Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Fireplace Mantel paint removal and stain to finish

Featured Replies

My home is a Cape Cod that was built in the 1950s and has a lovely formal fireplace that mimcs the fluted column-type trim of the exterior of the house.  Recently (well, 2 years ago) while I was repainting the living room I had an epiphany and decided to strip off the layers of white paint on the mantel.  It was fun.  I scraped.  I used a heatgun.  I used a chemical stripper.  The most challenging part is the lovely detailed carving on the face of the front board.  Except that it isn't a carving at all.  It is some type of plastic or resin glued on.  The paint is too stubborn to come completely off of it and the "carving" is coming away from the wood and will need to be reglued. It is also nailed in place with tiny headless nails and cannot be removed.

 

Off and on I have stopped this project and waited for a new epiphany...I need a solid plan.

 

The wood is light in color and not a significant grain.  In fact, it is 2 different tones in key places.  Probably this is why it was originally painted.  It is a bit soft so it might be pine.  It has some intricate details (plus the "carving") which are difficult to get down to the bare wood.  Yes, I try metal and nylon brushes and steel wool, but it is impossible to get a good angle on...well...angles and corners.

 

My goal is to stain it a very dark walnut.  The walls are mocha, the floors are oak and the woodwork is painted white.  Dark brown will be fabulous.

 

How do I get the last of the white paint from the detailed areas without gouging the wood or damaging the "carving" - it is the shape of a vase of flowers plus a scalloped border an inch and a half away - so actually, 2 pieces stuck onto the mantel.

 

How do I sand around the detail of the bouquet?  It is maddening.  Precious little room between the bouquet and the scalloped trim piece.

 

How do I stain the "carving?"  Should I stain the wood, reglue the carving, then paint the carving to match?  There are currently nail holes filled with white putty from the original work and I will probably have to dot those with some paint - right?

 

Any suggestions (other than repainting the whole thing white!!) will be great.post-14847-0-39909600-1386107234_thumb.jpost-14847-0-35788900-1386107271_thumb.j

If it were me I'd just yank the carving off and replace it with a real wood one that you could stain to match.  that way you don't need to worry about getting the last bits of paint off.  Search around and I bet you can find something you like for a decent price.  Then if you want the carving to really stand out, after you stain it use some steel wool to burnish it a little bit, basically rub some stain off the high spots so it jumps out.  Dark on dark with no burnishing or other such technique and it will just blend into the background. 

by the way nice job on the refinishing so far, I wouldn't have the patience for it.   looks really good. 

+1 for removing the appliqué. I would seriously consider veneer for a new carving to sit against. That radical but rather plain color differentiation does not beg to be featured in a natural finish environment. Even if you salvage the appliqué, it will be easier to pull it and soak it rather than stripping it in place.

==> if it were me I'd just yank the carving off and replace it with a real wood one that you could stain to match

+2

 

==> I wouldn't have the patience for it.

+2

 

Yea, if this was my honey-do, I'd wait for a convenient "girl-golf-weekend" and arrange for a mysterious (and highly unlikely) accident to befall said carving... and just as unlikely, I'd happen to find an almost perfect replacement on eBay that was "so cheap, that it was almost free"... :)

I do believe the wood in this photo is douglous fir, the heart wood being the darker too and the sap being the lighter pieces.

Perhaps taking a q tip wrapped in sandpaper at the end to get into those small details. Lol. Worse comes to worst, sandblast it.

  • Author

Am I allowed to yank it off?  That seems like a violation of some refinishing canon of ethics or something.  Tempting.  What are the does and don'ts of finding a replacement? 

 

If I decide to try the sandblasting route - is that really something I can do indoors?  Are there little petite sandblasting machines?

 

The two-tone main board - if it is Douglas Fir as was suggested, is there any difference in my approach to staining it?  Can I get the color to even out with stain?  Water-based?  Oil-based? Gel?

 

Thanks for all the great replies.  Please feel free to chime in again.  I'm in no hurry, but a Christmas deadline so we can use the main room would be nice.

--> Am I allowed to yank it off?  That seems like a violation of some refinishing canon of ethics or something.  Tempting.  What are the does and don'ts of finding a replacement? 

YES.  Wood is always better than plastic, at least better than plastic pretending to be wood.  The only does and don'ts are with respect to your budget.  Finding something the right size to glue on should not be a problem.  

 

-->The two-tone main board - if it is Douglas Fir as was suggested, is there any difference in my approach to staining it?  Can I get the color to even out with stain?  Water-based?  Oil-based? Gel

Yes, you can get it to even out somewhat, but you will have two challenges with the Doug Fir.  1) evening out the heart wood vs. the sap wood and 2) even within each section, you have what's called early growth and late growth.  Basically on softwood trees that grow year round some growth rings are dense and some are soft.  That is why you can see the vertical grain so clearly.  Well when you stain the wood the softer grain absorbs more stain so basically every other growth ring (the lighter ones) will get more color than the ones next to it.  A gel stain will work better because it sits on top of the wood rather than penetrating.  A wash coat of thin shellac or prestain conditioner might help you get more even color, but those will also make it more difficult to get the dark color you want.   

 

I still like C Shaffers idea of veneering over the frieze.  If you can do all the stripping you have done so far, a little veneering will be within reach.   Use a nice piece of burl walnut veneer or crotch mahogany and you will be the envy of your entire neighborhood :)

==> veneering over the frieze

Only if the fireplace doesn't get used...

true dat, i suppose heat would be a problem. but i have seen fireplace surrounds made from hardwood faced ply.... maybe they are destined to fail or does the adhesive matter?

  • Author

Well, call me impulsive, but after 2 years I have removed the applique/carving!!  Oh, I should have done this SO much sooner.  It is currently getting the stripper treatment since sanding did not get it completely clean.  A bit of paint is pushed into the grain where it is marred.

 

On a previous project I had some success removing scratches and nicks by soaking the area with a bit of water to raise the grain and then sanding it smooth.  Would this work on fir? 

 

Will a pre-stain application do any good?

 

What is your recommendatino for filling nail holes and some 1/4" gaps between the top and sides of the mantel?  The area previously had a white filler which has fallen out in chunks, but also appears to be holding it in the right position where it remains.  Is there a particular compound that will be great at taking gel stain (I will probably go that route) or should I buy something tinted?  Can I get tinted caulk?  I caulking gun would make it easier on the long edges.

 

Thanks for all your great advice.  It is making me get to it!post-14847-0-27202100-1386169235_thumb.j

Nice!

 

If you could take a picture of the gaps that would help.  My inclination would be to leave them be.  Filling a gap that big would just call attention to it and caulk is for paint grade work.  Maybe you could get a small profile moulding to conceal the gap?   

 

In terms of the nail holes, I prefer to fill them after I apply the stain and the top coat.  In the stain aisle you can find wax crayons that match most common wood and stain colors.  After putting on  your top coat and letting it thoroughly dry (at least a few days), just rub the wax crayon over the nail hole until it is filled, then use a cotton cloth to buff off the excess.  It will be nearly invisible.  It is hard to find fillers that take stain well so this tends to be the easiest/best way to go.    Sometimes I warm up the tip of wax crayon a little bit with a lighter so that rubs in more easily. 

==>but i have seen fireplace surrounds made from hardwood faced ply.

Real wood burners or the decorative gas jobs?

  • Author

Clearly I will have to find another applique as sanding alone will not fix this blemish.  I am using 60grit with an orbital and hate to go further and make it indented.   Willing to take suggestions.  More sanding?  Chemicals?  Applique?

 

Also attached are pix showing the gaps.  They are visible when I sit down on the couch for example.  Either I remove all the old crack filler and risk the wood moving or splitting or I refill it?  Other options?  Am I worrying too much?

 

Thanks for the advice and valuable information.  Who knew there was so much to know!

 

post-14847-0-14302300-1386176288_thumb.jpost-14847-0-35434700-1386176319_thumb.jpost-14847-0-39943200-1386176345_thumb.jpost-14847-0-54023400-1386176377_thumb.j

First of all, I've got to congratulate you on your patience... There is no way I would have hung-in so long...

 

I'd find a solid wood carving to replace the plastic one, then stain the entire thing once at the same time...

As for the nail holes, I'd get some scrap and put some nail holes in it... Finish it the same way and see if it comes-out better with pre or post stain filling.

Same for the gaps...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,012 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • JAR Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.