Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Finishing a walnut dining table - help needed

Featured Replies

hey all, first time poster, but have been lurking for bit. I've found several old post on the subject (and watched a couple videos too), but have a few specific questions about my potential finish technique(s) and the products I've been testing. I realize many folks have their go-to product, but here's what I've got in the works so far.

 

- Boiled linseed oil - several coats plus a howards wax and feed topcoat

- Watco Danish oil 'natural'

- Watco Danish oil 'dark walnut  

- pure Tung oil - several coats plus howards

- Behlens rock hard urethane varnish 'satin'

 

So far, the Watco Dark Walnut is out. Just too dark. Overall, I want to have a warm wood finish, to really just let the walnut be walnut. The room get's decent light, but no major direct sun, so UV protection isn't much of an issue. I realize I sacrifice a bit of durability if not building a film finish, but I don't want it to look plastic. I don't mind some upkeep, but do want a decent level of protection. my questions are these:

 

- Is there a lighter alternative to the Watco 'natural'? This still seems to impart a color to the wood. Maybe it's just the oil that's in the blend? Should I have just tried their 'tung oil finish'?

 

- Tung/BLO - Can I/should I use a coat or two of Behlens over the top of either of these to impart more protection? Can Behlens go over any/all of these?

 

- Behlens - If we choose to go a different direction down the road (or need to fix a small area), how difficult is it to fix? Does the whole thing need to be stripped/sanded down, or can I work on just that small area?

 

thanks for the help!

 

Hi Nod,

 

I'm new to the forum here as well.  If interested, you may want to contact Pierre Erizias at Erizias Basses as he is our go-to guy using some of the latest UV finishing techniques out there.  He can be reached at info@eriziasbasses.com .

 

Regards,

 

FÜZ

  • Author

Thanks Fuz! I'lll have to check him out. 

 

Does anyone have experience with Behlen's? just using it as the stand alone finish and/or using it as a top coat over tung or BLO?

Thanks Fuz! I'lll have to check him out. 

 

Does anyone have experience with Behlen's? just using it as the stand alone finish and/or using it as a top coat over tung or BLO?

 

RPM has been going through some changes over the last couple years. The older was great but I dont know about the newer formulations.

  • Author

There is a comprehensive thread on this topic, I have copied it below.  Amber shellac warms up walnut without darkening too much.  This might be the look you are going for.   

 

 

Here is Marc's advice, it is hard to argue with:  "So one alternative finish schedule that is much simpler and could yield similar results is to put on a light coat of dewaxed amber shellac, followed by 2-3 coats of wiping varnish. The finish will be beautiful, durable, and you'll be done in two days".

 

Thanks! I forgot I had bookmarked that thread at some point while researching finishes. I was always afraid of shellac, but it seems not like the scary beast I thought it was. I'll have to pick some up and do a test board this afternoon. I don't mind the warming up the wood at all. 

  • Author

RPM has been going through some changes over the last couple years. The older was great but I dont know about the newer formulations.

I had read about that. Sounds like the 'old' formula was a favorite among many. I can't seem to find anyone who's got much experience with the new formula. I'll have to post some pics of my sample boards when I get a chance. 

  • Author

tracking down 'dewaxed' shellac locally is proving more of a challenge than expected. scouring the interwebs for availability. Hoping to start the finishing (no pun intended) this weekend at the latest. Thanks again for everyone's info

tracking down 'dewaxed' shellac locally is proving more of a challenge than expected. scouring the interwebs for availability. Hoping to start the finishing (no pun intended) this weekend at the latest. Thanks again for everyone's info

 

Home depot or lowes. Sanding sealer.

  • Author

Home depot or lowes. Sanding sealer.

yeah? pretty much same thing? what about the 'amber' part of it? I'm on it. will report back. thanks.

Hey Nod. Welcome to the forum. It looks like you've gotten some sound advice so I don't need to add to it. Looking forward to seeing pics of your project.

  • Author

 

Finally had a chance to get pics off my camera. Wood selection, giant belt sanding, finished slab, plus some shots of the test finishes

 

 

post-14137-0-01968500-1370630218_thumb.jpost-14137-0-72667400-1370630226_thumb.jpost-14137-0-99590700-1370630231_thumb.jpost-14137-0-13466900-1370630239_thumb.jpost-14137-0-35672500-1370630243_thumb.jpost-14137-0-23184600-1370630250_thumb.j

 

Some misc. info if it matters - I'm a graphic designer by day. super novice want to learn more about woodworking since I was a kid. I finally have a house with a garage, and well, I'm starting to accumulate toys, errr.. tools and getting my hands dirty. But I didn't trust myself, or have the tools for this project. My neighbor happens to be a woodworker, so I enlisted his help to build the table top. I selected all the wood (with his veteran guidance). He put it together, and I'll be finishing it all. A metal fabricator will be making some legs for me next, and hopefully next week I'll be assembling. Will post final pics once complete. 

  • Author

Overall, it's been an interesting and FUN process. I really love the concept of hand rubbed tung oil finishes, and have seen a few that are absolutely incredible. I know I haven't done enough coats, or have enough experience doing them, so mine aren't turning out quite as expected. I have to admit the BLO is a very pleasing front runner at this point. I put a bit of Howards over it, and feels and looks pretty nice. My wife really loves the look of teak, but price for material was insane.

 

The Behlens seems to have a lightness to it that mimics that teak a bit, so that may very well be the choice. Two scaps have behlens, with different amounts of sanding to see if I can get it to be less 'film', but I'm also testing out Marc's shellac base with urethane overtop (the last image there). It still needs to finish drying and get sanded to lose that bit of shine. So far, it's looking really nice and the grain is showing well. This very well could be the winner. That guy must know a thing or two  ;)

  • Author

Thanks for posting the pictures. It makes me feel less guilty for paying my local hardwood dealer $25 to drum sand a table top i just glued up. i started with my hand planes, then got out the belt sander, and then finally admitted it was not worth the time, the dust, or the aggrevation.

let me make you feel even better - I paid $65 to run it through that machine. But it was well worth it. Time saved, flattened and evened out. Would have taken waaaaaayyyyy longer. All in, was just a hair over an hour to load the top, drive to the shop, sand, load it back and drive home. Not sure how big yours is, but this is 42"x 84"

  • Author

Mine was 36X60, my shop charges $75/hour.  This job was quick enough that they just charged me the shop minimum of $25.  

yeah, I guess that sounds pretty comparable. Nice of 'em to let you get away with $25.

  • Author

Update - the seal coat (dewaxed shellac) didn't quite add much color that I was expecting. The wife is now leaning towards the BLO finish with a urethane top coat. Been reading more about tung vs BLo. I've got both. Anyone suggest one over the other? Seems like the more I read the more confused i get, and really does it just boil down to personal preference at this point?

Update - the seal coat (dewaxed shellac) didn't quite add much color that I was expecting. The wife is now leaning towards the BLO finish with a urethane top coat. Been reading more about tung vs BLo. I've got both. Anyone suggest one over the other? Seems like the more I read the more confused i get, and really does it just boil down to personal preference at this point?

 

If it was my table i'd just use BLO let it dry and shoot it with a two part poly like CIC or Pinnacle. Maybe add a touch of amber tint.

Update - the seal coat (dewaxed shellac) didn't quite add much color that I was expecting. The wife is now leaning towards the BLO finish with a urethane top coat. Been reading more about tung vs BLo. I've got both. Anyone suggest one over the other? Seems like the more I read the more confused i get, and really does it just boil down to personal preference at this point?

In answer to your question, yes, it is a matter of personal preference. Mainly, it's the wife's personal preference. :D

  • Author

In answer to your question, yes, it is a matter of personal preference. Mainly, it's the wife's personal preference. :D

;) exactly!

 

thanks everyone for the feedback.

 

The last time I tried to 'finish' a project, it turned out terrible. I know much more now (at least in theory), but since this is such a special project, I really don't want to screw it up. I appreciate all the info and feedback. BLO it is. Tomorrow I dive in. Keep you posted on progress.

  • Author

UPDATE: 2 coats of (1/2 MS // 1/2 BLO) have been applied. I then applied one coat of 100% BLO. Didn't quite flood the 3rd coat as much as the first two, but gave it a good coating, let it sit, then rubbed it in and wiped off any excess and/or weeping I saw. My Question to you gurus is what next? Should I do a high grit sanding before applying another coat? leave it as is and then wax or varnish? How many more coats of BLO should I realistically be thinking about?

 

I've read wipe on coats are about half of brush on (2 wipe on : 1 brush on ratio), but is that more true for varnish/film finishes? Should I stop while I'm ahead and things look good? 

post-14137-0-79487500-1371487104_thumb.j

  • Author

Thanks Woodsap. I've got some "fine" scotchbrite pads. the grey ones. At some point I came across those being a nice alternative to steel wool since it won't shed like steel wool will. I wonder if the "fine" version is fine enough? I know I've got some high grit paper around if need be though. 

 

And I've read/heard about waiting for it to cure as well. I'd love to use it this weekend for dinner, like you said, it's taken this long, why rush it?! ;->

 

 

The idea of BLO and wax only is very appealing to the "back to basics/keep it simple/avoid chemicals" side of me, but I have never tried it.  In theory, if you get a scratch or stain you can repair with a steel wool rub and new oil and wax.  I just wonder about something like wine, coffee, or hard alcohol getting on the table. 

My thoughts exactly. I like the idea of being able to simply fix it if need be, but I'm sure others will argue if you put a different layer of protection on there, I'd probably never have to fix it

  • Author

Thanks for the info on cure time. I was thinking I'd have to wait a couple days.

I flipped the top over this morning, did one more light coating to the underside since it was a little light, and will apply the varnish/ms probably late this evening. I only did one 50/50 blo/ms wipe on the base previously.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.