one large dust collector/several small?

1 post in this topic

been thinking of adding some better dust collection to the school. i dont know if i want to push the school to buy a big unit that would involve duct work ect.... or if i want to just get several smaller 1hp dust collectors.

1hp unit unit for router,jointer and planer.

1hp unit for 2 large belt sanders and palm sanding station

1hp unit for 2 band saws radial arm saw

1 hp unit for sliding miter saw and drill press

i priced some local porter cable dust collectors that was 150 dollers each

or i can buy a 4-5hp dust collector for all my machines......

the shop length is 95 feet with 10 average machines and we can aften have 3-4 machines going at once.

what we have now is a 1hp unit that is spread out over too large a space with a couple shop vacs to help out as we need them.

would it be just as usefull to have several dust collectors spread out to different sections of the shop or should we invest in a unit that can suck dust from the entire shop?

honestly not shure that i cans swing a big unit so what kind of comparison will i have with several small units to a big one?

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Popular Now

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Little Lipper (cool router accessory)
      I can't think of a more useless tool and it's the first thing I would use if I wanted 9 fingers instead of ten. Anyone else notice the guy using it has a cut knuckle?
    • Kitchen remodel
      I would do 1/4" plywood for the sides of the cabinets, and veneer for the face frames. You can cover the plywood with the veneer. Depending on how clean the MDF is you might need to glue a thicker shop made veneer over the face frames instead of the thinner stuff. Here is a how to on simple shaker doors using a table saw  
    • Here we go. Roubo from scratch
      Sexy kinda. the back slab with all the knots  is upside down with epoxy in them. I was able to orient most of the defects to the bottom, there are two small ones on the top but I'll fill those after the final flattening. One cool thing I've learned so far on this build, my old craftsman #5 that I could never get to take a good enough edge to take fine wispy shavings, will do work as a scrub plane. I knocked the corners off cave it a decent hand honing and it made short work on getting the bottoms flat enough. I'm really happy I can use it for something. It may be a 15$ plane but it was in my grandfathers tool box when we cleaned out his garage.  Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
    • Table saw from Craig's list's a compact direct drive saw with a universal motor, short table, etc.  "DD" in the suffix means direct drive.   These should have more potential...are any nearby?: (might need a fence)
    • basic sharpening
      Sharpening is a world all its own and pretty subjective. Buy some cheap stones that are atleast 2" wide preferably wider, and learn to sharpen free hand. It doesnt matter what they are. Diamond, water, arkansas, etc they all work well. . I wouldnt get too invested in any one system or buy any guides to start. Watch some vids (paul sellers and rob cosman), learn the ropes and get a feel for what your individual sharpening needs are, then you'll have a better idea what you really want. . Fwiw im currently using king water stones. Theyre cheap, they cut fast and give a great edge but they wear down quickly and require regular reflattening which is not really a big deal. Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G890A using Tapatalk
  • Popular Contributors

  • Who's Chatting

    There are no users currently in the chat room