Tony Wilkins Posted May 1, 2012 Report Posted May 1, 2012 When someone suggested that bench hooks would be a big help I went to see how they were made. I found the Bad Axe version that looked really good. Then I got to thinking that I could make my own. And then I got to thinking of how good the Bad Axe version looked and the wood they used. Then I just go confused. So is this one of those you need a workbench to build a workbench things? So order or buy? Quote
daneger Posted May 1, 2012 Report Posted May 1, 2012 In my shop, material for the bench hooks and shooting boards all came from the scrap pile. So they were free, other than a few minutes to true them up, apply some glue and clamps, and ensure a right angle. The Bad Axe hook set isn't too expensive (2 hooks for $45 + tax + shipping) so not a major investment. And it has the added advantages of being really stoutly built and already having some saw kerfs for mitering. Now if your saw didn't cut those kerfs, it won't fit perfectly and you might not get a clean 45 (if too loose). Plus the miter kerfs will open up over time because of the saw set, so they won't stay accurate. No disrespect to Bad Axe, but I prefer the shop-built version. To me, building my own tools, jigs and fixtures hones my skills - cheap, fun and educational! Quote
James Finley Posted May 1, 2012 Report Posted May 1, 2012 Tony, I have both shop made versions and a set of the Bad Axe hooks. If you have the budget and would rather spend your time building other stuff, you can't go wrong with the BA hooks. Even if you do buy them I think you'll decide eventually to make more, to accomodate a wider variety of work sizes, tools ( I made a set for my pull saws) etc. Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted May 2, 2012 Report Posted May 2, 2012 I'd make them first. They take 5-10 minutes each, if you stop to have a glass of water. After using the shop made versions you notice some value added features on the purchased versions, pop for them at that time. Quote
EricFortin Posted May 2, 2012 Report Posted May 2, 2012 You seem to be inclined to japan tools. Keep in mind that Japanese saws work on the pull stroke and that the bench hook has to be used on the opposing side of the workbench. So depending on the width of your bench, it might not be comfortable to saw with a bench hook that has been made by a western saw maker. Quote
jHop Posted May 2, 2012 Report Posted May 2, 2012 Alright, how about a blacksmithing viewpoint? Metal bench stays are a simple form of metal smithing. Even using modern materials. You can make your own, with very little cost. Starting with a piece of round bar stock, you can either bend it cold or forge it - with "forge it" referring to adding heat. Adding heat makes it more malleable, but changes the material structure. Yes, metal has grain, too. It doesn't take much pressure to put a curve into this, the most work you will do is the pad that holds the material in place. Quench it, and you don't need to temper it, but most self-respecting metal guys would do at least some tempering work. total time, maybe thirty minutes. Maybe. if you had to start the fire from a match and harvest your own tree or coal. And yet we ooh and ahhh over these. Relating this to bench hooks, it's a simple thing. Any square chunk of left over plywood can do, just cut off a couple of strips to hold things in place and attach using your favorite fastener. What's more basic and readily available just about anywhere than Plywood? maybe round bar stock for metal... (Or is that just me, since I know where to look?) What you're paying for is the name, the apparent quality (not to discredit Bad Axe; they've got some durned good quality), and the convenience that you 1) don't have to make it yourself, and 2) don't have to figure out how to make it yourself. In fact, the amount of time you spent reading this reply could probably have been used to make two bench hooks... and maybe even a shooting board... Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.