Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Damaged old walnut table top

Featured Replies

My old solid walnut table just came back to me after several years of rather hostile territory use. The top was in sad shape when it left & now it is in very sad shape. In addition to many discolored splotches, etc. it now has a couple of places where the wood is beginning to split. I am a clueless grandma here & not in a position to consider trying to refinish at this time, but would like to do what can be done to safely clean up and help the surface, hopefully encouraging the cracks to tighten back up, in a non-toxic way since I am chemically sensitive. Is it as simple as using some kind of natural oil on it? Thoughts & ideas?

Thanks much.

Your first priority should be to correct the cracking/splitting. If left unattended it will continue until it breaks.

You can correct a split with some wood glue and a clamp. Just squeeze the glue into the crack and clamp it. If you don't have a clamp, I would just ask around the neighborhood or your family, I am sure someone can spare a clamp for a day or two. Be sure to use "Wood Glue", I reccomend Titebond, but Gorilla or even Elmer's Wood should do the trick. Be sure to keep it clamped at least 12 hours. There is limited air flow once you clamp, so the reccomended 1-2 hours may not be enough. Error on the side of caution and keep it clamped as long as you can.

Ask for oils/refinishing. The first thing to access is what finish was on it to begin with. An furniture oil may help to mask some small scratches and bring a luster/shine to the wood. However, if the furniture was finished with a poly or lacquer, the oil would likely just sit on the surface, and not do any good, or worse, cause an uneven finish where the original finish has worn off. I use "Butcher Block Oil/Wax" or "Orange Oil" when I know the wood is exposed and I want a chemical free finish. Both can be bough at a big box store like Home Depot or Lowes.

Hopefully another poster may have a better idea for here, but in my experience when there is inconsistent damage to wood, the only way to really repair it is to strip it down and start over. That would include relatively harsh chemicals, or some (ok, more like lots of) elbow grease with a sander/sandpaper.

  • Author

Thanks, Chris. I have Elmer's wood glue, but don't understand how I could clamp the broad expanse of a dining-room table top. The splits are in spots that have obviously gotten wet, but are narrow--the widest one just lets my thumbnail down into, if that makes any difference.

Can you upload an image of the table?

Now that you mention moisture, I didn't think to ask, but is the wood rotted out where there is damage? Is it flaky, or spongy feeling?

Without knowing the shape and location of the cracks, I can't reccomend a clamping method. If the table is square or rectangle, you should be able to apply gentle pressure with a large bar clamp or pipe clamp.

If the table is round, then it gets trickier, and more dependant on the location/size of the crack.

  • Author

When I have time for a learning curve, I'll try to figure out the picture thing.

The damaged places are dry & somewhat rough feeling around the splits, but not flaky or spohgy.

It's a rectangular table, 44" x 57" without the leaves.

post-7224-0-51420100-1354737570_thumb.pnSo for a rectangle table, especially of that size, you are likely going to need a large clamp. A pipe clamp would probably be the most economical option is you need to buy one (Sample Here). But again, ask around. It's not unusual for a hobbyist woodworker or DIYer to have 48-50" clamps. Hopefully the 44" is the cross grain section and the 57" is the straight grain. If its the other way around, you are going to need a big mother clamp!

So, you want to place the clamp perpendicular to the split. You squeeze glue into the crack and let gravity do it's thing for a minute or so (Put a paper towel on the floor below the table, because glue may drip threw). Then just tighten the clamp until the crack is closed. You may want to put a piece of scrap lumber or folded up paper towel between the clamp end and the table. This will prevent the clamp from marring the table. Then just wipe any glue away that you can see (top and bottom). Let it sit overnight and then you can remove your clamp, it should hold the crack closed. Any excess glue can be scraped or sanded off, but it may damage the finish on the table doing so. So it is important to get as much glue up while it is still wet. (I found that moist paper towel or those alcohol wipes used for cleaning in the kitchen work pretty well at getting that stuff off while it is wet.

Beech - is that just a cargo strap? I'll second that - I used a couple cargo straps to re-tighten my basement steps (which had started to work their way apart over the years). You definitely get some pretty good clamping pressure out on those.

  • Author

Chris--thanks much. The long way is perpendicular to the split, but the measure is with the 2 butterfly leaves up. With them down, it's only 2 ft.. Will have to see if can get a grip on the edges.

Beechwood-thanks for the info on the cargo straps. This ol' grandma may just have to get some & figure out how to use them. They sound really handy.

Beechwood-thanks for the info on the cargo straps. This ol' grandma may just have to get some & figure out how to use them. They sound really handy.

You may want to put some cardboard or something on the edges of the table, to keep the straps from digging in. With a hard wood like walnut it shouldn't be a problem, but just in case.

  • 2 weeks later...

I'd also consider some cauls, to reduce the need for some of the clamps. This can be a simple 2x4 with some slight sanding on the opposing corners to create a slight arc. (Slight being the important word.) A couple pieces of cardboard and a caul or two could prevent a lot of scratching while clamping. Plus it gives you more room to maneuver for finding a less awkward clamping location.

  • 4 weeks later...

Were it me, I would be for slowing down the process until we can see precisely the damage, both the splits and finish before working on a fix that may or may not yield satisfactory results for you. We need good pictures for a good recommendation. I'm presuming we aren't dealing with a precious antique, but that would be clarified by pictures.

Often splits in old work are the result of changing moisture content due to humidity changes where the tables has been living. If the top boards are attached to the apron in a way that they can't freely expand and contract, the wood tries to pull itself apart which usually results in a split. Sometimes it opens or widens and eventually closes seasonally. Sometimes it doesn't. At any rate, the underlying cause needs to be fixed first or the cycle repeats.

Of course there could be other causes and pics might reveal them.

As far as finish, most often spot repairs of damage that has affected the colour is a very tricky business to do well. It isn't impossible to hit an acceptable match to the surrounding colour, but it's usually a painfully long process and expensive because you might need to buy a variety of different colours of stain to achieve a close match to the old finish, and then apply a number of clear finishes for top coat. There are products on the market that soften the existing finish (finish restorers) which might allow you to 'redistribute' it, but that often results in a totally unsatisfactory result. Presuming this isn't a valuable antique, most often the best, cheapest and fastest way is to remove the finish from the entire table-top by either stripping it or sand it in it's entirety, and then colour (stain or dye it to an acceptable colour) and top coat it to give the sheen and durability you want. If the legs and apron is in good shape, it usually isn't necessary to do other than clean them well and perhaps renew the top coat while doing the table top.

Attempting to clamp spits in old wood works sometimes depending on the location and cause, but often doesn't because of the extreme clamping pressure required to get the fibers to flex back to their original position which closes the gap. Depending on what the pics reveal, the right answer could be clamp shut, clamp and glue to stabilize and fill the remainder of the gap, or even leave it alone and fill with coloured epoxy.. and there may be more obvious and better options when we see it.

You may even decide to live with it as is and throw a suitable table cloth on it... problem solved. That's what the majority of people do.

Another possibility is to have a refinisher take a look and recommend. If it's straight-forward, the cost might be surprisingly moderate.

My 2 cents.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.