pghmyn Posted October 15, 2013 Author Report Posted October 15, 2013 I'll just have to go contrarian today ==> June 2004 issue of Woodworker's Journal Not having read the review, I don't have the benefit of its findings or test methodology... But one thing I do have is years of direct experience with various dado stacks... including all three dado stacks mentioned previously -- plus one or two more... If you start comparing brand new/freshly-sharpened entry-level stacks against top-shelf kit, the performance can be comparable -- you can still tell which is which, but the results of the entry-level stacks can be quite acceptable... However, the performance gap widens as the stacks get used... Once they've got some time on them, the differences really start to stand-out... Trust me, Forrest gets $300 for their stack for a reason... Part of that value equation is the thickness of the carbide (allowing more re-sharpenings), part is the hardness of the carbide (retaining its edge longer) and part is the quality of manufacture... The result is that even after dozens and dozens of dado cuts, the results are still smooth... This is simply not the case with entry-level stacks --- or at least it hasn't been my experience with them . If others are getting good results, more power to them... But the important point for the OP, if your dados are hidden, it might not matter which stack you get... What do you mean by a hidden dado? Biggest use of dados for me is for attaching shelves. But, it's not always in plywood. So I think the Freud is a pretty good choice for me. But, now, should I get the 6" or 8" ? Quote
JoshC1501 Posted October 16, 2013 Report Posted October 16, 2013 I have the Pro 8" model, not sure I needed the 8" but got it anyway. It has worked well for me. I have found it to be a good value for the $. I would of liked to have the better freud model or a forest but didn't want to spend that much right now. I would say for the price you get a lot for your money. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted October 16, 2013 Report Posted October 16, 2013 Trust me, Forrest gets $300 for their stack for a reason... Part of that value equation is the thickness of the carbide (allowing more re-sharpenings), part is the hardness of the carbide (retaining its edge longer) and part is the quality of manufacture... I think Particle Board is right. It seems to me it would be like a lot of things. If you don't plan to use it that often, you may not need to fork over the cash for the Cadillac model. But if you are a heavy user, then of course you want to get a tool that suits your needs. If you cut 90% of your dados with a router, dropping big bucks on a dado stack might be silly. HHH - As long as you went contrarian. I wanted to let you know one thing. It is very unlikely that the carbide used by Forrest is any "harder" than the carbide used by Freud or anyone else for that matter. Firstly Carbide is not made in all that many places in the world. It's hardness is measured on the Vickers scale and nearly all of it used in tooling or tools is exactly the same hardness (unless an error is made or a bad shipment is received, which of course can happen.) Anyway, the "hardness" of carbide comes from the ratio of cobalt to tungsten. In general the more tungsten the "harder" the carbide. However, it also becomes more brittle and likely to shatter. Their are tool industry standards that only allow a certain level of "hardness". This is done to eliminate the likelihood of the carbide shattering (more likely chipping) during use. Everyone brings the "hardness" of their carbide up to basically the same level. Having said that, you are probably right that the Forrest can go longer between sharpening, but this is more likely due to lower porosity of their carbide (read that as higher cost carbide.) Could also be the surface finish, although you'd lose that advantage the first time you sharpen it. Or what's even more likely is that it is due to the design of the actual tooth, shape, pitch angle, all that sort of stuff. So, I hate to split hairs with you because I agree that the Forrest is likely to go longer between sharpening, but there is almost no chance that their carbide is any "harder" than anyone else's. Quote
Trip Posted October 16, 2013 Report Posted October 16, 2013 ==> It is very unlikely that the carbide used by Forrest is any "harder" than the carbide used by Freud or anyone else for that matter. There are over a dozen alloys of tungsten carbide: The most common alloys are C4, C2 (general purpose); C10 through C14 (milling grade); C1 through C3 (fine); C11, C12 (heavy duty). There are also about a dozen specialty carbide alloys. Freud uses C3 in most of their blades and a custom-formulation of C3 on their high-end blades. Forrest uses C4 on their standard-duty and a custom-formulation of C4 on their signature blades. C4 is far longer-wearing (and more expensive to work with) then C3. This accounts for much of the price difference between the blades. ==> for a guy that cuts a lot of dados it may last the occasional user years In general, I agree... But it also depends on the projects... I see the difference after a built-in or kitchen project --- that's a lot of cuts in plywood... In fact, it was a 12-sheet built-in project that convinced me to shell-out $300 for a Dado King. I was working with another guy on the project, and his cuts were so much cleaner, so I went-out and got the Dado King for our next effort... Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted October 16, 2013 Report Posted October 16, 2013 ==> It is very unlikely that the carbide used by Forrest is any "harder" than the carbide used by Freud or anyone else for that matter. There are over a dozen alloys of tungsten carbide: The most common alloys are C4, C2 (general purpose); C10 through C14 (milling grade); C1 through C3 (fine); C11, C12 (heavy duty). There are also about a dozen specialty carbide alloys. Freud uses C3 in most of their blades and a custom-formulation of C3 on their high-end blades. Forrest uses C4 on their standard-duty and a custom-formulation of C4 on their signature blades. C4 is far longer-wearing (and more expensive to work with) then C3. This accounts for much of the price difference between the blades. ==> for a guy that cuts a lot of dados it may last the occasional user years In general, I agree... But it also depends on the projects... I see the difference after a built-in or kitchen project --- that's a lot of cuts in plywood... In fact, it was a 12-sheet built-in project that convinced me to shell-out $300 for a Dado King. I was working with another guy on the project, and his cuts were so much cleaner, so I went-out and got the Dado King for our next effort... HHH check your Vickers scales on C3, C4 and Forrest's "custom" C4... you'll see what I mean. Quote
Trip Posted October 16, 2013 Report Posted October 16, 2013 ==> HHH check your Vickers scales on those... you'll see what I mean. I know, I know... I just didn't want to get into shear, grain structure, et al... You're quite correct, the 'hardness' is almost identical (like within a few percent), I should have just stuck with edge retention in a given application and left it at that... Using 'hardness' as a surrogate was a mistake and I kind of knew that at the time (and just hoped no one called-me-on-it)... my bad... But the point remains the same: C4-based alloys have better edge retention in this application over C3-based alloys... That's how I should have put it... If you are doing a set of kitchen cabinets, a C4-based blade is going to perform more consistently over the duration of the project than a C3-based blade all other factors the same... At the end of the day, that's what you are paying for in a Forrest blade.... That, and the fact that you can probably get between six and eight re-sharpenings... But for the OP, all this might not matter at all... It depends on the projects.... If built-ins, kitchens, bathroom vanities, etc are not in the picture, then most any decent stack will last years between sharpenings... Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted October 16, 2013 Report Posted October 16, 2013 HHH - Sorry man, of course, I knew what you meant, but sometimes I just can't help letting my inner Nerd out. Quote
Trip Posted October 16, 2013 Report Posted October 16, 2013 ==> I just can't help letting my inner Nerd out. Yea, no problem... I've got that inner-Engineer going as well.... I'm the kind of guy who's spends his career in R&D/Operations, not Sales/Marketing.... But there's a lesson here -- trying to simplify explanations can lead to even more confusion... Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.