Lets talk about bandsaws..........Again!


Recommended Posts

Posted

I want to start by saying that I am not in the market for a bandsaw. I am just seeing these all the time online and am curious about the marketing strategy and how it all works. Powermatic has their PM1500 and 1800 bandsaws that seem to be on the steep end price wise. I know these saws are supposed to be very "robust", but I am not sure how far that goes and when is it time to draw the line. Laguna is famous for their Italian bandsaws and award winning laguna guides. What would sway someone to buy a PM1800 for $4800 vs an italian LT20 for $4500, or LT24x17 for $5000? Putting these back to back, what are the major pros and cons of going powermatic or laguna? 

 

 

Posted

I picked up the pm1500 a few months ago for around $3k delivered (maybe a little less).  I don't have any other 'nice' units to compare it to, but I will say that I'm very happy with it.  I've resawn 14" wide mahogany and it didn't even flinch.  Very accurate, well built and no regrets..  Dust collection is good, lots of power, quiet and fun to use..

Posted

Good question. I have the Italian LT-18 and love it.  Like Tom pointed out, the other Laguna saws (ones not labeled "Italian made") are made in China.  But then honestly so are all Powermatics; Taiwan is part of China and yes I know they are better at manufacturing though it really boils down to QC. To me a large part of it is the name: who wouldn't want the gold standard? Besides, Laguna has crappy quality control on their Chinese-made saws.

Posted

I think once you start talking about spending 5K on a band saw you need to learn to look past the hobby shop hype. With bigger better saws you dont have the same concerns as you do smaller saw.

Posted

Well going back to my op, what would be the benefitting factors of choosing a pm1800 over an italian lt20 or lt24x17 for 200 more than the 1800?

Once you get into a 24" saw that is where the bandsaw game is supposed to change. The problem is the Laguna is a little on the light side for a 24" bandsaw and still relies on the guides for resawing. The PM 18" is IMO is one of the nicest saws in its class meaning 18" saws. Then again with the Laguna being so light and still relying on guides for resawing I would say its closer to a 17 or 18" class saw rather than a 24 making it not worth as much as the PM 18.

To throw a wrench in the spokes the PM24 is real 24" workhorse, cost lest than both the saws mentioned without the hyped up features. IMO Neither the PM18 or the Laguna 24 would be a better choice than the PM24 for less money.

Posted

PB, I based my limited research on the powermatic 24 being $5,278.99 through rockler. I just checked tool plus and its 4699 and free shipping, wow! But could you explain the differences in the laguna 24 and pm 24 that make one light duty and the other tougher?

Posted

Be careful - not all Laguna saws are still made in Europe. They now have some made in China.

 

Be careful - I deal with Italian manufacturers all the time in my real job. Trust me when I tell you Italy is the China of Europe.

No offense to any Italians or Chinese who may be present. But neither country will get any quality props from me.

Posted

Sure, I used to be an engineer. Today I'm a product line sales manager for hydraulics and electronics used in mobile equipment. You know, anything that has a diesel engine on it and moves. Ag, construction, material handling etc...

  • Like 1
Posted

Be careful - I deal with Italian manufacturers all the time in my real job. Trust me when I tell you Italy is the China of Europe.

No offense to any Italians or Chinese who may be present. But neither country will get any quality props from me.

That is interesting Chet and I am sure that doesn't apply to all of the country's items. I am quite fond of Freud "anything that I have ever bought from them" LOL. I have found their items to be good at a reasonable cost. Their QC seems pretty good. Have you any input on Freud? I think they are now German owned if that makes a difference.

Posted

I'm not saying everything made in Italy is crap. I don't mean that at all. Just like not everything made in China is crap. But I will say this, I find a lot of the suppliers I deal with out of Italy suffer from the same issues the Chinese suffer from. For example if you demand a certain level of purity in the castings or the steel being used what have you, you will get that level the first year of production. But if you turn your back the second year, they will drive costs out even if it means using inferior raw materials. I have found this to be common place in both Italian manufacturing and Chinese manufacturing. This is not to say they cannot manufacture to what ever standards you set, its more like they both look for loop-holes in your spec, if that makes any sense.  

 

Similarly if you walk through Bologna every corner has a factory building gearboxes or drive trains or electric motors for half the costs compared to their German or Swiss competitors. When you make that much stuff, with that many competitors crammed into an industry everyone strives to drive every nickel out of their manufacturing. This often comes at the expense of quality control. My experience is that "matched" gear-sets quickly become "close enough" gear-sets in order to save costs.

 

Once again, I truly do not want to offend anyone. However, early in the post somebody mentioned to watch out for Chinese manufactured products posing as Italian manufactured products. My experience has been that the quality I get out of Italy is very similar to the quality I get out of China.

 

In my industry we tend to get highest quality stuff out of Switzerland, Germany, Japan, The US, Brazil, the Scandinavian Countries, The UK, Canada and Northern Europe. Which really should be no accident because these are all places that have spent the better part of the 80's and 90's copying Japanese manufacturing processes. So you would expect to find similar quality. Where as I find China, India, Italy, Mexico and some others have spent that time copying products rather than the processes to manufacture the products.

 

Note to Forum Monitors: If I just got too political please delete this post, I will not be offended.

  • Like 1
Posted

No offense chet, this is all great imformation. I learned a lot today by posting this thread, from you and other members. Im sure alot of viewers learned a few things as well. My post was simply aimed towards the marketing strategy between the saws since i thought they were two good brands for bandsaws with slighlty offset prices to the average woodworker. We ended up digging a little deeper :)

Posted

Not to take away from the op question, I surely don't take offense by what was said. It makes a lot of sense. Being that you are in an industry that has knowledge of the inner workings, do you have any information about Freud's QC?

Posted

Getting this thread back on track = Bandsaws.

I would like to one day get a new bandsaw, but I too have struggled with the money question.

I always try to get the best tool I can afford. But If I want a 18" bandsaw here's how it breaks down in my mind.

 

I can buy a $4800 Powermatic 18" bandsaw

 

OR

 

I can buy

a $1500 19" Grizzly bandsaw

a $800 Festool router

a $600 Festool dust extractor

a $1200 Festool domino XL

a $550 Leigh dovetail jig

a $160 Veritas router plane

 

OR

I can buy

a $1500 19" Grizzly bandsaw

a $1300 Powermatic Tilt table vertical mortise

a $2000 Powermatic 8" jointerr

 

OR

I can buy

3 $1500 19" Grizzly bandsaws

and 60 board feet of 8/4 Walnut

 

I am fully ready to admit that the 18" Powermatic Bandsaw has to be better than the 19" Grizzly, but I can get 3 Grizzlys for the price of the Powermatic. So my question is where does my money go when I upgrade from a Grizzly to a Powermatic bandsaw?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   1 Member, 0 Anonymous, 49 Guests (See full list)

  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined