pghmyn Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 I've been looking to get a dado stack for some time. I don't have the $300 to plop down on a Forrest brand. I like the Freud brand, and that's what I have in my saw now. Anyone know anything about this item? Personal experiences? http://www.rockler.com/m/product.cfm?page=10502 Quote
Freddie Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 Oh wow, another thread to hijack! Quote
Dave H Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 I have the Freud the 6" not the 8" it works just fine for my needs, I've never felt the need for the 8" dado. Quote
dwacker Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 It cuts dado's. We put one on my kids radial arm and it works fine. Quote
Freddie Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 I have one of these 99 dollar freud kits. Works good. I just dont understand why the thin shims always have to get crushed on the arbor threads all the time. Quote
dwacker Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 I have one of these 99 dollar freud kits. Works good. I just dont understand why the thin shims always have to get crushed on the arbor threads all the time. Because they are not magnetic. Order a set of magnetic shims. Quote
pghmyn Posted October 14, 2013 Author Report Posted October 14, 2013 It cuts dado's. We put one on my kids radial arm and it works fine.Basically the response I was looking for. Sharp enough for typical use? I won't be cutting endless amounts of dados, but it would be a dream to have for a plywood bookcase, instead of the straight edge and router I used at my dads. Or just doing occasional tenons. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 I've had that particular 8" forever. That was my first dado I ever owned. I have been more than pleased with it's performance. For the money, I'd say it's one of the better values in dado's out there. Today, that stack is mostly relegated to outdoor type projects, I've cut a ton of dado's in the underside of green treated lumber with that stack in order to make deck handrails. The darn thing is like the energizer bunny. Even after running all that green treat and stuff through it, it still cuts a decently flat bottom, non-fuzzy sided dado. I have NOT experienced the thin shim issue. I don't think you'll be disappointed. Quote
dwacker Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 Basically the response I was looking for. Sharp enough for typical use? I won't be cutting endless amounts of dados, but it would be a dream to have for a plywood bookcase, instead of the straight edge and router I used at my dads. Or just doing occasional tenons. I wouldnt give it rave reviews for plywood but its a good starter set. As Freddie stated the shims can get caught in the threads. Sometimes they get crushed and sometimes they just make removal a pain in the ass but magnetic shims fix that and Id get them for any stack that didnt come with them. For $100 its going to be hard to beat. Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 Oh, that reminds me. If you do end up using this dado for plywood. You will be doing yourself a favor by making a couple of zero clearance inserts for the 2 or 3 most common sizes of plywood. That and/or a little bit of blue tape on the plywood before running it, will definitely improve your results. Quote
pghmyn Posted October 14, 2013 Author Report Posted October 14, 2013 Very well, then. Added to the list as a definite purchase. Thanks. Quote
Freddie Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 Zci are on the endless list of things to do Quote
Dave H Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 I just figured out why I've never felt the need for a 8" dado stack and, that's because that's what I have is an 8" I hope this isn't on the test, I should have checked before I spoke up. Quote
dwacker Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 I just figured out why I've never felt the need for a 8" dado stack and, that's because that's what I have is an 8" I hope this isn't on the test, I should have checked before I spoke up. Most guys lie about having a bigger one not a smaller one. 1 Quote
Dave H Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 Ouch that really stings! reminds me of the old joke why do carpenters wives have depth perception problems__________________ Quote
knotscott Posted October 14, 2013 Report Posted October 14, 2013 The Freud SD208 was my first decent dado set....it's good, and is a good value. I will say that the DW/Delta 7670 set has twice as many teeth, cuts cleaner, has great shim stock in comparison, and comes with a really nice case. If you can find one near the $100 range, I think it's a better set that gives a taste of the premium sets. If price is a big factor, the Avenger 6" C4 set (same as Oshlun) is on sale for $61 shipped. It's also a good performer for the price. Quote
Chris H Posted October 15, 2013 Report Posted October 15, 2013 I also have the 6" version. I have never needed the extra diameter, but I suppose that doesn't mean I will not. It's a great little set. I love my Forrest WWII, but I can't imagine what the extra $$$ buys you when you get a premium dado. The Freud works great. Quote
jmaichel Posted October 15, 2013 Report Posted October 15, 2013 I have this set too and have not been thrilled with it. Whenever I use it, I find myself wishing that I had just paid the extra $80 and gotten the Dadonator Jr. from Infiniti. Don't waste your time with the Freud, pony up the extra cash for the Dadonator Jr. Quote
Trip Posted October 15, 2013 Report Posted October 15, 2013 Freud has several levels of dado stack... The 'pro' you are considering is at the lower-end of their offerings... To increase value, the 'pro' product has fewer cutters and requires spacers to build several stacks (specifically, 5/16, 7/16, 9/16, 11/16 and, unfortunately, 3/4)... It's performance in plywood is at the low-end of acceptable and should only be used if your dados are hidden... It's performance drops-off when the desired width requires spacers... When using only cutters, the 'Pro' gives similar results to the Freud's 'Super' (top-of-the-line stack). The 'Super' has more cutters and leaves a much cleaner cut -- especially in plywood... It's the back-up for when my Dado King is at the sharpener... One thing to consider, the 'Super' stack uses thicker carbide so it can be re-sharpened probably twice as often as the 'pro'... A non-trivial consideration for the long-run... Quote
Alan Bienlein Posted October 15, 2013 Report Posted October 15, 2013 Freud has several levels of dado stack... The 'pro' you are considering is at the lower-end of their offerings... To increase value, the 'pro' product has fewer cutters and requires spacers to build several stacks (specifically, 5/16, 7/16, 9/16, 11/16 and, unfortunately, 3/4)... It's performance in plywood is at the low-end of acceptable and should only be used if your dados are hidden... It's performance drops-off when the desired width requires spacers... When using only cutters, the 'Pro' gives similar results to the Freud's 'Super' (top-of-the-line stack). The 'Super' has more cutters and leaves a much cleaner cut -- especially in plywood... It's the back-up for when my Dado King is at the sharpener... One thing to consider, the 'Super' stack uses thicker carbide so it can be re-sharpened probably twice as often as the 'pro'... A non-trivial consideration for the long-run... I have to disagree with you on this. I have the so called lower end SD208 and it cuts beautiful cross grain dado's in Chinese plywood with chipped carbide cutters. I refer you back to this thread post #21. I also only use one size of insert for my dado setups and that is shown in the photos. 1 Quote
ChetlovesMer Posted October 15, 2013 Report Posted October 15, 2013 Okay, funny thing. I just found my June 2004 issue of Woodworker's Journal. Yeah, seriously I just found it totally by mistake and it has a review of stack dados in it. The main thing I gleaned from the article is that most of the stack dados they tested performed about the same. The Forrest Dado King turned out to be the longest lasting as far as the amount of times it could be resharpened (i.e. it had the thickest carbide chips on the blades). Although, they admitted that almost any of the dados was likely to last the average hobbyist more than a lifetime. They rated the Freud Super Dado and the Everlast DS840 as just as good as the Dado King but for a lower cost. The most interesting thing I learned from this article was this: If you have a saw at or below 1-1/2HP you should buy a dado stack with 2-wing chipper blades. These machines are not designed to spin the higher weight associated with the 4 and 6 wing chipper blades. Further more, they could not detect any difference in the quality of the cut between dados with 2, 4 or 6 wing chipper blades. They also seemed equally well balanced. They did notice that you have to push harder during a cut with dados having a 4 or 6 wing chipper blade than dados with a 2 wing chipper blade. The only feature of the chipper blades that the article did recommend looking for was the anti-kickback nubs behind the teeth on the chipper blades. Although they did not get kickback from any of the blades they tested, the articles advice (and it seems logical) is that if you are comparing two blades and one has the anti-kickback nubs and the other doesn't, you may as well get the safer one. The article is a pretty good read even for an article that is nearly 10 years old. It offered a lot of information about the design and use of dado stacks. It compared 12 different sets. If you get a chance I'd consider reading it before making a purchase. Quote
Trip Posted October 15, 2013 Report Posted October 15, 2013 I'll just have to go contrarian today ==> June 2004 issue of Woodworker's Journal Not having read the review, I don't have the benefit of its findings or test methodology... But one thing I do have is years of direct experience with various dado stacks... including all three dado stacks mentioned previously -- plus one or two more... If you start comparing brand new/freshly-sharpened entry-level stacks against top-shelf kit, the performance can be comparable -- you can still tell which is which, but the results of the entry-level stacks can be quite acceptable... However, the performance gap widens as the stacks get used... Once they've got some time on them, the differences really start to stand-out... Trust me, Forrest gets $300 for their stack for a reason... Part of that value equation is the thickness of the carbide (allowing more re-sharpenings), part is the hardness of the carbide (retaining its edge longer) and part is the quality of manufacture... The result is that even after dozens and dozens of dado cuts, the results are still smooth... This is simply not the case with entry-level stacks --- or at least it hasn't been my experience with them . If others are getting good results, more power to them... But the important point for the OP, if your dados are hidden, it might not matter which stack you get... Quote
dwacker Posted October 15, 2013 Report Posted October 15, 2013 I agree that the good results are going to be short lived but that's for a guy that cuts a lot of dados it may last the occasional user years. No stack really holds up well to plywood and melamine but the forrest does hold its edge the longest. The infinity IMO is the worse I've found at holding an edge only next to amanna shaper dados. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.