DeanJackson Posted August 26, 2012 Report Posted August 26, 2012 So, I have a 5" RO sander from Bosch that cost me about $100. I use it for everything between 80 grit and 320 grit, then tend to hand sand for any higher grits. If I can save time, and/or put less dust in the air, I'm willing to spend the money, at least to a point. Pneumatics are out; they're too loud for my urban shop. What should I be looking at? - Any huge advantage or disadvantage to a 6"? Is the extra size worth the extra weight? - Is the CEROS made from the same Kool-Aid that Festool uses? - Is a set of sanders purchased over time more useful than any one particular upgrade here? Quote
STL Woodguy Posted August 26, 2012 Report Posted August 26, 2012 I think going with a 6" RO sander depends on the work you do, as well as the model we're talking. If I had to work on a lot of time-consuming huge surfaces like table tops, floors and decks on a frequent basis, the 6" would be a godsend. However, when I shopped for a Festool Rotex I felt the 6" was too heavy and the 5" felt better, and spending a little more time to sand large surfaces wouldn't bother me none because I don't have projects like that often. I can't speak for the Mirka Ceros as I don't own one, but I've heard a lot of positive opinions from owners, some saying it's even better than Festool. On the last question, once again, I think it depends on how you like to work. I only own a Rotex 125 as I wanted one sander to do multiple jobs. However, regular RO sanders like Festool's ETS are desired as they work better in the hand (Rotex is better guided with two hands) and preferred for fine/finished sanding, so some people have both a rotary and RO and use whatever the job calls for. Quote
DeanJackson Posted August 26, 2012 Author Report Posted August 26, 2012 I think going with a 6" RO sander depends on the work you do, as well as the model we're talking. If I had to work on a lot of time-consuming huge surfaces like table tops, floors and decks on a frequent basis, the 6" would be a godsend. However, when I shopped for a Festool Rotex I felt the 6" was too heavy and the 5" felt better, and spending a little more time to sand large surfaces wouldn't bother me none because I don't have projects like that often. I can't speak for the Mirka Ceros as I don't own one, but I've heard a lot of positive opinions from owners, some saying it's even better than Festool. On the last question, once again, I think it depends on how you like to work. I only own a Rotex 125 as I wanted one sander to do multiple jobs. However, regular RO sanders like Festool's ETS are desired as they work better in the hand (Rotex is better guided with two hands) and preferred for fine/finished sanding, so some people have both a rotary and RO and use whatever the job calls for. From what I gather on the Festool front, a 150/5 or Rotex 125 would be a decent all-around answer, hand sanding for the final grits. A Rotex 150 + the 150/3 seems the two-sander Festool route. The Ceros seems to be a monstrously powerful variant of the 150/5, which uses Abranet instead of sandpaper? Quote
joelav Posted August 27, 2012 Report Posted August 27, 2012 If dust collection is ultra important to you, Festool is king. It's expensive though, but the extractors are universal for other festool items. If you want sanding performance this is close to Festool for a ton less money, get this: http://www.amazon.com/Milwaukee-6021-21-Random-Sander-collection/dp/B0012RWCF6 It gets rated right behind the festool sanders in a lot of reviews. I own this and hooked to a shop vac, dust collection is acceptable. I actually prefer the 5" to the 6". It really depends on your projects and how you sand. I also have some pneumatic but don't use them often for the reason you mentioned. I try to be as considerate as a neighbor as I can be (but I've still had the cops show up) Some may tell you to ditch the ROS all together and get familiar with scrapers. I have some spring steel and this is something I have thought about trying. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.