Its a 3 sided type of enclosure that corrals and collects the dust. The concept I'm floating (pun intended) is doing it from the work surface as well as from overhead. Quote
dwacker Posted December 26, 2013 Report Posted December 26, 2013 It takes a lot of cfm for a down draft table to work and depending on the work you do you may want a little or a whole bunch. When I had my warehouse shop I had three Dynabrade tables and they are not top of the line tables IIRC about 3000 cfm at the table each. When hand sanding cabinet doors if you stood a door on end and there was any draft the tables would not pull down the dust. The filters plug very quickly and rely on pre filters to keep the fine filters clean. The real key is the vacuums and sanders. I would concentrate more on your sanders and vacuums and worry about the tables last. Tables are really just to clean the air not to collect dust from sanding. Quote
Alan Bienlein Posted December 26, 2013 Report Posted December 26, 2013 You can do what I did and build one. I have about $20 invested in mine when I bought the switch for the furnace fan and the filters. Everything else was either reused from the old out feed table or I had gotten for free. The only other cost was the four casters and they where purchased when I built my first out feed table. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.