Onboard Posted August 24, 2011 Report Posted August 24, 2011 Has anyone used these? If so, do they work okay and do they hold their sharpness well? Doesn’t seem like you could re-sharpen them. At the sale price, maybe they are worth it as a disposable item. Looks like you could retire them to opening paint can style lids. Quote
wilburpan Posted August 24, 2011 Report Posted August 24, 2011 I'd use a block plane instead. You can resharpen a block plane blade. To be fair, you could probably sharpen those cornering tools with a slip stone. But I'd still go with a block plane. Quote
mikem Posted August 24, 2011 Report Posted August 24, 2011 I am working hard (and my wallet and wife are screaming) to stop buying "disposable tools." As Wilbur pointed out there probably is a way to sharpen those, but they just don't look well made, and the price further indicates that. Save a bit and invest in a good block plane, you won't regret it. Quote
Onboard Posted August 24, 2011 Author Report Posted August 24, 2011 I guess my attention was caught at the parenthetical comment “(slightly rounded, but not beveled)”. Not to be lazy, but wouldn’t that take at least 3 passes with a block plane to create a “rounded” profile? Also a block plane may not yield as uniform a profile. Maybe I’m overstating the case. Possibly for the woodworker who doesn't "ease" corners much it may be a reasonable investment. Of course they are promoting this tool to fit flush doors or shutters. That would make it more of a specialized tool and may not be useful for the more general application. Besides, not having used this tool I may not like the profile it creates anyway. What was I thinking! Thanks for the replies. Quote
wilburpan Posted August 24, 2011 Report Posted August 24, 2011 You do need at least three passes. The way I've done this is to make the first pass at 45º, the second on one side leaning the plane about halfway over, and the third leaning the plane the other way. This adds maybe about 45 seconds to a whole minute to the process. That's not even enough time to think about taking a bathroom break. The result is surprisingly uniform, and the slight variations really show that your board was worked by hand. If you really wanted uniformity, you'd use a router and a roundover bit. But this is the hand tool area, after all. Next time you're in your shop, grab a board and a block plane, and give it a try. I think you'll be surprised as to how quick and easy this is. Quote
jhl.verona Posted August 24, 2011 Report Posted August 24, 2011 Might be that my brain has cooked completely - still 37°C after almost a week and another week to follow, but this seems to use the 'potato peeler' principle. I'm all in favour of simple tools, which must be why I like the card scraper so much. I'd try it out - just as a fun experiment if nothing else. I am beginning to believe that a lot of craftsmen, er craftspersons, make their own tools to 'scratch an itch', so if it gives even half decent results, you can soon make something better yourself. Here's a different example from an old mitre saw blade (I believe): http://www.arcadileg...php?f=16&t=8888 Wilbur is right too. Only I can easily take a quarter of an hour, and the result is always 'unique'. But that's what it's all about, isn't it? Which ever way you go, enjoy yourself. John Quote
Onboard Posted August 24, 2011 Author Report Posted August 24, 2011 You do need at least three passes. The way I've done this is to make the first pass at 45º, the second on one side leaning the plane about halfway over, and the third leaning the plane the other way. This adds maybe about 45 seconds to a whole minute to the process. That's not even enough time to think about taking a bathroom break. The result is surprisingly uniform, and the slight variations really show that your board was worked by hand. If you really wanted uniformity, you'd use a router and a roundover bit. But this is the hand tool area, after all. Next time you're in your shop, grab a board and a block plane, and give it a try. I think you'll be surprised as to how quick and easy this is. Sage advice Wilbur! I like it. Quote
Onboard Posted August 24, 2011 Author Report Posted August 24, 2011 Might be that my brain has cooked completely - still 37°C after almost a week and another week to follow, but this seems to use the 'potato peeler' principle. I'm all in favour of simple tools, which must be why I like the card scraper so much. I'd try it out - just as a fun experiment if nothing else. I am beginning to believe that a lot of craftsmen, er craftspersons, make their own tools to 'scratch an itch', so if it gives even half decent results, you can soon make something better yourself. Here's a different example from an old mitre saw blade (I believe): http://www.arcadileg...php?f=16&t=8888 Wilbur is right too. Only I can easily take a quarter of an hour, and the result is always 'unique'. But that's what it's all about, isn't it? Which ever way you go, enjoy yourself. John I like your spirit John! I do like the idea of one pass, but I guess I'm now under the advisement of Wilbur Pan. Those are two very awesome planes. Very resourceful use of a saw blade. When will you be building a pair John? Quote
HoboMonk Posted August 25, 2011 Report Posted August 25, 2011 I use "these" tools frequently and they are easy to sharpen for their particular task. Just use a dowel of the appropriate size and wrap it with some fine grit abrasive paper. Mine have been in use for about six years. Here's a set from Lee Valley that includes a sharpening thingie. Here's a fancier version, also from LV. I also use one of these chamfer planes. Quote
Darnell Hagen Posted August 25, 2011 Report Posted August 25, 2011 I've got a Veritas set, it was one of my first tools, and is one of my least used. I've found them to be prone to tearout and very sensitive to grain direction. I prefer a flat champher anyway, from a sanding block or plane. Quote
HoboMonk Posted August 25, 2011 Report Posted August 25, 2011 As stated, I use these quite often with good results. Here's some tips on proper use from Lee Valley: "Cornering tools serve the same purpose as molding planes and should be similarly used. To avoid a rough finish, always cut with the grain. Since, unlike a molding plane, you can cut on either a push or pull stroke, the tools are fast and very easy to use. A quick check on grain orientation is all that is needed before you start. Whenever possible, cut on the pull stroke to avoid the risk of a splinter in your hand. Cut with the grain. As you get accustomed to using these tools, you will find them to be among the most versatile tools in your shop, capable of fine work, even on end grain when well sharpened. Sharpening Cornering Tools The enclosed sharpening jig was specifically designed as a sharpening system for the cornering tools. It can also be used, however, to sharpen other single-radius cutting blades whose radii match one of the four sizes of our cornering tools. The sharpening jig has five radii as shown. It comes with 600 grit silicon carbide coated paper. The paper is wrapped around the jig and held in position with the included block. Basic sharpening is best done by sharpening the inside radius at each end of a tool. Rub the tool back and forth along the abrasive-covered sharpening jig until a keen edge is achieved. Maintain these angles when you sharpen. Touching up the grooved side is usually not necessary. If you do so, maintain the cutting angles. As the diagram shows, the cutting angles differ by 15°. Maintain this geometry as you sharpen. Reducing these angles will reduce the depth of penetration of the tool. As a final step on either side, use a scrap of leather (shaped to fit) with a good honing compound. Hint: When rounding an edge, it is best to first ease the edge with the next smallest diameter. This reduces the thickness of the shaving of your finishing cut and leaves a smoother surface. " Quote
Onboard Posted August 25, 2011 Author Report Posted August 25, 2011 I've got a Veritas set, it was one of my first tools, and is one of my least used. I've found them to be prone to tearout and very sensitive to grain direction. I prefer a flat champher anyway, from a sanding block or plane. Darnell, I can certainly see why this has become one of your least used tools after you said “I've found them to be prone to tearout and very sensitive to grain direction.” It would also become my least used tool if I had the same experience. As stated, I use these quite often with good results. Here's some tips on proper use from Lee Valley: HoboMonk, thank you for the valuable information on the use and sharpening of the cornering tool. It seems that you have had a different experience than Darnell. I certainly believe Darnell’s description of his experience with the rounding tool. That is one thing I like about a forum. If enough people reply you can get to see if everyone (or most everyone) had a similar experience or not. If the experiences are mixed then you have to ask what are the individuals, who are having negative results, doing differently than those who are experiencing positive results. I think for $5.79 it would certainly be worth buying a cornering tool set and finding out what my experience would be. If I find I like it, and since Lee Valley sells the sharpening tool separately for $7.50, I could purchase one of those also and be set for quite awhile. The cornering tool would be a simple and nice efficiency in the shop if all goes well. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.