Recommended Posts

Posted

The CL options are a Jet 1/2 hp mortiser and a Grizzly tenon jig for $300 or a 3/4 hp Powermatic mortiser for $300. Either one would probably come down some on the price and looking at the two, the PM is twice as heavy. It seems better built and is more powerful.

-Do you own either? If so, what do you think?

-Do you need the extra 1/4 HP?

-Do you know anything about the Griz jig?

Thanks

Tim

Posted

Tim - in all my reading on benchtop mortisers, there seemed to be little practical difference due to HP. There was a review a long time ago in Shopnotes (I think) and the 1/2 HP units did at least as well as, if not better than, more 'powerful' units. I'm sure the extra 1/4HP would make *some* difference, but what you really need to be sure of is well sharpened and tuned chisels.

If the Jet is the one I am thinking about, the one thing I did not like was the MDF table - most other units have a cast iron table.

Check out this review. The PM is not one of the ones tested but it should give you an idea of what to look for.

http://www.woodnet.net/plansnow/review-mortising.pdf

This review has both a Jet and PM model - might be more relevant.

http://www.squidoo.com/compare-top-benchtop-mortisers

Posted

The jet is wimpy compared to the powermatic. The powermatic is much more stout and thats what you need in a mortiser above and beyond the bigger motor. If you were closer I have a jet collecting dust I'd sell you for much less than that. $300 is to high for a used machine.

Don

Posted

I don't have the bench top model PM, but the thing that I found in my searching as most important is the amount of leverage the arm gives you for pushing the chisel through the wood. IMO i don't know that HP is a huge consideration unless you're doing large (1" or larger") mortises. Second in importance for me was the hold down. I ended up going with the PM 719 and am a solid believer in PM quality. Jet is still nice, but a heavier unit is going to be less prone to flex and racking when plunging the chisel down..

Hope this helps :)

Happy Holidays!

Posted

Tim,

I own the PM mortiser and love it. Before the PM I used a conversion kit for my bench top drill press. The one thing that I hated about using the conversion kit was getting the fence set up, so I should not be a surprise that what drew me to the PM was mainly the table/fence. I really like that distance adjustments can be made by turning a knob at the back of the machine. When you get the fence correctly positioned, you can secure it with the two toggle locks. The hold down is reversible, so you can hold thin or thick pieces (You can also get a riser block for the machine which increases the capacity by 2"). Another nice touch are the rollers that you can position against the work to hold the work piece against the fence. As far as power goes, I don't think the extra 1/4 HP is noticeable but may help when drilling larger mortises. As Don mentioned, the PM is much more stout. It has a larger, wider base and is much heaver (I believe it is over 80lbs).

Matt

Posted

I've also got a PM719.

If I had to have a benchtop unit, I would choose whatever mortiser has the better hold down, beefiest column, and had the smoothest action. Be prepared to bolt the thing to a heavy, strong bench. The stouter everything is, the more accurate your work will be. I agree with the others that the motors won't make a huge difference. The motor is basically drilling 1/4->1/2" holes, nothing more. If the PM is newer, the motors may be more similar than you'd believe.

If you invest in a diamond sharpening cone and learn to properly sharpen and polish the chisels, you'll get far better results with much less effort. Machine chisels are notoriously dull out of the box.

I'm not a big fan of commercial tenon jigs, I've sold mine. I think the bearing / clamping surfaces are too small, and there are too many adjustments to get knocked out of whack. I greatly prefer cutting them with a simple and quick shop-made version that rides the rip fence, or in my sled, either flat with a dado set or vertically with a clamped vertical block.

With the fence riding jig, I use two thin kerf rip blades, with a block of MDF and dado shims as spacers. Once you figure out the combo of dado shims that match the equation created by the tooth offset of your blade pair, your MDF spacer, and the width of your machine chisel, the setup is 100% repeatable. The jig is a large version of this:

highland-tenon-jig.jpg

I add extra layers of MDF to the stack above the fence for extra beef. Mine is 18x18, and can accept additional clamps on the far edge for wide boards. Make the close fence replaceable, as it will act like a zero clearance insert and get chewed up. Use RIP blades for the vertical cuts with the jig, and cut the cheek waste free in a crosscut sled with stop blocks. I mated a set of Freud 24T blades to the setup. The blades were only ~ $35 each, and are inexpensive to resharpen. Again, the jig is extremely easy to make and repeatable cuts are no-brainers with the twin blades.

Parts too long and heavy for the jig get done flat, in my dado sled with stop blocks. This takes more futzing, as depth of cut adjustments need be set carefully. Once you're there, you can cut identical tenons all day long.

Mortise first, as the tenons are easily adjustable... :)

Posted

Since this topic is already up, I won't create a new one for my question. PM mortiser or the General with the tilting head? I was looking at the PM but saw the General and the tilting action looks really useful. How good is it in comparison?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 43 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined