Recommended Posts

Posted

Yes, I am pretty sure he was comparing them to Lie-Nielsen.  Rob used to be a distributor for them.  When Lie-Nielsen changed their sales model for their tools, they cut their ties to most of their distributors (Woodcraft included).  In a few of his videos, while touting his own tool line, he made some comparisons with Lie-Nielsen that likely he was not authorized to make.  As a result he was requested to eliminate those portions of the video.

Posted

Yes, I am pretty sure he was comparing them to Lie-Nielsen.  Rob used to be a distributor for them.  When Lie-Nielsen changed their sales model for their tools, they cut their ties to most of their distributors (Woodcraft included).  In a few of his videos, while touting his own tool line, he made some comparisons with Lie-Nielsen that likely he was not authorized to make.  As a result he was requested to eliminate those portions of the video.

Well that thar explains why Woodcraft had those blades on clearance....

Posted

Just to jump in,

 

I have an IBC Cosman blade in my jack. I've probably sharpened it once since the day I bought it, and I have used it fairly regularly over a year and a half. It's still pretty sharp.

Yes I'm lazy, and I should have sharpened it many a time since then, but what I mean is that if you want a blade for a go to jack plane, they're fantastic.

While I don't really rate A2 steel, they definitely aren't kidding when they say it has good edge retention!

 

Fraser

Posted

Thanks Fraser,

 

I had looked for these in the UK but had no joy. Not looking to take the plunge just yet although I will give them consideration when my irons get too short. How do you reckon they would fare on a fine oil stone?

Posted

You found them here I take it?

I have very little experience with oil stones, only using them once or twice, but they seem very similar to water stones really... I reckon it would be fine, besides I've never heard anyone say "Oh no, I can't use A2 because I've got an oil stone"!  :D

Sadly not cheap, but for a stock removing, every day plane, I think they're perfect.

For my jointing and smoothing I prefer either an old sweetheart (or earlier) Stanley USA blade, or out of the new bunch I'm very partial to the Clifton irons. Their hot forging process definitely seems to produce great results regarding edge sharpness... I can get the Clifton much sharper than any A2 blade I have, but obviously the blade wears back quicker as a pay off...

 

Fraser

Posted

Fraser,

 

I did indeed find it there with some other rather choice offerings. I'm very lucky, I have a clifton iron! I have had it for some time and almost forgot it was in my day job No4 smoothing plane. Not really the place to get the best idea on the performance! Once I get my #4 refurb done I was going to try it against the standard record blade. Should it work well it will probably appreciate life in my tool chest more than my day job tool box. Glad to hear you have had good results with the clifton, I hope I do to.

Posted

I just put one into my #4 Stanley, even with very VERY careful; fitting, I got nicks on the edge in the file/fit/file/fit process. I will regrind on my low RPM wheel then onto water stones for final work. I have not had much of a chance to use it yet as it was just installed. I think I am going to open the mouth a little more on the Stanley, the blade has about 0.020" clearance with the frog in the rear most position, there is a lot of room to move forward so opening the mouth will give me more adjustment room. It seems to be a well made iron and breaker and like others said, it was not cheep, I expect it to serve well but at this point for me, it is all a guessing game. I am comforted by the good reports above in regards to performance.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.