Wmacky Posted November 27, 2012 Report Posted November 27, 2012 New guy here! I would like to purchase a Incra miter gauge, but I'm worried it may not work well with my new saw. You see the miter slots on the new saw appear slightly deeper than the 3/8 average. Mine are closer to 7/16" and this caused my stock miter gauge bar to tip slightly foward, and therefore the gauge fence no longer being 90 degress to the table. There appears to be NO fence adjudtment ( to square it to the table surface) on my gauge or any other gauge for that matter. I find this odd as research shows some variation in this miter slot depth. I was able to fix the issue by shimming the slot key at the end of the bar, This raised the nose of the bar up, and squared the fence to the table. BUT, I now would like a Incra gauge. The way the slot "key" is attached to the bar does not allow it to be shimed downward like I did on the stock unit. Is this right? Is there no verticle fence adjustment on the Inca? Will I not be able to use it on this saw? Should I just return the saw? I'd rather not as it's working great otherwise, and will be a real pain to return. Perhaps they would send me a new top? The saw is a R4512 Quote
JerrySats Posted November 27, 2012 Report Posted November 27, 2012 I have a R4511 and the incra SD1000 . No problems with it , I don't know if the miter slots on the R4511 are the same as the R4512 . Quote
robjeffking Posted November 27, 2012 Report Posted November 27, 2012 I have the incra 1000Hd with a 4512 works perfectly I removed the wide tip because of my outfeed table. Im glad I did no more threading it in and out of the miter slot just drop it in and out Quote
Wmacky Posted November 27, 2012 Author Report Posted November 27, 2012 I have the incra 1000Hd with a 4512 works perfectly I removed the wide tip because of my outfeed table. Im glad I did no more threading it in and out of the miter slot just drop it in and out Butdoes your bar tip foward? How deep are your miter slots? Quote
PaulMarcel Posted November 27, 2012 Report Posted November 27, 2012 IIRC, the 1000HD's key is screwed in and entirely optional. I like using it, though. In your case, I'd think you could get a longer screw and put a nylon spacer to get the key to the correct position so you don't have to monkey with the gauge's fence. You'll like that gauge. Quote
Wmacky Posted November 27, 2012 Author Report Posted November 27, 2012 IIRC, the 1000HD's key is screwed in and entirely optional. I like using it, though. In your case, I'd think you could get a longer screw and put a nylon spacer to get the key to the correct position so you don't have to monkey with the gauge's fence. You'll like that gauge. Are you sure? The pics I see show the key mounted to the top of the bar. It would seem that a spacer would raise the key rather than lower it as needed? Quote
robjeffking Posted November 28, 2012 Report Posted November 28, 2012 My 4512 was purchased new 1.5yrs ago and the miter slot is roughly 3/8" deep. The incra rides almost flush with the bottom of the slot(maybe 1/64" gap between bottom of bar to bottom of slot). The gauge rides perfectly flush on top of the table with no side to side rocking. It will tip forward slightly if I intentionally lift up from the rear handle but when your pushing stock thru I have never had an issue. Ill take some pics in the morning if your still unsure. The Incra is a fantastic upgrade from the stock miter gauge after you compare the two side by side youll see a huge difference in the repeatable accurracy. The factory gauge is very sloppy. The key is mounted on top of the bar in a groove so if some reason your slot is deeper than 3/8's just remove it you should have a functioning gauge regardless of miter slot depth. Quote
Wmacky Posted November 28, 2012 Author Report Posted November 28, 2012 My 4512 was purchased new 1.5yrs ago and the miter slot is roughly 3/8" deep. The incra rides almost flush with the bottom of the slot(maybe 1/64th gap between bottom of bar to bottom of slot). The gauge rides perfectly flush on top of the table with no side to side rocking. It will tip forward slightly if I intentionally lift up from the rear handle but when your pushing stock thru I have never had an issue. Ill take some pics in the morning if your still unsure. The Incra is a fantastic upgrade from the stock miter gauge after you compare the two side by side youll see a huge difference in the repeatable accurracy. The factory gauge is very sloppy. Thanks, My slots are 1/16" deeper than yours. Thats what causes the miter to tip foward slightly. I wonder if I should demand a new top? Is that unreasonable? I really don't want to box it back up and try again, but maybe I should? Quote
JerrySats Posted November 28, 2012 Report Posted November 28, 2012 Thanks, My slots are 1/16" deeper than yours. Thats what causes the miter to tip foward slightly. I wonder if I should demand a new top? Is that unreasonable? I really don't want to box it back up and try again, but maybe I should? How does the miter gauge that came with it fit ? Quote
robjeffking Posted November 28, 2012 Report Posted November 28, 2012 You could take a depth micrometer or dial caliper to HD and check the floor models miter depth it does seem to be alot of trouble for 1/16th of an inch. I would go ahead and order the incra and try it out if it still bothers you about the depth return the saw but verify miter slot depth on the replacement at the store to avoid the same problem. One thing all those saws have in common was a packaging defect that dents the ruler around the 14 inch increment we went thru 3 different cartons that all had the same packaging defect. The store had no saws in stock without this defect so they knocked off another 100.00 for the flaw and the service center mailed me a replacement rail that I never installed I just got used to the dent. 2 weeks ago I upgraded the fence to a vega 50 so that little demple flaw with my military discount meant I paid 350.00 with tax included. Quote
Wmacky Posted November 28, 2012 Author Report Posted November 28, 2012 How does the miter gauge that came with it fit ? It fits great side to side, but tips foward slightly due to the key riding 1/16" low. This causes the miter fence to tip foward very slightly so that stock referenced to it is no longer square to the table suface, Quote
Wmacky Posted November 28, 2012 Author Report Posted November 28, 2012 You could take a depth micrometer or dial caliper to HD and check the floor models miter depth it does seem to be alot of trouble for 1/16th of an inch. I would go ahead and order the incra and try it out if it still bothers you about the depth return the saw but verify miter slot depth on the replacement at the store to avoid the same problem. One thing all those saws have in common was a packaging defect that dents the ruler around the 14 inch increment we went thru 3 different cartons that all had the same packaging defect. The store had no saws in stock without this defect so they knocked off another 100.00 for the flaw and the service center mailed me a replacement rail that I never installed I just got used to the dent. 2 weeks ago I upgraded the fence to a vega 50 so that little demple flaw with my military discount meant I paid 350.00 with tax included. No floor models at the only HD that has these. I think it is to big a risk that I could get a worse one with other issues, I could see a non ending loop trading new issues for old ones, I think I shall demand Rigid send me a brand new replacement top. This one also has bad rust streaks as reported by others. I wonder how hard I would have to fight? Quote
robjeffking Posted November 28, 2012 Report Posted November 28, 2012 Changing the top is a big job the motor and saw blade alignment will all need to be recalibrated. They'll probaly request you bring the saw to a service center so your looking at some down time unless you have a backup. If the saw is less than 90 days old HD will exchange it on the spot. Quote
Wmacky Posted November 28, 2012 Author Report Posted November 28, 2012 Changing the top is a big job the motor and saw blade alignment will all need to be recalibrated. They'll probaly request you bring the saw to a service center so your looking at some down time unless you have a backup. If the saw is less than 90 days old HD will exchange it on the spot. Argggg. Perhaps thats what I need to do, Still I guess it wouldn't hurt to call Rigid to see if they would send one? I'd feel better just knowing I had the replacement! You have no Idea how unappealing the thought of taking that thing completely apart and starting over is. Thats enough to give up and concetrate of other hobbies! How about a poll. - Would you guys accept the Miter depth issue if this was your new saw, or am I crazy? That miter slot just seems like a very important part of the saw. A google search show only 1 other person on the entire Internet with this issue. Thats some bad luck right there. Quote
robjeffking Posted November 28, 2012 Report Posted November 28, 2012 No need to take it apart if you have help to load on a tilt trailer. Quote
Eric. Posted November 28, 2012 Report Posted November 28, 2012 Return it. No question. You paid good money for it. Keep returning the bastards until they get it right, or buy a different brand. Grizzly sent me three different tables for my bandsaw until I got a dead flat one...shipping on them every time. Yeah it was a huge PITA, but now my BS is right. Quote
Wmacky Posted November 28, 2012 Author Report Posted November 28, 2012 Spent my lucnh break holding for Ridgid, and that didn't goes as hoped. Rather, it went as robjeffking had thought. sevice center,or return it, as thet refused to send a new top. OK then, they get to give me a whole new saw..... I'll think it over today. I'm new so I'm just still not sure if this issue is big enough to take the risk of additional issues as can be the case with these cheaper saws. Quote
robjeffking Posted November 28, 2012 Report Posted November 28, 2012 What did you measure your miter slot depth with sometimes a tape measure has to much slack in the tip try using some scrap wood and mark a line and measure the the depth. Here's my results Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted November 28, 2012 Report Posted November 28, 2012 Miter bars DO NOT need to ride on the bottoms of the slots. In fact, many slots aren't even milled smooth on the bottom. I build my sleds and other implements with 1/4" thick runners, as that's all the side support there is in most saws. With a miter guage, if the stock is held firmly against the miter gauge fence, you'll be fine. Quote
Wmacky Posted November 29, 2012 Author Report Posted November 29, 2012 What did you measure your miter slot depth with sometimes a tape measure has to much slack in the tip try using some scrap wood and mark a line and measure the the depth. Here's my results Thanks for taking the time to do that. BTW, I'm using a digital caliper, and a metal ruler. Your slots look just about right. Just slightly over the 3/8" mark. My measurement is all the way over to the next mark "7/16". I wish I had your slots! I just wonder how many have been cut deeper. Are they still being cut deeper? If they are all that way now I'd just live with it. but I'm thinking about giving it another shot with a return. I hope I'm not maki9ng a mistake! Quote
robjeffking Posted November 29, 2012 Report Posted November 29, 2012 I guess in the manufacturing process it was an acceptable tolerance. I dont think the 1/16" would bother me unless the miter gauge did not function properly. Quote
Wmacky Posted December 2, 2012 Author Report Posted December 2, 2012 Well after much thought I decided to waste an entire day taking the saw apart and driving 100 miles to exchange for a new one. It did not go well. I picked a box that was damage free and returned home hoping for the best. Upon assembling the saw I noticed the entire main carcass appears to have been skewed when it was welded as it is 1/4 " out of square. This is apparent when sitting the dust collector chute on it. This meant the leg assembly needed to be skewed out of square also to get it to bolt up. However it did bolt up and all appears ok as there is no wobble, and the lift works fine. On to the table.... Wow., Looks like I wasted a bunch of time. All though this one has no rust on the table as the last one, the miter slot are even deeper on this one .440, and the miter gauge tips foward even worse. Insome places it appears even deeper. I can't believe this. Looks like they are all being made defective now. I'm not really a wood worker, and bought this to finish up another hobby. I always did want a TS though, and like the thought of finely crafted things. I think I'm going to box this back up and get back my money. I'm going to forget about this new, hobby, and concetrate on my other interest. I'm done ..... Quote
JerrySats Posted December 2, 2012 Report Posted December 2, 2012 Sorry to hear of all the problems with the table saw . I'm sure you're very frustrated at this point perhaps you'll change your mind and do some woodworking again . It happens to all of us at some point , I got tired of woodworking when I hit my mid 20s but came back to it later in my late 30s . BTW you should contact that company and let them know of your dissatisfaction with the saw and all the troubles you went through . Regards Jerry Quote
Eric. Posted December 2, 2012 Report Posted December 2, 2012 The inconvenience you went through sucks, but don't just throw in the towel on the joys of woodworking because you had a bad experience with one piece of crap saw. It's a cliche of course, but you do get what you pay for. You'll be back... Quote
Wmacky Posted December 15, 2012 Author Report Posted December 15, 2012 Well It's been a couple weeks, but I've been too busy to return the saw. Today is the day, but now my wife is trying to talk me into trying one more time. This time returning the saw locally instead of making the 100 mile round trip, and have this local store order one. They said they would, and it would take 5 days. What do you think? Am I a glutton for punishment? I'm getting really really tired of unboxing, and reboxing, transporting, loading, and assembling 300 pound cast iron shop gear. Really getting old! I think that there is a bad run, and there are no good replacements, but maybe I've just have really bad luck? Do I go for strike 3, or get my money back? BTW I got the HF 20% off on this saw ($399) Which is why my wife wants me to give it another shot. It was a really good deal, and I won't be replacing it with a more expensive saw, or ANY other saw. This would wrap up my wood working adventure.......... Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.