Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Restoring a Rocking Horse

Featured Replies

Hello,

I'm new to this forum and pretty much a rookie when it comes to woodworking.

I recently decided to try my hand at restoring an old rocking horse for my nephew and so I thought I might ask for some advice.

Firstly, I'm embarrassed to say I need help in identifying what sort of wood I am working with. I would like to know, as it sounds like that can be an important factor in what stain/finish to use. Correct?

I have attached an image of the rocking horse and hope that can help identify the wood in question.

Otherwise, if anyone else has ever taken on such a project, feel free to share any tips or advice you may have.

Cheers!

muddy

post-14223-0-06740900-1372271873_thumb.j

Hey Muddy. Welcome to the forum. That looks like a nice project for you to sink your teeth into for a first timer. At first glance, I thought it was all maple, but the body of the horse and the head have knots that look like pine. I'm thinking it may be a combination of two woods. This is often done when manufacturers are making paint grade objects. The maple is used for the parts that will receive the most stress and the pine is used for the rest. Ponderosa pine is one of the commonest used for this. If you can get a couple small boards of maple and ponderosa pine, you could make samples to see how they will match when stained. I'm assuming you are going to stain it. If you are going to paint it, just sand it smooth, to 220 grit, and then prime and paint it to suit. Make sure you sand between your primer and first coat of paint, 220 grit, just a light smoothing sand is all you need.

  • Author

Hey Muddy. Welcome to the forum. That looks like a nice project for you to sink your teeth into for a first timer. At first glance, I thought it was all maple, but the body of the horse and the head have knots that look like pine. I'm thinking it may be a combination of two woods. This is often done when manufacturers are making paint grade objects. The maple is used for the parts that will receive the most stress and the pine is used for the rest. Ponderosa pine is one of the commonest used for this. If you can get a couple small boards of maple and ponderosa pine, you could make samples to see how they will match when stained. I'm assuming you are going to stain it. If you are going to paint it, just sand it smooth, to 220 grit, and then prime and paint it to suit. Make sure you sand between your primer and first coat of paint, 220 grit, just a light smoothing sand is all you need.

Thanks, TRBaker!

Yes, I think I'd like to stain it. I prefer that look over paint.

What would the procedure be for staining? Would I use the same grit sandpaper? That is something I don't quite fully understand yet.

Thanks again for your help. I really appreciate the advice!

Muddy, if you're staining it, sand to at least 220 (I usually go 320 to 400 on harder woods), and then apply your stain of choice. One of the problems with both maple and pine is the tendency to blotch, so that the stain isn't consistent. This can be minimized by applying some pre-stain conditioner, available at most box stores. I would use a simple wipe-on stain, per directions on the can, and then apply a coat of polyurethane varnish. Sand after the first coat is dry with xxxx steel wool and wipe clean with a mineral spirits rag. when dried, apply a second coat. If you decide to do any further coats, sand between coats lightly with 4x steel wool or 320 grit paper. All that is needed is a scuff sand. Any more questions, just ask. I hope this helps.

  • Author

Muddy, if you're staining it, sand to at least 220 (I usually go 320 to 400 on harder woods), and then apply your stain of choice. One of the problems with both maple and pine is the tendency to blotch, so that the stain isn't consistent. This can be minimized by applying some pre-stain conditioner, available at most box stores. I would use a simple wipe-on stain, per directions on the can, and then apply a coat of polyurethane varnish. Sand after the first coat is dry with xxxx steel wool and wipe clean with a mineral spirits rag. when dried, apply a second coat. If you decide to do any further coats, sand between coats lightly with 4x steel wool or 320 grit paper. All that is needed is a scuff sand. Any more questions, just ask. I hope this helps.

Hi again TRBaker,

Thanks for the continued advice.

Couple more questions for you...what exactly does 4x steel wool mean? Does that indicate how coarse or fine it is? I think I have some 'superfine' stuff lying around. Is that right for this job?

Next, how many coats of stain should a project like this require?

Lastly, I imagine the varnish goes on at the very end, yes? Not after each coat of stain, I mean.

Thanks again!

0000 grade steel wool is referred to as four aught. I think it has to do with how fine the wire is making the measurement to four places after the decimal place. When you buy steel wool it is labeled, you just have to know to look for it.

C Shaffer is correct. It is extra fine steel wool. You should only need one coat of stain, and yes, the poly goes on after the staining.

  • 3 weeks later...
  • Author

C Shaffer is correct. It is extra fine steel wool. You should only need one coat of stain, and yes, the poly goes on after the staining.

Hi TRBaker,

Sorry for such a delay in responding to your last post. The nephew arrived and things got pretty busy in a hurry!

As for the project, I am just about ready to stain it, but wanted to double-check something with you first.

I think in a previous post of yours, you mentioned sanding with a steel wool between coats, but in a later post you suggested I should only need one coat of stain. Also, in the directions on the can of stain, it says not to sand between coats.

Needless to say, I am left feeling a bit confused.

Could you let me know how many coats of stain you think I should need, as well as whether or not I should be using the steel wool if only using one coat of stain?

Hope these questions make some sense. Thanks so much again for the help.

Cheers!

Sorry to muddy the water with my advise, Muddy. Only one coat of stain is needed. Use the steel wool between coats of poly, not after the stain. You need to put at least two coats of poly on the project.

  • Author

Sorry to muddy the water with my advise, Muddy. Only one coat of stain is needed. Use the steel wool between coats of poly, not after the stain. You need to put at least two coats of poly on the project.

Thanks, TR.

Feel a little gutted today as when I checked on the horse this morning after staining yesterday, I noticed a few areas where it looks blotchy. Thought I had done a pretty good job of staining evenly, but I guess not. Will this require a complete redo or is it possible to simply redo the affected areas?

Thanks again.

What kind of stain did you use? Some guys start over. Some guys try to thin the applied stain down by wiping with solvent. The goal in this method is to begin the process again with a sealer (thinned shellac is popular.) When you pigment stain over the sealer you get more consistent penetration and far less blotching.

Some recommend instead, going over the blotched project with a semi-opaque product like a glaze. This would not be my favorite because it obscures a lot of the natural features of the wood.

  • Author

What kind of stain did you use? Some guys start over. Some guys try to thin the applied stain down by wiping with solvent. The goal in this method is to begin the process again with a sealer (thinned shellac is popular.) When you pigment stain over the sealer you get more consistent penetration and far less blotching.

Some recommend instead, going over the blotched project with a semi-opaque product like a glaze. This would not be my favorite because it obscures a lot of the natural features of the wood.

Thanks for the reply, C.

I used a Varathane brand oil-based stain. I used a conditioner on the wood first, however, as I had read that this generally prevents smudging, especially on pine, which I suspect I have.

Is it at all possible to sand the areas and re-stain?

I don't suppose the poly helps to disguise such blotches either, eh?

Starting to think I'll have to just start all over again. Argh...

Pine takes water based stains quite deeply in spots. An oil based might give you a better chance at sanding to start over. I lack the experience but i would test a small area like thebottom of the seat. Try sanding it but not removing one hundred percent of the color. Shellac seal, restain, then evaluate. An extra step or two here can save you further effort downstream.

Conditioners are well intentioned but not all equal. A good de waxed shellac thinned to what is called a wash coat has been recommended here in this forum, by most of the major hobby literature mediums, and in my training to be a superior low budget plan for minimizing blotching.

  • Author

Hi again,

Thought I would share a picture of the (I think) final product.

The chewed up front 'hoof' was sadly beyond my amateur restoring abilities, but all things considered, I think things turned out okay. Was never quite able to fully repair some blotchy bits, but oh well, I'll know better next time. Learned a lot along the way and am very appreciative of all the help I received here from the start.

The nephew has already been for his first ride and seems delighted with it, so it makes the whole process all the more fulfilling!

Thanks again, TRBaker and C Shaffer, for all your insight and advice.

Cheers!

post-14223-0-94685500-1374236587_thumb.j

The blotch is not readily apparent in this photo at this distance. Especially since you rate yourself a rookie I say well done. Count this a success and note things you would change as ideas for future projects.

  • Author

The blotch is not readily apparent in this photo at this distance. Especially since you rate yourself a rookie I say well done. Count this a success and note things you would change as ideas for future projects.

Thanks, C.

I think the biggest challenge I had was not being able to take all of the separate pieces apart, thereby making all of the sanding, staining and finishing difficult, in having to access tight and awkward areas. It was fun learning along the way though. Both my grandfather and father have woodworking in their blood, so perhaps I have finally started to get that same itch.

Would you have any suggestions for other good beginner projects?

Thanks again.

Wow, Muddy! Great job. I see nothing for you to hang your head over. Keep up the good work. There are lots more toys you can make from wood.

If it rocks and the nephew loves it then it's great.  I've yet to see a horse that's completely even colored all over.

 

I think it rocks! (Pun intended.)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.