Recommended Posts

Posted

So the other dust collection question got me thinking about my own shop and my new needs, I just bought a house and upgraded to a 2 car sizes shop from a single car shop! I dont know what protical is in a fourm so I figure I'll ask a new question rather than replying to Dust Collection 101.

I'm trying to figure out if an older Grizzly 2hp on 220v will pull enough spaning about 30 or so feet from one corner to the other coner of my shop with 4 in duct. The duct will be attached to the ceiling making the straightest shot possible. The info ive found suggests that a 1 1/2 hp machine pulling 1100 CFM will do just about do a 40ft run. If thats the case I would assume a 2hp would do what I'm looking for.

I know everyone is mentioning a book but the C list add is up right now and I cant pass the deal up waiting for a book on amazon.. Are there any online resources out there you know of?

Thanks gang!

Posted

I have an older 2hp dc and its hooked up to a straight run of 30 ft pvc. At the far end its hooked up to my bandsaw. It has 3 ys that split off to other machines. It works great and has a very strong pull. Just make sure to limit 90 degree bends and use y's with blast gate at all the intersections. How much is the grizzly on cl?

post-5469-0-85245200-1345677229_thumb.jp

Posted

I buy alot of my tools used through cl and then upgrade to the next level when another deal comes around.

Almost always tools hold their value and I have no problem selling them to finace the next deal. I would go for the dc on cl before someone else gets it. It will certainly meet your needs until you add more drops

then sell it and upgrade. Maybe it will meet your needs and you will never have to sell it.

Posted

Thanks robjeffking, I feel the same way. My wife bought me a Shop Line Jet DC off c list last year for my birthday. I think it pulls just under 600 CFM. The tool worked well on a 15ft line with my table saw right next to the machine and bandsaw at the end of it. She got it for 75 dollars from a guy who made pens, i think i can sell it for about the same $$.

I think i need to get savy with some elecitrical now.

Posted

My understanding of DCs is limited, so a question for the floor - would putting the DC in the middle of the room (assuming that was practical) be a good idea? After, the distances for the straight runs would be shortest and span out like the spokes on wheel.

Posted

I assume that would be a really good way of doing it. Unforintlly in a 20tfx24ft building space is somewhat limited. Id really like to see some of the other guys working out of a 2 car shop have things set up.

Posted

Im having trouble grasping the dc in the middle of the room. Im guesing you would disconnect it from 1 spoke rotate and hook up to another spoke? Thats gonna be alot of pipe. To keep the circulation strong

in my system (6 tools) each of my 3 drops service 2 machines that share dc hose via quick connects sold through rockler.

Posted

If you can remove the Y adapter and go with the single 5 or 6 inch line at the impeller you will gain quite a bit more suction in terms of CFM. Advertised CFMs are rarely the actual, real-world, full performance capacity. That is, an advertised 1100 CFM is more likely half that capacity in actual use. The more you reduce hose diameters from the machine to the DC impeller the more you reduce CFM capacity.

Having a two or three-line Y adapter at the impeller may be a convenient feature, but the trade off is that it reduces CFM capacity significantly. The better solution is to confine the reduction (reducer) at the machine rather than at the DC impeller. In other words, You want to keep your lines as large as you can from the DC to machine - don't reduce at the DC, reduce at the machine.

I hope that makes sense... If not, ask away.

Posted

Time to sell the Old Jet Shopline!

Pagel, that makes a lot of sense.I'll have to look into investing into some 6 in pipe and tube I have noticed in the Grizzly catalog they specify a larger pipe as a main line and reduces to a 4 or 3 at the Y going to the tool in a straight run. I'll have to look into that for future dollar locations. I currently have enough 4 inch pipe at home to make cover the span i need to do. luckly its just me in the shop and will only be running one tool at a time.

Pretty stoked on my new buy! Thanks for the assistance.

Posted
I'm trying to figure out if an older Grizzly 2hp on 220v will pull enough spaning about 30 or so feet from one corner to the other coner of my shop with 4 in duct. The duct will be attached to the ceiling making the straightest shot possible.

I gave a similar but longer response about this in the DC 101 thread...which is, it depends on what you consider adequate DC. If your 30 foot run goes to a jointer or planer and you want it to pull the huge pile of shavings they create, then yes, it will probably do that. But if you're running it to a table saw and you expect it to extract the fine dust that it throws everywhere, no, it probably won't. A 2HP unit just doesn't have the ability to do that, at least in my experience.

CFM is a function of DC power and pipe size. You can use 6 inch pipe instead of 4 inch to increase your CFM, but keep in mind that for every inch you increase the pipe size, you lose velocity, which is what clears the bigger chips and shavings. So it's possible (probable) that you'll start getting clogs, especially in your verticals and wyes, if your pipe size exceeds the capacity of the DC. When talking about blowers smaller than, let's say 3HP, you're pretty much forced to design your system with "chip" collection as the goal instead of "dust" collection.

But since you're in a garage shop like I am, you can do what I do and open all the doors and windows, put on a respirator, and be happy to watch the bulk of the mess be sucked away as you work. Then at the end of the day I get my backpack blower out and blow all the fine dust into the driveway and all over my neighbor's cars. :D

Posted

I gave a similar but longer response about this in the DC 101 thread...which is, it depends on what you consider adequate DC. If your 30 foot run goes to a jointer or planer and you want it to pull the huge pile of shavings they create, then yes, it will probably do that. But if you're running it to a table saw and you expect it to extract the fine dust that it throws everywhere, no, it probably won't. A 2HP unit just doesn't have the ability to do that, at least in my experience.

CFM is a function of DC power and pipe size. You can use 6 inch pipe instead of 4 inch to increase your CFM, but keep in mind that for every inch you increase the pipe size, you lose velocity, which is what clears the bigger chips and shavings. So it's possible (probable) that you'll start getting clogs, especially in your verticals and wyes, if your pipe size exceeds the capacity of the DC. When talking about blowers smaller than, let's say 3HP, you're pretty much forced to design your system with "chip" collection as the goal instead of "dust" collection.

But since you're in a garage shop like I am, you can do what I do and open all the doors and windows, put on a respirator, and be happy to watch the bulk of the mess be sucked away as you work. Then at the end of the day I get my backpack blower out and blow all the fine dust into the driveway and all over my neighbor's cars. :D

My understanding is that one needs a true 800 CFM to collect fine and large dust at the source. A high quality, 1.5 HP DC can achieve this. You need to keep your ONE run short (usually a short section of smooth walled flex hose) and wheel the collector to all your machines as you use them, 1 by 1. Use the largest hose your collector will accept (usually 5 or 6 inch) and modify your machine ports to receive the larger hose.

Part of the DC problem is that companies test their collectors without static pressure (resistance). This gives false CFM numbers. My collector is rated for 1200 CFM by Delta, but in indpependent testing, it comes it lower when static pressure is introduced (whch basically means when you want to collect dust through a hose. Do you know anyone who buys a collector, and doesn't use hose?!?)

Here is an excerpt from Bill's site:

The bottom line comes out the same for almost all who have normal hobbyist machines. If you have larger professional units, then you need to do the work.


  • For those who move a dust collector from machine to machine they can get buy with a good quality 1.5 hp dust collector that turns at least an 11" impeller.

Personally, I don't mind wheeling my DC around, as most of my mashines are clustered. I will, someday, buy a large cyclone and pipe the shop. But until I can afford a high quality cyclone machine, wire 220 service, and pipe the shop in 6 inch pipe, I will wheel my 1.5 DC around.

If my understanding is incorrect, I hope someone with more experience than myself will correct me.

Posted

As for putting the DC in the center of the shop, you've just created more cost for yourself trying to get ducts laid to the corners. It's actually easier to do one run, and maybe a bend to go around a corner.

Sure, the individual runs are shorter. But now you have more of them.

Laying out a shop for workpiece flow sometimes feels easier than laying out the shop with duct work in mind.

(I do need to add a caveat to this: I do a lot with theory. My shop is small enough I can get away with a modified house vacuum and a Dust Deputy.)

Posted

Personally, I don't mind wheeling my DC around, as most of my mashines are clustered. I will, someday, buy a large cyclone and pipe the shop. But until I can afford a high quality cyclone machine, wire 220 service, and pipe the shop in 6 inch pipe, I will wheel my 1.5 DC around.

If my understanding is incorrect, I hope someone with more experience than myself will correct me.

Yep, I agree with you. If I hooked my 2HP DC directly to my tools with a really short run I'm confident it would clear a whole lot more dust than it does now. But it sounds like the OP was wanting a stationary system, in which case you have to either get a much larger unit or settle for mediocre dust collection. I opted for the latter because I refuse to take the time and inconvenience to move the DC around the shop from one tool to another. :)

Posted

I've got a 600 cfm collector now, it was hooked up to a 15 ft run of pipe to my band saw/ridgid planner. It pulled the chips from my planner well. I think ANYTHING will be an improvement. For now I can keep my respirator on or open the garage door and stick the box fan in the window.

While laying in bed last night not sleeping I was able to revamp where the DC will sit so it will only be 15 feet of duct work to 2 drop downs, they will have blast gates. the branches will have Ys rather than Ts. the duct will be 4 in smooth PVC. (in the future i'll upgrade to 6in main line, i currently own the 4 in material)

It will also cut down on cost of 12/3 wire from the main box. really pumped on how this will come together!

My next purchase will be a 200 dollar air filter, looking at the grizz model they have just put out on the summer flyer. Does anyone have any thoughts on an air filter? My space is a 20x24 with 10ft ceilings

Posted

I've got a 600 cfm collector now, it was hooked up to a 15 ft run of pipe to my band saw/ridgid planner. It pulled the chips from my planner well. I think ANYTHING will be an improvement. For now I can keep my respirator on or open the garage door and stick the box fan in the window.

While laying in bed last night not sleeping I was able to revamp where the DC will sit so it will only be 15 feet of duct work to 2 drop downs, they will have blast gates. the branches will have Ys rather than Ts. the duct will be 4 in smooth PVC. (in the future i'll upgrade to 6in main line, i currently own the 4 in material)

It will also cut down on cost of 12/3 wire from the main box. really pumped on how this will come together!

My next purchase will be a 200 dollar air filter, looking at the grizz model they have just put out on the summer flyer. Does anyone have any thoughts on an air filter? My space is a 20x24 with 10ft ceilings

When you say air filter, do you mean an air scrubber or do you mean a cartridge filter for your DC?

I am afraid I cannot comment on air scrubbers, except for what i've read in the magazines. As for cartridge filters, the Wynn is consistently reported as exceptional and affordable. Make sure you share some pics of your shop when it comes together - sounds like it's coming together for you!

Posted

I'm hoping to pick up http://www.grizzly.com/products/Hanging-Air-Filter-3-Speed/G0738 air filter.. That pleated filter for the DC Unit looks pretty sweet too and not that spendy. The DC came with an upgraded felt bag from Grizzly, not sure if its 5 micron or 1 but its defiantly a lot nicer than the one I had on that little Shop Line. I'll take some photos soon. Always feels like there is something else to tweak!

Posted

Having the spare duct laying around alrdy you are in a great position to take a stab at the process and learn

what works best for your shop. If most of your machines are against the wall I would try to keep the ducts about 20-30 inches from the floor. Most tool ports are in that range this will elimnate the need to go up to the ceiling and back down from the dc to the tools. That should give you the best airflow with no 90 degree elbows and the dc in the corner.

Posted

Don't forget blast gates. I've heard putting them right after the Y has the most effect. (Then again, y'all know my setup.... the only Y's I have in my house are from the kids trying to get out of chores.)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 50 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined