Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

The $350 Dust Collector Challenge

Featured Replies

Ok, pretty much a newb in the the forum so if I post in wrong area, my apologies.

I recently asked Marc, Matt, and Shannon about recommendations for next steps in upgrading my garage/shop. The resounding recommendation was dust collection. As I was hoping.

Here is the challenge. I have a budget of $350 and of course, like everyone else, limited shop space. The question is, can I get "adequate" dust collection or at least a really good start on a dust collection system in that budget? Currently, my only solution is the poor rigid 6HP Shop Vac. Here are the specs on my two car garage shop.



  • Large open area in the middle with most tools on the walls.
  • Router table on casters.
  • table saw on casters.
  • cabinet with compound miter saw and drill press.
  • general purpose workbench.
  • mobile workbench with 12" planer, Benchtop bandsaw, benchtop belt disk sander

I'm looking for a DC that I can mount on the wall and takes up a small amount of space. I'm ok with running conduit, pipe, etc around the 2 car garage as needed. I've been eyeing the rockler DC that runs about $200 but have noticed some Jets, ShopFox, and Delta that is in the "comparable" price range.

Here is the list of DC's that I've been looking at but have yet to pull the trigger.


25344-03-80.jpg

$219 - Rockler Wallmount Dust Collector


419yZZD9f6L._AA160_.jpg

$199 - Jet DC-500 Dust Collector


41%2Bb9fiPpwL._AA160_.jpg

$319 - Shop Fox W1727

You can do better for less, if your willing to put some sweat equity into it. I made mine for under $200 and that includes the 3 micron bag from grizzly. I would be willing to bet that it will out perform anything on your list.

http://www.dans-hobbies.com/2008/07/12/shop-made-dust-collector/

Another possibility if you are willing to part with the space, is the 2hp harbor freight unit ($160 on sale with coupon), with a Thein baffle, and a canister.

these threads might be of interest to you:

I got this dust collector for $139 with a coupon in this month's Wood magazine. I plan to add a separator like dan's and some hoses. Probably get the Wynn filter, still well below $350.

+1 to Dan's suggestion (edit: and SignWave to who posted while I typed :)). I have the HF DC with Wynn canister filter on it. That would be $280-300 depending on the DC sale (happens often). Of your current tools, only the planer is a dust devil really needing a great deal of DC but you'll have a lot of room to grow. A friend of mine said "that DC could suck the butt off a cat". While I don't totally understand that image, I think it's pretty positive.

  • Author

+1 to Dan's suggestion (edit: and SignWave to who posted while I typed :)). I have the HF DC with Wynn canister filter on it. That would be $280-300 depending on the DC sale (happens often). Of your current tools, only the planer is a dust devil really needing a great deal of DC but you'll have a lot of room to grow. A friend of mine said "that DC could suck the butt off a cat". While I don't totally understand that image, I think it's pretty positive.

Ok, the cat comment is a keeper. :) funny stuff.

Chandler, AZ? I'm across the street in Gilbert.

  • Author

You can do better for less, if your willing to put some sweat equity into it. I made mine for under $200 and that includes the 3 micron bag from grizzly. I would be willing to bet that it will out perform anything on your list.

http://www.dans-hobbies.com/2008/07/12/shop-made-dust-collector/

Another possibility if you are willing to part with the space, is the 2hp harbor freight unit ($160 on sale with coupon), with a Thein baffle, and a canister.

these threads might be of interest to you:

Yea, I've been kicking around doing my own, sweat equity, etc. I got so many other projects and stuff going on, Part of me just wants to buy a system for plug and play. Dont get me wrong, I love the DIY. I just dont know if I wanna invest the time in it when I got other items on the list. Just kinda wanna get something, get it up and running, and get on to other stuff.

under 350 in a garage shop absolutely. check out my setup its definitely simplistic but does the job in a 2 car garage.

  • Author

under 350 in a garage shop absolutely. check out my setup its definitely simplistic but does the job in a 2 car garage.

Alright! Alright! Alright!!!

Ok, my frugal DIY nature is kicking in. I wanted to go plug and play with a DC but yes, you guys are right, I need to say true to my build it yourself roots.

Today I was pondering how to use the HF 2HP DC system. The biggest constraint is space. I have absolutely NO wallspace or a nook and cranny to put it in. I do have a couple of options though. I live in a subdivision that has an association. So we are limited on what we can and cant do to the exterior of our homes. I was looking at my garage in the backyard and I do have a small space behind the garage next to the house that I could possibly put the DC outside and enclose it, (with proper ventilation and access for emptying) I live in a 2 story so I could even elevate a platform to about waist height to make emptying the bag easier with an access panel. The space is next to our AC condenser unit so I power is available outside. It would be simple 4" pipe run up the side of the house and then punch into the garage and run around the ceiling as needed. (will have to address any 90 degree turns though to keep from losing CFM)

Main thing I need to know is, what is the footprint of the HF 2hp DC at its widest and longest points? Height isn't a problem.

I looked at HF and their product manual and of course, its not in there.

Other than ventilation for air flow out of the DC, anybody got any good advice on enclosing a DC that is installed outside?

I think if I were putting it outside, I really wouldn't care much about its dimensions since I'd use the impeller and the collar on the dust bag and pretty much ignore the rest (keep it in case you sell it or want to mount it). Even the collar could be eliminated. Make a Thein baffle and insert it before the impeller and vent the impeller exhaust directly into the upper filter bag; you'd only have the dust bin for the baffle to empty. Mine would have been outside long ago if it wasn't that "outside" for me is the other side of the garage and I don't want that much pipe eating up the cfm.

I think if I were putting it outside, I really wouldn't care much about its dimensions since I'd use the impeller and the collar on the dust bag and pretty much ignore the rest (keep it in case you sell it or want to mount it). Even the collar could be eliminated. Make a Thein baffle and insert it before the impeller and vent the impeller exhaust directly into the upper filter bag; you'd only have the dust bin for the baffle to empty. Mine would have been outside long ago if it wasn't that "outside" for me is the other side of the garage and I don't want that much pipe eating up the cfm.

agree, you probably don't need it fully assembled if enclosed outside. to answer your questions the dimensions fully assembled with movable base are:

29" wide - this is due to the Y pipe fitting on the impeller assembly sticking out passed the base

40" deep

80" tall

  • Author

I think if I were putting it outside, I really wouldn't care much about its dimensions since I'd use the impeller and the collar on the dust bag and pretty much ignore the rest (keep it in case you sell it or want to mount it). Even the collar could be eliminated. Make a Thein baffle and insert it before the impeller and vent the impeller exhaust directly into the upper filter bag; you'd only have the dust bin for the baffle to empty. Mine would have been outside long ago if it wasn't that "outside" for me is the other side of the garage and I don't want that much pipe eating up the cfm.

Ok Paul. I'm gonna have to come over sometime and see your setup.

The reason the dimensions are important is I have a 20" space between the wall and the AC Compressor Unit that I could put it.

For those with the Wynn cannister do you guys recommend their 80/20 paper one that's $105 or the more expensive one? I hadn't even known about it until seeing it here, and have the HF. I'm interesting in upgrading to the filter, just trying to figure out if that one is the best bang for the buck.

I spoke with their customer support people and they recommended the washable filter ($150 at the time). I like it because I do hose it down sometimes and that cleans it up in no time and makes a big difference in airflow if it got a bit caked in there. They have a very fine filter; they said it will block faster if you ever get the DC too full where much more dust is flying into the canister. Give them a call... you have to for placing an order anyway... the Internets are kinda beyond them, frankly. At least I'd buy the washable one again.

I have the 1 HP Grizzly with the better bag on it. That goes to a dust collector separator on top of a trash can; the big chips get dumped here. That goes to a Rockler dust-right expandable hose. The dust collector stays put, and the hose moves with me.

Collector:

$150 http://www.grizzly.com/products/1-HP-Dust-Collector/G8027

Better Bag:

$15 http://www.grizzly.com/products/14-5-x-23-3-0-Micron-Bag-for-G1032-G8027/G5559

Hose between collector and separator:

$15 http://www.grizzly.com/products/4-x-10-Flexible-Hose/G1536

Separator lid:

$25 http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?page=1515&filter=dust%20collector

Trash can:

$15 at Home Depot, $5 for foam insulation tape to make a better seal

Expandable Hose:

$40 http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?page=21316

Grand total: $260. You probably want something between the expandable hose and separator for stability, but you don't need anything there. If I had another $90 to spend, I'd probably get the 1.5 HP Grizzly instead of the 1.0.

http://www.grizzly.com/products/1-1-2-HP-Dust-Collector-with-New-Impeller/G1028Z2

Separator lid:

$25 http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?page=1515&filter=dust%20collector

Trash can:

$15 at Home Depot, $5 for foam insulation tape to make a better seal

Like you, I pre-separate, I use the Trash Can Cyclone lid (http://www.woodcraft.com/Product/2004310/8981/Trash-Can-Cyclone-Lid.aspx)

Only problem I had was I put it on a metal trash can, and the suction was so good it crumpled it like a tin can! So I needed another $15 or so of angle iron, half an hour wtih a hammer to bash it back out and rib the trash can :P.

The pre-separators are a must I'd say. I've only emptied the dust collector bag twice since I've had it, but emptied the trash can a good twenty times or more.

all i have to say is craigslist. i got a great deal on my d.c. with lots of fittings, rigid pipe, and flex hose. just find your closest city and search the for sale on the home page for dust collector. you're bound to find something. it took me about a month of looking but well worth it.

Like you, I pre-separate, I use the Trash Can Cyclone lid (http://www.woodcraft...yclone-Lid.aspx)

Only problem I had was I put it on a metal trash can, and the suction was so good it crumpled it like a tin can! So I needed another $15 or so of angle iron, half an hour wtih a hammer to bash it back out and rib the trash can :P.

The pre-separators are a must I'd say. I've only emptied the dust collector bag twice since I've had it, but emptied the trash can a good twenty times or more.

I went without the pre-separator for a year. Every time I hooked up the planer, I'd jam the dust collector twice per board, and fill the bag repeatedly. After putting the separator on, I toss a trash bag in the can, fill it up, and never lose power. It's absolutely the best $40 upgrade *ever*.

coupl'a' things.

Handy Magazine had an article on building a tool cabinet under the eaves of your roof, so you can put the "gardening tools" away without going back to the garage. I forget which issue it was in, but it was this year. (Haven't received an issue in a couple of months, so I think it was May/June area.)

You can find the Harbor Freight DC system indirectly, but it takes for freakin' ever. I just go with the short-cut, and enter it in the search box.

I've heard of people removing the plastic casters on HF DC system, and going with the 2 or 3 inch casters, purchased at the same time, just for easier moving and peace of mind. (Thinking about it myself...)

If you vent the DC outside, remember to put inflow air back into the shop.

Why do we park in a drive way but drive on a park way?

Sleep is not over-rated.

does anybody else have cleanout plugs installed on their DC line? I've kicked around installing one on the table saw I have access to, but as I have not yet built the enclosure for the bottom, I haven't put one in yet.

Where is your favorite location to purchase the main lines for the dust collection trunks? My local Lowes does not sell solid wall S&D for some reason; all they carry is the bell end or the leach bed version. (I'm not paying $40 for an 8' section with a bell end, and I think -but I'm not certain- the one with the holes every six inches will not work too well to collect dust. Just a hunch.)

Well, I've said enough. Off to bed, so I can put in another 12 hours tomorrow, then go to a parent meeting for the Scout troop, and then deal with an ADHD child at a Scout meeting... Oh, the fun we have in store!

;)

  • Author

Alright, I kept my eyes open and found the following on Craigslist for $40. Its the Harbor Freight 2HP model with the metal impeller. It is beat up some and needs some cleaning up. The hose between the motor and collector has sun damage and needs replaced. But it runs great and the bags got no holes in them.

Now just to get it all hooked up! :)

Waddya think?

Harbor%20Freight%202hp%20Dust%20Collecter.jpg

nice find, don't forget, already assembled, a plus in my book :)

Very nice; I saw somewhere someone used stovepipe piping to go between the impeller and the separator. Benefit is that it is smooth-surfaced. Since it is on the blower-side, you don't have to worry about the vacuum collapsing it.

Man, and I thought I did well getting a new, already assembled clearance Jet 1 hp DC for $45 laugh.gif

  • Author

Very nice; I saw somewhere someone used stovepipe piping to go between the impeller and the separator. Benefit is that it is smooth-surfaced. Since it is on the blower-side, you don't have to worry about the vacuum collapsing it.

Man, and I thought I did well getting a new, already assembled clearance Jet 1 hp DC for $45 laugh.gif

Dont forget! I still got pipe all this crap! :)

  • Author

Now... just selecting the pipe to run. the challenge of all new dust collector owners. Cheapest pipe you can find that gives you the most cfm over the longest distance. I'm looking at about 20-30' main run now along the ceiling and dropping down to the tools with appropriate couplings and blast gates....

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.