Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Getting ready to make my first attempt at finishing. Am I on the right path?

Featured Replies

Yet another neophyte to the world of wood here who is looking for guidance on finishing. So far, I've cut down a piece of red oak plywood to 3'x6' to be used as a desktop (the legs are metal and already done. I just need the top stained). I'll be applying edge banding to the sides and then applying the stain/finish. It's that last part where I'm looking for help. I've done a bunch of net searches, read Jeff Jewitt's "Spray Finishing Made Simple" and watched the super helpful Wood Whisperer video "You and Dye". Even with all that, I'm still not certain about my approach.

I've gotten my hands on an HVLP spray gun and this is what I'm thinking:

1. Spray with water to raise the grain.

2. Sand down with 220 grit sand paper.

3. Spray a coat of General Finishes' Light Brown, Water Based Dye Stain

4. Don't wipe it down, because it's a no-wipe stain (right, maybe?)

5. Spray two or more coats of General Finishes' High Performance Polyurethane Water Based Top Coat.

You wouldn't think that it took me hours of research to come up with that, but it did. Such are the joys of the early part of a learning curve. My question to the forum is if that basic approach will work for a first piece. I'm more interested in getting this first one done than getting it perfect. That's how I learn. That said, I want to make sure to avoid obvious errors. Any helpful advice is greatly appreciated.

I can't help with that approach, as I haven't gotten an HVLP setup yet. I have done about 6-7 projects so far and have used either BLO and wax, or BLO with an oil-based poly over it for all of my projects. I am getting much more comfortable with those finishes, and so haven't branched out yet. I probably wouldn't go the wax route for a desk, stain and poly seems reasonable. I understand your hesitancy. good luck!

First rule of finishing - never use your project to practice your finish. If you screw up while building you cut a new board. You screw up while finishing and you might be building a new project.

I have never sprayed so can't advise if that's too tough for a first time finish. I'm an oil finish (Waterlox) guy and recently tried some waterborne poly on test boards and the finish looked cracked. For a first time finish I would do oil stain and wipe on oil varnish. To make wipe on oil varnish you thin poly 50% with mineral spirits. One thing is red oak's pores won't take water based dye very well.

My best advice is to get out some scrap boards and practice. Research and reading books is great but there is no substitute to playing around with different techniques.

Second rule of finishing - if you're a novice finisher, keep it simple. You're diving in head first with HVLP, dye, water-based materials, etc. It may be prudent to simplify things on your first go 'round, and just wipe on some varnish or spray shellac or lacquer. But good luck, either way. It's gonna be..."fun."

I think you chose the wrong finish product for this approach. Wb dye stain uses a poly binder unless you have some experience its to difficult to spray without wiping. To much flow and you will be left with a sold color instead of a stain with grain showing. I'd suggest a binder less dye like transtint or Lockwood.

Don

  • Author

estesbubba: I'll definitely be testing on a piece of scrap first. Should have mentioned that in the original post. Really what I'm looking for is feedback on the overall process I'm looking at. If what I said didn't make sense, I didn't want to buy everything only to figure it out on the test run.

eric1978: I'm a big fan of keeping it simple. That's part of why I'm putting up this post. There's so much info out there, it's tough to get a foothold. About the only thing that I want to keep in the mix 100% is the HVLP. Most of the stuff I plan on working on is bigger stuff (like desktops) or simple computer monitor stands. So, I figure there's no time like the present to start learning the tool. As for the rest of the stuff (e.g. dye and waterbased), that's where I'm looking for suggestions/guidance. For example, what Don said.

Don: Two follow up questions based on your answer:

1. If I use the same approach, but plan on wiping the stain off, does that make it more likely I'll be sucessful?

2. If I use Transtint, would I just mix that in with the "General Finishes' High Performance Polyurethane Water Based Top Coat"? That seems to be what the Wood Whisperer video indicated, but I'm still unclear.

Your best chance for success would be to keep coloring and topcoats separate. Mixing color in the topcoats makes me think of Polyshades and I have never heard of a woodworker that likes that product.

estesbubba: I'll definitely be testing on a piece of scrap first. Should have mentioned that in the original post. Really what I'm looking for is feedback on the overall process I'm looking at. If what I said didn't make sense, I didn't want to buy everything only to figure it out on the test run.

eric1978: I'm a big fan of keeping it simple. That's part of why I'm putting up this post. There's so much info out there, it's tough to get a foothold. About the only thing that I want to keep in the mix 100% is the HVLP. Most of the stuff I plan on working on is bigger stuff (like desktops) or simple computer monitor stands. So, I figure there's no time like the present to start learning the tool. As for the rest of the stuff (e.g. dye and waterbased), that's where I'm looking for suggestions/guidance. For example, what Don said.

Don: Two follow up questions based on your answer:

1. If I use the same approach, but plan on wiping the stain off, does that make it more likely I'll be sucessful?

2. If I use Transtint, would I just mix that in with the "General Finishes' High Performance Polyurethane Water Based Top Coat"? That seems to be what the Wood Whisperer video indicated, but I'm still unclear.

No you dont mix transtint with the top coat unless your applying a tinted finish, just water. If I understand you correctly you want to go 100% sprayed. If thats the case I'd practice with tinted top coats and dyes but stay away from trans tint because its way over priced, try lockwood. You can also spray dyes without wiping, water base are very easy. You do have to understand there is a difference between something like GF dye stains and just using dyes dissolved in water. The gf is going to have a binder, the plain dye will not. Those are two completely different animals. Personally I wouldnt rule out wiping stains, they produce a very nice finish with practice.

Don

Alan,

First of all, welcome to the forum. It's always good to have another input source, that's what wer're all about, sharing info and helping each other out.

My input to your questions:

First of all, I'd skip steps 1 and 2. You don't have a lot of real wood to work with on plywood and there's always the question of how far the glue has penetrated into the thin veneer. It's too easy to sand too far and then you have a problem with uneven absorption of the dye/stain. My approach for plywood is to color, seal, spray a couple of finish coats and then sand out the whiskers.

As far as spraying the dye stain, I think you'll find it difficult to get an even coverage on the color. You're dealing with a large surface and you're obviously new to this, take my word it ain't exactly the easiest thing to do. The primary advantage for spraying dyes/stains versus wiping is to avoid blotching on woods like birch, poplar, maple, pine, etc.. Oak isn't one of those woods. So why take the trouble? Wipe on, wipe off, lots less trouble. Move fast, water-based stains dry fast.

I'd suggest a seal coat between the stain and the topcoat. A coat or two of 1-lb. cut dewaxed shellac will prevent the topcoat from pulling up the stain and dulling the finish. Then a light finish coat, a full wet coat, a light scuff sand to de-whisker and then another coat or two of finish.

If you want to use Transtint, just dilute it with denatured alcohol(stay away from the box-store stuff, it's half methanol) or water and spray or wipe it on. You can use it to tint topcoats but it takes a lot of practice to spray it on and get even coverage.

HTH,

Bill

  • 1 month later...
  • Author

Appreciate all the input here. There is a local Woodcraft class in a few weeks on staining. I'm signed up so I can get my feet wet, as they say with staining with a little more oversight. 

 

Cheers,

-a

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.