Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Honduran mahogany color variation between boards

Featured Replies

Hi everybody.

 

This is my first post on this forum, although I go on it regularly. Anyway, I just finished building a honduran mahogany coffee table and I wanted to use an aniline dye to give it a different nuance and a little more character. Now, since honduran mahogany is pretty expensive, I did my homework on the exact measurement I needed and I am proud to say I got the exact boards I needed. However, there is a noticeable color variation between the boards. Here are a couple of pictures that show what I am talking about:

 

post-4527-0-40144300-1359252366_thumb.jp and

post-4527-0-61194700-1359252381_thumb.jp

 

I guess my question is: Can I get away with using an aniline dye to bring the panels to the same color or do I need to go with a stain? Also, any techniques you guys think might be appropriate to each method would be greatly appreciated. Thanks in advance.

IMO what you're dealing with is the difference between heart wood (center wide pieces) Vs sap wood (narrower edge pieces).  If you're looking to make the appearance as uniform as possible I would suggest using a stain / grain filler.  I just finished doing a video on the various stain / fillers that Pettit offers (yes, I'm a boat guy and this is the brand that I use most often with mahogany, but I am sure that others that deal with furniture finishing will chime in soon)..  It won't make it completely uniform, but there are a few tricks that can be done to make it pretty close (mostly sanding techniques before staining)..

  • Author

IMO what you're dealing with is the difference between heart wood (center wide pieces) Vs sap wood (narrower edge pieces).

First, thanks for the quick reply.

Second, I doubt that I'm dealing with a hearwood vs sapwood issue, mainly due to the fact that the wide pieces have some sapwood on the edge (no noticeable in the photos, they are on the other side of the board) and that sapwood is considerably lighter. I am thinking more that it could have something to do with the age of the tree as it was cut down. I remember working with another huge board a while back (about 7/4 thick and 13" wide) that was darker than other boards. And yes, it was honduran mahogany, not some other mahogany species or substitute...

I'll check Pettit's website right now.

I doubt that I'm dealing with a hearwood vs sapwood issue, mainly due to the fact that the wide pieces have some sapwood on the edge (no noticeable in the photos, they are on the other side of the board) and that sapwood is considerably lighter

 

This is what I'm referring to..  Is the color along the edges of the center pieces closer in tone to what was used for the front / back?  I haven't posted the video yet so it's not on Pettit's site (but I am sure it will be very soon).. 

  • Author

What I meant was that the sapwood from the wide pieces is considerably lighter than the narrow pieces. That was the reason I was doubting that the narrow pieces were sapwood.

Hmm..  Either way IMO the best way to make this as uniform as possible would be to use a filler / stain..  Interested to see what others have to say.  Are you sure that all the pieces are actually Honduran?  Mahogany goes by a number of different names (sometimes not always accurate).. 

  • Author

Pretty positive. It's all been bought from the same stack from a reputable lumber yard. I will definitely use a filler, I was just wondering if I could control the color so that I could use dye (it penetrates the wood grain in depth, unlike stain) by getting the darker boards wet with just water before applying the dye and thus get more dye in the lighter wood...

Have to wait for others to weigh in on the dyes (I don't use them very much), but you're on the right path for using different sanding grits to vary the intensity of the fillers to vary the color of the stain..  Basically if you're tying to make the appearance more uniform, sand the lighter pieces with a more coarse grit (80 grit), wet the surface to raise the grains (let dry) and stain..  Doing it this way it will hold more pigment and darken the appearance.  Darker pieces you'll want to sand to a much finer grit (320 + / -) and go over top of that with the same filler / stain. 

 

The only draw back of this is that the pieces that are sanded to a finer finish will show more of the grain character as it will hold / absorb less of the stain / filler...  But, this is really only noticeable when looking at it "up close and personal" :P. 

 

Best thing to do is experiment on scrap if you have any...

Radu, I've done a lot of stuff in Honduran Mahogany and have experienced the same problems. I solved most of those problems by ordering all of my Mahogany color-matched from my wholesaler. They typically send whatever is on the top of the stack unless you order it that way. I order all of my hardwoods s2s and straight line ripped, so the color is obvious to them when they plane it. Where I haven't had this luxury, I have always used dark mahogany or dark walnut stain on it and have never had a big problem with it. Whatever way you go, do as Andy suggests and try it on samples first.

  • Author

One thing I forgot to mention is that the table is not glued yet. It's held in place by the dominoes (all my love to Festool) in between the boards and boards and legs. So the darker pieces are detachable from the lighter ones. Could I dye the lighter ones to match the darker and then dye them all to a different color/nuance? I am really stuck to this dyeing method of coloring as it brings an almost 3d effect to wood grain by not covering it (stain is, after all, a diluted paint, while dye is made of microcrystals that travel with the solvent deep in the wood grain without changing its character)...

These days Genuine Mahogany (Swietenia macrophylla) is grown all over the world.  One thing you can count on is that what you have isn't actually from Honduras.  That is the marketing name that has been attached to it over the years.  In fact Honduras no longer produces Mahogany in any significant numbers due to CITES regulations and a long term forestry management plan.  So what the Genuine Mahogany market see now is lumber from all over Brazil, Peru, Mexico, Guatemala, Paraguay, Uruguay, Fiji, and Bolivia (very little here as it is illegal now).  Each one of these areas has slightly different soil chemistry, rainfall, growing times, etc.  For instance, southern Brazilian Mahogany from the Santo Domingo area is much lighter in color closer to a pinkish African Mahogany (Khaya, not genuine) due to very fast growth and higher rainfall.  Bolivian and Peruvian are darker and denser due to slower growth and a more mountainous soil.  You will also find a bit of shimmer in these variants due to that more silica rich soil.

 

My point being that the exact same genus and species yields very different wood and when the importer orders Mahogany it can be coming from multiple suppliers, mills, and regions.  It will all get grouped together on sea going containers to ship to the US.  From there it can be broken into many different bundles and shipped all over the place.  The only way to really get a large amount of Mahogany from the same region is to buy it in container volumes (~10,000 bf) and even then this tends to clean out the individual mill.  We do this where I work but even then we are selling that material along with other containers from other mills/regions all over the nation in smaller quantities like 1,000 bf at a time.  So at the average woodworker's level where we buy the material from a retailer who may have bought several shipments from different wholesalers (some of which don't buy the same way we do) it is next to impossible to expect that you are getting material from the same region let alone the same tree.  The notable exception to this is the guy who imports a log (very tough to do legally) and saws it himself then keeps it in flitch form. 

 

In the end it is easier to get a good match when you buy in quantity but this is not a luxury most of us have.  Finally to beat this horse thoroughly dead, many retailers are buying from brokers who don't actually have the material in hand and buy sight unseen so other species get mixed in since it is all "red-brown wood".  Now you are finding African Mahogany, Utile, Sapele, Philippine Mahogany (Luan), and even Eucalyptus variants mixed in and labelled at Genuine Mahogany.  Obviously these act and look very differently.  A good dealer won't let this happen and more than anything can identify the species himself but really it is up to the woodworker to be the picky one.

 

All this being said, I rarely build with Mahogany where I don't try and unify the boards with a dye or gel stain.

I agree its hard to get mohogay all the same color and I doubt any dealer in the US can match color very well. The only way Ive found to get a real good match is buy from HUGE suppliers and buy in thick slabs. The color varies even in boards from the same tree so even buying thick slabs and resawing you will not get a perfect match.

Here is an example this was all made from the same tree and was purchased as two bookmatched slabs. You can see the top and bottom are not a perfect match. The bottom was closer to the outside of the tree. Thats about as close as a guy can ask without coloring the wood.

For what it's worth, I no longer buy mahogany lumber, especially if I am matching it up to mahogany plywood. I use Royal Cedar which looks like a figured Mahogany and matches the color of the plywood better than Mahogany lumber (probably for the above mentioned reasons). Royal Cedar is consistent in color and has the same basic characteristics of Mahogany but at half the price. It is a cousin of Spanish Cedar, but doesn't stink as bad when you machine it. I posted a thread a while back of a gun room that I made of Royal Cedar and Mahogany plywood if you want to see an example.

  • Author

First, thank you all for the input. It's impressive and very useful. I always thought that wood that's in a bundle came from the same source. Anyway, I doubt these guys would knowingly sell me other "mahoganies" as genuine mahogany. But I've been wrong before...

"All this being said, I rarely build with Mahogany where I don't try and unify the boards with a dye or gel stain"

So it's ok to do this with different concentration dye solutions? The pieces aren't glued together, as I said. Of course, after trying it on scrap...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.