Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

When to start with Watco Danish oil and then put General Finishes Arm R Seal over it?

Featured Replies

First time poster!

I have used a lot of Danish oil (Watco) and I have also used a lot of Arm R Seal - both great products for sure.  What is the rationale for starting with Watco Danish oil and then putting the Arm R seal on after that?  Trust me, I am aware of the benefits of either finish.  I actually prefer the look and close to wood feel of Watco Danish Oil, however, I understand its' short comings in the protection arena.  So, If l want protection, say, for my current build (desk made out of sapele), why don't I just use the Arm R Seal?  Can someone explain to me the benefits of using both?

Thanks so much.

Best,

Ron

maybe the DO will give you a little more color.  But that is the only benefit. 

 

 

 

 

 

Welcome to the forum!

 

Doesn't make any sense to me. The only time Ive done a coat of danish oil first is when I was spraying a waterbourne lacquer over it . That way you get the the awesome colour the DO gives and not the colder look of the waterbourne lacquer. Arm r seal is just fine on it's own.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sent from my SM-N910W8 using Tapatalk

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

There is no benefit.

 

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

 

 

As mike said, use the Watco to add color to the wood or I will use it to pop the grain in figured woods in lieu of dye. Just make sure the Watco has time to fully dried before going over it with ARS. The longer the better.

 

-Ace-

  • Popular Post

Danish oil "natural" and Arm-R-Seal are both amber in color.  There would be a negligible difference between the two if you did test boards side-by-side.  Since you have both available, you might as well try it and compare.  Danish oil would be a waste of time and an unnecessary complication if you plan to top coat with ARS anyway.  Danish oil is great for workbenches.  Otherwise just use a wiping varnish or a pure oil.  Anything in between doesn't make sense IMO.  Danish oil just creates a lot of waiting and an uneven sheen.

If you're talking about using colored versions of DO...there are better ways to color woods.  I've done test boards with DO walnut and blah, ugly.

  • Popular Post

tTvCeaqUVcB6Fw6iqOayZygF-xkgMlSAHGi6gXi5Dmp-0CdwxuW3Jj8JgFbVUAh1flblho0nd-rLmgJhvfn5pPs40dvWOfTQQt9Mc1l4zOSFsb8jR8h5iMvol2UWo1nPPnKS1bVt-setlXP6pTWVXTFmyBEan-1bgxoAq2rR9WSEjKSqyswgtf54iP5rqK2o-JF6t5_Lp5nVE-uQlcl0OpHgoARLt_qrb6eyQXlODOZqLd7d1JeKZbszECmLiBRUdOGk_-xX4JoVItEmJ6xzSJtGZOSuUO_8pIdfCeMI99T4Y12vlcMT4xvbPuhdi22xRheNh3YmZYt5sjgtj0F3jUJ72q_onPSS4q7ojqYOte-XrLEOpyWg_r43ssBuPkiUM6PnrnPkf3MNdDuA7b4Ctw7-OKJ5GgAaQl5ympEBye0-KF_7yHiX_bxPZylEEtrB87p-FIPiRnyBDZygA--WgffZRDgOKJ_tVC9k0gj5cbWJLrAGfMwdFD7NoTDM1CDRzwDIMQfKteccv_enyebujXci-Zn4TY7eB_5cHB6Dkao9zE0Z_4Uwp9B0F_rL5k0MoUgRSk-4KOGyukf1yOzAHguKVE97gTU5OQHeJ7Du367TxZWumg=w1027-h771-no

 

This is a spice chest I made using Watco to pop the figure in flame birch door and drawers (I can't remember what colors the Watco's were, but blended the 2 oils together and a shot or two of shellac over top) Watco is a very good choice to color wood. 

 

-Ace-

18 hours ago, AceHoleInOne said:

This is a spice chest I made using Watco to pop the figure in flame birch door and drawers (I can't remember what colors the Watco's were, but blended the 2 oils together and a shot or two of shellac over top) Watco is a very good choice to color wood. 

 

-Ace-

That's a beautiful piece, man.  We need to see more of your work.

I still hate Danish oil though. :D

1 hour ago, Eric. said:

That's a beautiful piece, man.  We need to see more of your work.

I still hate Danish oil though. :D

ArbHRmOdRbnVLeHJq9LadLPdUBAcawHfawafQLWrNzaezN4CbbNn0HHb-Xys1gXxSQRKQfd4kHrzLD7PRbxNnB_9FeEKMSCWVYpj9V72hA0yB33NLwqfZ9CJU31QuEs_CeD2EDKiPcMNuDThfJKj0kEAWCQCy9RtmIKTOPed4Ks_MGAVdumfeLZV15YntWlYTPGSROc3SSPf7aNIRXQ1FhY9ZapLIUc6lxMgJEQ-rghH34YkzgM40keNNZ-9v25DbMj2xNCeC3XF_VTBxO2m2A1vkXTJLFs8g0h6sUb-t1ICVcLhEC9c3U-S8HSSHcTXrLd6MgKaaqp6po9e9VmW5p7BaR6YaM3rarWSDIKi200rZjibbKFFjIziyXoaN2j8wMYfQTAk4INDNpQjOVgFzn2X6bSpr-skctUTMaMt9ltPN-kzbVuvTrv4WeI22LhtnHEYlH7dgHDI7jvtgQB8f2mAp4Bzgvvt86AHv7RC2tT2_gxnAMU6O2VW5d_SavbaCdkc8cSlTKbLeWJyqZNpjYMPYmLSkO7izpdh-3WZkgmds4nqKkf2KGD80RRMJNBbDUx2vVB49qAeL_JarbNeypvGi11YZ-GoSmz6najnpzA-eWUo2w=w1027-h770-no

8WXJxpsOoiHdBw7XIzGFPW70U6n-4PUxSWVgsi0MSXGfSHvBqRN7su1Z2BdBXawBl_7ToCWNSeHwmEpMVM8cnXVvgQUARdzqGb5kCjvkTIVMmmi2tAyAxDIVisq1pLhgy6EtQe2cv_TL91CSvrRPPPqlRZHVwCkBYKGPx3YXSqbdZ2wmPYJFBQOEJarmdCDMXYQWPjmSsmran-fz4J1LLxx2hlND7vNRnZyZmZDYN2_1y3SgGzXuDcNOiygSJIKSjt_E5nNzQq4FcFpmzZoAyqCYZ6f0uPK88yNXCJQpu_h1UCz6L6GLLJQW8Oh4bcFxTN6IVhCDnxTJZkiMuABMuAYZW-oEqWi0vL92ocDavRUPefQ6wA6Quni9bo_QONEETLS5PgsnjerXiylJXjNAdfqbDdR3DsDVkhAKCa-WLu3obXjhJOwB1LOZ8Y948rygGmN0o6Tr9DacyBuVIGhHKIi1N-fHW4rdYspkhAFeE6UjcwNlBUFoQE7SvKN_l4dz4-o2LT8kxYTD1ZrrDZHktfAmgVIVFOBM72x4ZGkENfqBkw7MY-NPZUTRN5JivViaqBeUrdehQJihhlG85k0lokE_pMCYh9trNyw9GEcg0c90Lw=w578-h770-no

RT4mHkbTLucPYYKwRdDSBtqe66Xsw0dNJqPmcyqYpbiX7bFupVdOgsKkzmkXisUl1Wrn7Ts2RF5jrtPkz-hWZAcLyyUkMr-WH37twVs2ReU-T_w4UZcb-wpgzpEVUqQ_LnTtrpZkMtcPOoMSyS5Y75q4lgKyQeDytyKjwVu6_HPciSFm2FWkMcTBlD8T4OprZ-264z0rX4GGGQMt7eh-5SSVgsRMNcRmMbCLUH7pVFk_v5E7EZaKLWB6q_YjksIDrTJG0niZ3-RRa1jDSnwIqROt6cWk-i-hbRaKp-AYJmyxZ3GHMs_Q1tf1QVpYl7Goyynq--gj3_hw4jpcd7e4QcCnxYId3ks_I3Ev02mbzH--htMddnwMtC1iZXzVXWPaAJhmzgRODni7tBcSV6WUIXohyEFGQ-hcEt_YSH090TcDmogmTWu-iLRui2OojlUfgEf9q6W4rsozv24kCXluT5ahrLUS-Q7i4wZkIpWoaWG8aaqwONwTQKj8H3bohM2scP8uNS5pOhd9laejXA2X2LLgA_oX-nxRKcJnwD_Tyr8T2BVEntk3f06vx3Y36bzf0XA4Orhe-dPNczu5BEVwxDmA-2PEi2FzE0WdiJ-Utc7xSZP4Xg=w1027-h770-no

The top 2 pic's are Watco to pop the figure/add color. Bottom, finished door panel has 2 coats of amber shellac. Still hate the Watco Eric?.....:P

 

-Ace-

6 minutes ago, AceHoleInOne said:

Still hate the Watco Eric?.....:P

I do.  I haven't had good experiences with it as a finish and I don't really color wood ever...but I did some test boards in the past and never found it attractive.  But yours looks good.  Did you use DO on the maple case, too?  Or was that something else?

46 minutes ago, Eric. said:

  Did you use DO on the maple case, too?  Or was that something else?

I used General Finishes RTM water-based system. They are base colors/stains which allow you to mix together to achieve any color you wish. 

-Ace-

I've done that on several pieces I've built because I like the look the DO gives. I give the DO at least two weeks to cure before applying the ARS.

Lately I've switched to Osmo PolyX hard wax oil. It has the penetrating qualities of DO and protection (it's a floor finish) of varnish in a one step process. It's pricey, but a little goes a very long way. The feel of the finished pieces is incredible.

tTvCeaqUVcB6Fw6iqOayZygF-xkgMlSAHGi6gXi5Dmp-0CdwxuW3Jj8JgFbVUAh1flblho0nd-rLmgJhvfn5pPs40dvWOfTQQt9Mc1l4zOSFsb8jR8h5iMvol2UWo1nPPnKS1bVt-setlXP6pTWVXTFmyBEan-1bgxoAq2rR9WSEjKSqyswgtf54iP5rqK2o-JF6t5_Lp5nVE-uQlcl0OpHgoARLt_qrb6eyQXlODOZqLd7d1JeKZbszECmLiBRUdOGk_-xX4JoVItEmJ6xzSJtGZOSuUO_8pIdfCeMI99T4Y12vlcMT4xvbPuhdi22xRheNh3YmZYt5sjgtj0F3jUJ72q_onPSS4q7ojqYOte-XrLEOpyWg_r43ssBuPkiUM6PnrnPkf3MNdDuA7b4Ctw7-OKJ5GgAaQl5ympEBye0-KF_7yHiX_bxPZylEEtrB87p-FIPiRnyBDZygA--WgffZRDgOKJ_tVC9k0gj5cbWJLrAGfMwdFD7NoTDM1CDRzwDIMQfKteccv_enyebujXci-Zn4TY7eB_5cHB6Dkao9zE0Z_4Uwp9B0F_rL5k0MoUgRSk-4KOGyukf1yOzAHguKVE97gTU5OQHeJ7Du367TxZWumg=w1027-h771-no

 

This is a spice chest I made using Watco to pop the figure in flame birch door and drawers (I can't remember what colors the Watco's were, but blended the 2 oils together and a shot or two of shellac over top) Watco is a very good choice to color wood. 

 

-Ace-

 

Beautiful!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.