jmaichel Posted July 4, 2011 Report Posted July 4, 2011 This week I received shipment on 4 saws that I purchased in order to try to beef up my hand tool kit. When I first started I bought two Pax Panel saws and two Veritas carcass saws but quickly started to notice that each saw was lacking in some areas. I especially noticed after I attended a LN even back in March and had the opportunity to use some of there saws. After extensive research on panel saws I determined that the only way to go was to buy used Disston saws. I found two great saws on ebay they cost a little more than what most would pay for these saws on ebay but when I set out to search for saws I wanted them to meet certain criteria. 1) I wanted to buy from a reputable ebay seller someone who offers returns, guarantee their product and deals in mostly old tools. 2) I wanted the saw be sharp, clean and ready to use. 3) I was looking for specific saws. I used http://www.disstonianinstitute.com/ to do research on the different Disston saws and that is where I came up with my saw choices Disston D8 and Disston No.16 (Not D16). The D8 is a 5 1/2 PPI rip saw and the No. 16 is an 8 PPI x-cut saw. Both saws are in great shape with nice apple wood handles and were sharp and ready to use. I wished I had purchased these initially but I was stubborn and did not want to buy used tools. I did say 4 saws, earlier in the week I order two saws from Mark Harrell over at bad axe but after speaking to him on the phone to change up some details he informed me that my saws won't ship for another 12-14 weeks :'(. I was in need of new carcass saws so I decided to order some LN Independence Carcass saws one filed 10 ppi rip and the other 14 ppi x-cut. I have two sixteen inch saw on order from mark one filed x-cut and the other filled rip, although I may change my order to his 18" tenon saw just not sure I need that much saw. I got the LN's in two days and have already put them through a couple workouts. The Veritas x-cut saws were nice for the price but their is a huge difference in the LN's, something I noticed at the LN event and confirmed while using them over the weekend. The heavy brass back makes sawing straight a lot easier and it really became clear to me what it means to "let the saw do the work." Again should have spent the money up front for the LN's but I was able to get some of my money back after selling the Veritas and Pax saws. http://www.flickr.com/photos/james_maichel/sets/72157626991043067/ James Quote
aengland Posted July 5, 2011 Report Posted July 5, 2011 Congrats on the saw purchases--my head is spinning trying to chase out all your orders! But, I really urge some restraint on changing the 16" tenon saws to 18". I've been using backsaws constantly for the last four years (I'm just under 6') and 16" with a 3-4.25 tall plate is plenty big. Beyond that I reach for my 24-26" handsaws, from 7 tpi to 12 tpi, and get marvelous cuts. Backsaws excel in the short cut arena (no pun intended). I'm quite comfortable doing much of the backsaw cutting with a handsaw, especially a shorter panel saw (18-20"); but I'd never attempt dovetails with rip handsaw! I've accumulated backsaws (note: not collected) of the old Disstons, Simonds, Atkins, Jackson, Pearce, and some others as well, in lengths of 8" to 20". I never use the 20" except as a miter saw. Even then, I've made a cutting board with my common angles and use 10" or 12" for most all cuts--except tenons or large carcass cuts. I've got a dedicated 14" and two 16"s. All I can say is, "sweeeeeeeettttttt!" Five backsaws should do it: 1 dovetail (8-12", thin plate, high tpi, your choice); 1 12" cc; 1 12" rip; 1 14" cc; 1 16" rip. But, of course, who's counting OBTW, I'm envious of your forthcoming Bad Axe saws. One day, I own one each of the great sawmakers--accumulated, not collected!!! Archie Quote
jmaichel Posted July 5, 2011 Author Report Posted July 5, 2011 Congrats on the saw purchases--my head is spinning trying to chase out all your orders! But, I really urge some restraint on changing the 16" tenon saws to 18". I've been using backsaws constantly for the last four years (I'm just under 6') and 16" with a 3-4.25 tall plate is plenty big. Beyond that I reach for my 24-26" handsaws, from 7 tpi to 12 tpi, and get marvelous cuts. Backsaws excel in the short cut arena (no pun intended). I'm quite comfortable doing much of the backsaw cutting with a handsaw, especially a shorter panel saw (18-20"); but I'd never attempt dovetails with rip handsaw! I've accumulated backsaws (note: not collected) of the old Disstons, Simonds, Atkins, Jackson, Pearce, and some others as well, in lengths of 8" to 20". I never use the 20" except as a miter saw. Even then, I've made a cutting board with my common angles and use 10" or 12" for most all cuts--except tenons or large carcass cuts. I've got a dedicated 14" and two 16"s. All I can say is, "sweeeeeeeettttttt!" Five backsaws should do it: 1 dovetail (8-12", thin plate, high tpi, your choice); 1 12" cc; 1 12" rip; 1 14" cc; 1 16" rip. But, of course, who's counting OBTW, I'm envious of your forthcoming Bad Axe saws. One day, I own one each of the great sawmakers--accumulated, not collected!!! Archie Hi Archie, Very good points on the 18" tenon saw and I may have to rethink that decision. I don't think I am going to go with the traditional 14" cc saw, aka sash saw. I like the idea of big 16" cross cut saw for longer dados and finish cuts on thicker stock. I'm not sure you can ever have enough saws. James Quote
newageneanderthal Posted July 14, 2011 Report Posted July 14, 2011 ...The Veritas x-cut saws were nice for the price but their is a huge difference in the LN's... I actually prefer the Veritas saws, the LN's are great saws, and probably better from a pure quality stand point, but from the time I picked up the first Veritas dovetail saw it felt like part of my hand. While the LN feels good, the Vertias just simply had to be purchased on the spot, even if it would have been much more than the LN Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.