JimB1 Posted December 28, 2011 Report Posted December 28, 2011 Just tossing some ideas around here but since I already have the Lie-Nielsen Dovetail saw, standard 15ppi not progressive, does it make sense for my next saw to be a carcass saw to handle crosscuts for tenons? I realize the depth of cut is less then the tenon saws but it should be decent for everything other then the longest through tenons I would think. I'm just trying to maximize my cash and get the most bang for the buck... alternatively I could spend a little more and get the crosscut tenon saw. Then if I find the dovetail saw's depth of cut is an issue, it's a matter of saving up for the rip tenon saw. Currently I really do most of my joinery using power tools so I have to lean heavily on recommendations for hand tools since I don't have all that much experience with them... Any ideas would be appreciated... Thanks -Jim Quote
Morton Posted December 29, 2011 Report Posted December 29, 2011 Jim - I bought the LN progressive pitch dovetail saw and the LN small carcass saw at the same time. I use the carcass saw about 10x more than the dovetail saw (you can tell how many dovetails I cut I use it for cutting all sorts of small parts - it works really well with a bench hook (I bought one from Bad Axe, but they are easy to make). The small carcass saw is a nice size for all small to medium size parts. You could do small tenons, but nothing large since it won't cut very deep. But I use it all the time for making accurate crosscuts in stock. I also went with the LN saws because if I ever change to a different size/brand you can easily resell and lose almost nothing. They retain their value that well. Quote
jmaichel Posted December 29, 2011 Report Posted December 29, 2011 Jim - I bought the LN progressive pitch dovetail saw and the LN small carcass saw at the same time. I use the carcass saw about 10x more than the dovetail saw (you can tell how many dovetails I cut I use it for cutting all sorts of small parts - it works really well with a bench hook (I bought one from Bad Axe, but they are easy to make). That makes me feel better knowing that someone else bought Bad Axe bench hooks instead of making their own . I have both a LN Rip (10 PPI) and X-cut (15 PPI) carcass saws. The only real problem is there depth of cut. Not so much an issue with the crosscut saw but a bigger issue with the rip/tenon saw. I think there will always be a need for a small X-cut but I wish I had a larger tenon saw. I imagine sometime later this year I will be springing for bigger Bad Axe X-cut and Tenon saws. For the price I think LN's are an excellent saw and there will always be a place in your shop for them but over time you will end up wanting more depth on you back saws IMHO. Good luck! Quote
ChrisG Posted December 29, 2011 Report Posted December 29, 2011 The carcass would be a good option, but my personal preference would be for an xcut tenon saw that is longer (14" for example). The depth is less important but if you have only one xcut saw you will end up being glad you have the extra length. I have the LN 15ppi Rip Carcass and their 14" xcut tenon saw. Love both saws, but I do have a qualm with the tenon saw in that it is a fairly thick plate (.032") by modern standards. This isn't a huge deal, but thinner plate saws do cut a little nicer in my experience. The LN carcass saws have a nice thin .020" thick plate, but if you do end up getting a larger saw my recommendation would be to get one with a .025 (or even .020) thick plate, which would mean, Adria, Wenzloff, Gramercy or Bad Axe instead of LN. All that said, if you only intend to use the xcut for small tenon shoulders and other joinery xcuts then the carcass saw would be great. I like the longer tenon saw because I frequently use it to cut pieces to length and the longer saw plate really makes things work better in pieces that are more than 3-4" in width Quote
bois Posted December 30, 2011 Report Posted December 30, 2011 Hey, not sure if you guys heard, but I won a Bad Axe tenon saw at WIA11 . So far though, I've found that I only really use my carcass saw or tenon saw for large tenons that I can't cut on the TS. On the other hand, I do hand cut a lot of dovetails, so that saw gets a ton of use. I'd say the carcass saw is going to be more versatile than a tenon saw, but I typically use the two in conjunction. You could use your dovetail saw in lieu of the tenon saw (both are crosscut saws) but you'd be limited to fairly short tenons (that you could fairly easily cut on a router table or table saw anyway). It all comes down to the type of work you do. Quote
jimithing616 Posted February 3, 2012 Report Posted February 3, 2012 Hey, not sure if you guys heard, but I won a Bad Axe tenon saw at WIA11 . So far though, I've found that I only really use my carcass saw or tenon saw for large tenons that I can't cut on the TS. On the other hand, I do hand cut a lot of dovetails, so that saw gets a ton of use. I'd say the carcass saw is going to be more versatile than a tenon saw, but I typically use the two in conjunction. You could use your dovetail saw in lieu of the tenon saw (both are crosscut saws) but you'd be limited to fairly short tenons (that you could fairly easily cut on a router table or table saw anyway). It all comes down to the type of work you do. actually dovetail saws are filed rip, not crosscut. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.