Recommended Posts

Posted

I'm going to put a cyclone in my new shop and finally retire my HF DC (it just won't die). I've been doing a lot of searching and it pretty much seems that anyone that has a cyclone loves it no matter what brand. I've decided my choice will be between the Grizzly G0441 and the ClearVue 1800. The Grizzly is on sale and currently $1500 delivered and CV $2100 once you add the electrical box with remote, filter clean out box, hanging brackets, and shipping. For those prices you get the 55 gallon drum with the Grizzly and none with the CV.

 

Now I know the CV has a better American motor and better filters but I plan on putting the cyclone in its own room. So in doing that does the filter matter that much? I plan on running 6" main lines in my one-man hobby shop and will probably only need one blast gate open at a time. Is there anything else I'm missing here? I own several Grizzly machines and have been happy with them and I've heard good things about ClearVue, but $600 is money that could be used elsewhere in my new shop. 

 

What do you guys think? Let me know if I'm missing anything in evaluating the 2 cyclones.

Posted

I have the 2 hp version of the grizzly cyclone (G0440).  I would have bought the 3hp unit but my ceiling height is under 9 feet.  The 3hp unit takes just over 9 feet once assembled and in position.  Note that the unit is assembled on the ground and then tipped into position.  This requires an extra couple of inches to clear.  How high is your ceiling?  Also, make sure the room you are putting it in is at least 10 feet long. 

 

I also appreciate the shorter drum.  It is easier to empty since I can shovel most of the dust then tip it up to get the last bit out.  I couldn't lift the 55 gallon drum.

 

I don't know about the CV system as far as size  is concerned.

Posted

I've had the G0441 for about 18 months and It really sucks! If you turn it on with our any pipe it could latterly pull your arm in. My longest run is about 36' to my table saw and it has no problems pulling the saw dust out even though I don't have the most efficient run to it. I forget to close my gates and have not noticed any drop off with 3-4 open at a time. I'm using 6" steel pipe I bought from Penn State. They also did my layout (for free since I got the pipe from them). If you've never assembled a steel pipe set up you might want to look into this as there are quite a few pieces that are not necessarily intuitive that you need to order. Assembly is pretty straight foreword and Mike M is right that you need a couple extra inches to tilt it up, which is not a one man job. All of the weight is in the motor and I swear the thing weighs a lot more than they advertise. My wife walked into my shop when we where in the middle of this and I made her leave before she freaked out watching the process! The unit is very well built with heavy gage steel, the stand might appear unstable when you assemble it but once its in place the sucker doesn't move. Mine isn't bolted to the floor and has not moved at all. You can also buy extra remote controls for about $20.00 and I have a few laying around the shop for convenience. The 55 gallon drum holds a lot of saw dust which saves you from having to empty it a lot, on the other hand 55 gallons of sawdust is heavy and can be tough to move even with the heavy duty bags. One last thing to note is that the steel pipe (even from a discounter like Penn State) is expensive. The pipe for my layout (40x40) was about $500 more than the dust collector with the most expensive parts being the wyes.

Posted

I don't own either of the machines, but in my opinion the three most important things to look at when comparing dust collectors is Cfm , filter area, and filter efficency. After a quick check this is what I found.

 

G0441

===========

1,654 CFM  (http://cdn0.grizzly.com/specsheets/g0441_as.pdf)

Filter surface area: 113 sq. ft.

Filter: 99.9% efficiency captures 0.2-2 micron dust particles

 

cv1800 

===========

1,442 CFM (http://www.sawmillcreek.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=262865&d=1369258159)

12.75" OD x 34" x 8.4" ID (300 sq. ft.) (Nano filters)

Efficiency: 99.999% at .5 micron (Nano filters)

 

In my opinion  the cv1800 is better, because  while it has a little less cfm,  it has almost 3 times as much filter surface area, and the filters are more efficient. The extra surface area will mean the cfm won't fall off as fast between cleanings. It sounds like a trivial thing, but it can have drastic effects of the ability of the machine to collect dust.

Posted

 If the CV1800 is in your price range, it's a no-brainer. As far as I'm concerned, it's the last dust collector I'll ever need to buy.

 

I thought hard about saving $500 or $1000 by going with something smaller or more "appropriately scaled" to my small shop, but long term, this seems like the best option.

 

It fits under an 8' ceiling, and the footprint is tiny. It only takes up 2'x3' of floor space. There's a tube coming out of the top of the cyclone that extends that another 18", but the tube is over your head. You can also pick where and how the tube comes out, and rotate the cyclone to optimize its position for your space--I cram the CV1800 into an otherwise useless corner of my oddly-shaped small shop. No other full-sized cyclone would fit there without compromises.

 

The grizzly is 60x38"--over twice the footprint.

 

The 5hp motor in the CV1800 will actually produce better airflow than the 3hp grizzly, despite the "lower" CFM rating. The grizzly has its CFM measured at its unrestricted 8" port. The CV1800 is measured at its 6" port. An 8" port has 1.7x more cross-sectional area. The numbers can't be compared directly.

 

As to your extra room, the filter matters unless that room is sealed off from your house/shop and is venting to the outdoors somehow. If it's sharing air with your home, then the fact that it's in another room is irrelevant for everything but noise. Remember--1442cfm is being sucked from your shop into that room. The air entering the room needs to go somewhere. If it's in a closet, it's going to end up back in your house. Also, the increased surface area of the Wynn Nano filter will improve the airflow.

 

The CV1800 ships in a bunch of UPS boxes that are easy to handle and come quickly and easily. The assembly is straightforward and the design makes immediate sense. Most of the parts can be easily re-ordered from their website if you break something. The construction of the device is really simple and I have no concerns about my long term ability to repair it or fabricate replacement bits if needed. I can't say the same about most taiwan-made stuff like the grizzly that I've encountered.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 65 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined