Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Turbine vs. compressor

Featured Replies

Franklin's post got me thinking about my current setup, its limitations and perhaps with the collective knowledge here I can set off in the right direction.

 

I currently have a compressor setup for spraying with two needle sets. If I recall correctly it is a wagner conversion hvlp gun run off a 20g air compressor that is about 10 y.o. The gun works ok, but I think its better suited to spraying thinned paints than to other finishes. With WB polyurethanes, it sometimes would spit small round particles that were practically dry as they were coating the board, never could get a wet surface without flooding. Works ok with shellac and lacquer.

 

Should I get a different (read better) gun or move over to a turbine setup?

It might be the gun.  I have a conversion gun on a 20g compressor and am able to shoot shellac and WB coatings like Polyacrylic with no difficulty (no thinning on that WB either).  I got the QS-125WB gun from Jeff Jewitt's Homestead Finishing site.  He has a few more accessories now since when I bought it, but it works well after you play with it a bit.

 

I also have a Fuji Super 4 turbine (uh, 4 stage :))  Sprays great; excellent atomization.  I've only needed to thin latex paint a bit once to do some trim on the house; otherwise it has only seen WB finishes.  Super 4 was the predecessor of the Q4 and simply isn't "quietized" like the Q4.

 

The conversion gun can get into smaller places if I need it and though it is gravity-feed, 3M cups let me shoot upside down.  Otherwise, my preference is the Fuji turbine.

 

Those, and Apollo turbine, and a couple small touch-up guns are all I have experience with.  If you are looking at the Earlex as a turbine, I'd just caution you that they are 3 stage not 4; their site's "technical specs" don't point that out.

If you are looking at the Earlex as a turbine, I'd just caution you that they are 3 stage not 4; their site's "technical specs" don't point that out.

 

If I'm not mistaken, the Earlex 5500 is actually only a 2-stage turbine. I think you have to bump up to the Earlex 6900 to get 3-stage and at that price point, you're probably better off looking at Fuji. Unless one plans on spraying latex routinely, a 4-stage unit is probably a little overkill for most clear finishes. I've been using the Q3 for years now and it works great.

  • Author

Thanks guys :-)

 

Paul, why do you like the turbine better?

Ace, why do you prefer the gravity feed gun?

 

My experience to date is using the wagner gun which is a 1 qrt cup. While tiring after long spray sessions, the convenience of having enough material mixed and ready to go makes up for it. I don't know whether its the compressor or the gun, but my compressor ends up running too long to keep up with the demand of the spraying. Getting a bigger compressor is one idea but at that point I had started to look at the turbine systems.... but turbine's can't fill up bike and car tires ;-)

Thanks guys :-)

Paul, why do you like the turbine better?

Ace, why do you prefer the gravity feed gun?

My experience to date is using the wagner gun which is a 1 qrt cup. While tiring after long spray sessions, the convenience of having enough material mixed and ready to go makes up for it. I don't know whether its the compressor or the gun, but my compressor ends up running too long to keep up with the demand of the spraying. Getting a bigger compressor is one idea but at that point I had started to look at the turbine systems.... but turbine's can't fill up bike and car tires ;-)

Just easier on my arm, feels more balanced than a conventional. And requires less air pressure. To me the fluid seems to flow nicer out of the gun.

Thats just me!

-Ace-

Your compressor being only 20g should only run LVLP. If you are on the fence and want to future proof a purchase, I'd go with something like mine. An appolo 7500 series gun. It will run off your compressor, only needs 7cfm @ 45 psi. but will run off any turbine as well. This gives you HVLP at LVLP air volume.

You get gravity feed and gravity pressure feed. Bottom pressure feed without the woes of siphon feed. You can add a pressure pot line to the bottom feed if later you decide you need more volume. Add PPS pressure cups to either top or bottom feed. All with just one gun.

When your compressor dies you can either buy a new compressor or turbine its up to you. The connection is the same on all turbines except the little Earlex vacuum cleaner.

Care to elaborate?

 

Sure will buddy :) I have Sears 20 Gallon, 2 cylinder which has quick recovery. Air pressure has never been an issue for me.

 

-Ace

I use the spray gun linked below on my little 6 gallon pancake compressor.  No issue with atomization.  I set the pressure to the minimum which just barely gives me the minimum CFM.  I just have to be mindful of the compressor motor, as it will run.  This translates into only being able to finish smaller projects.  I will be using this setup this weekend to spray shellac on to my hand tool cabinet.  I only need to spray a couple projects a year, so it doesn't make much sense to buy a high-end turbine.  Someday, I hope to justify the purchase of the Earlex 5500.  I really can't justify buying a bigger compressor at this point as the only other uses I use it for are the nail guns, the occasional tire, and sometimes the need to have air to blow dust away.

 

 

http://www.woodcraft.com/product/2021128/25126/woodriver-pro-hvlp-spray-gun-with-600cc-plastic-cup.aspx

Thanks guys :-)

 

Paul, why do you like the turbine better?

 

I get a nice spray from both the conversion gun and the turbine.  The turbine is just so easy to use... carry the 1'-cube out with the hose, unlatch gun, fill pressure pot, latch gun, turn down the fluid knob, quick-connect hose, turn on, spray.  Usually takes a couple seconds to prime and adjust the gun to what I want.  Cleaning is as simple as pouring off and cleaning the pressure pot then fill with soapy water and tape the trigger back so it sprays the whole pot while I put stuff away.

 

For the gravity-feed conversion gun, I use 3M PPS cups so I can spray upside-down.  Priming the gun takes a bit longer since I want the PPS cup collapsed for upside-down spraying (if necessary) and I find I need to fiddle longer with the gun to get a good wet coat.  I find cleaning this gun takes longer or is at least less "hands-off" vs the Fuji gun.

 

It is likely that I don't spray that often and that's why the extra care the conversion gun seems to need leans me to the turbine.  Really, though, that turbine, you could turn your brain off and get a good finish; have a friend around to turn it back on, though.

  • Author

I love the idea of the gun that can be used with both turbine and compressor, however.... ouch, to get an additional aircap, nozzle and needle is over a c note!! I will have to dig up the specs on my compressor. Maybe the specs lie...

 

Thanks Mike, I often do larger projects and still need to be able to spray paint whether it be oil or latex. (another thread on that soon)

Ace, can you share the model number on the sears unit.

 

Thanks all :-)

No problem.  I have only sprayed shellac, which tends to spray well anyway.  I am not sure I would have as much luck with thicker finishes.  As I said, I do want the Earlex so that I have more options available.

I love the idea of the gun that can be used with both turbine and compressor, however.... ouch, to get an additional aircap, nozzle and needle is over a c note!! I will have to dig up the specs on my compressor. Maybe the specs lie...

 

Thanks Mike, I often do larger projects and still need to be able to spray paint whether it be oil or latex. (another thread on that soon)

Ace, can you share the model number on the sears unit.

 

Thanks all :-)

The one it comes with will spray anything from dye to WB poly. I never spray latex unless its on my house walls but would need a bigger needle for that.

Any compressor is only going put out 3 to 4 cfm per Hp closer to 3. As soon as the motor starts your maxed out. Most hvlp guns consume 9 cfm. So irregardless you a loosing volume as soon as the compressor starts and need to stop and let it recover. That's more stopping than spraying. The average 20g compressor will barely handle lvlp and the cheaper ones under 2 hp won't do lvlp well. No way a pancake will handle anything other than very thin shellac or water and not for more than couple seconds at a time with an hvlp gun. It's all about volume a pancake unless its one of those gas powered industrial truck mounted ones is going to self destruct if used to spray.

air-compressor-150psi-twin-cylinder_1.jp

 

Chopnhack...this is similar to mine. Old garage sale find. They still sell the rebuild kits for this baby! And finding parts is no problem either.

 

-Ace-

 

P.S. I have sprayed many (small) projects using a pancake compressor and an hvlp spray gun. The spraying gets tough when your trying to apply a nice wet coat to say........a 25x50 coffee table top. Then compressor has a hard time keep up.   

  • 1 month later...
  • Author

Ace, that is a heavy duty unit! I have an old Husky and the motor is probably tiny and is hidden by the cowling so we can safely assume its not a true horse power rating...

I have an Apollo turbine. I spray waterbourne finishes and some solvent based stains. The air from the turbine is warm which helps with the water based finishes drying in the winter.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.