Recommended Posts

Posted

I think I'm off to a good start but want to get some opinions before I get in over my head.

 

I've already purchased the Porter Cable PCB270TS and love it.  I figure my next sensible purchases should be a router, jointer, and planer.  Since I'm by no means a pro and would consider woodworking a hobby for me for a while I'm thinking I'm just going to get bench top models.

 

My plan is to get the Bosch 1617EVSPK Router Kit, the Porter Cable PC305TP Planer, and Porter Cable PC160JT Jointer.

 

Bosch 1617EVSPK Router Kit - Not seen anything real negative about this, offers fixed and plunge base and I figure the fixed base will mount in a table and I can swap it out with the plunge base as needed.

 

Porter Cable PC305TP Planer - I've seen mixed reviews on this and figure the only real issues seem to be with the infeed/outfeed tables not being long enough to limit snipe.  I've got a large enough bench that I can make some extended infeed/outfeed tables that should solve this.  Does that make sense?

 

Porter Cable PC160JT Jointer - Again, mixed reviews and the same thing with infeed/outfeed.  My solution for this would be the same, making longer tables.

 

I don't plan on taking on any big projects that are going to require pro-grade tools just yet and figure these three items should get me off to a good start.

 

Oh, and I am also going to get the Bosch ROS20VSC Orbital Sander as well.

Posted

Just posted this...I've never heard anyone complain about the 735 other than how they scream.  People seem to love these units...

 

 

A benchtop planer will serve you well, but I'd think long and hard about a benchtop jointer.  You can get a 6" on a cabinet for pretty cheap.  Look at Grizzly.  8" would be ideal.

Posted

Welcome to the forum Rick!

 

I have the Bosch router (among others) and really like it!  It's been a great router.

 

Can't speak for the other items that you mention tho.  I would agree with Eric on the jointer.  I had a small one from Grizzly and out grew it about 10 minutes after it hit my shop.  I've since given it away to someone who's just starting out.

 

Good luck!

Posted

The only downside I'll mention about an aircraft carrier jointer is that it takes up an obscene amount of room if you have a small shop. That said, I wouldn't get rid of mine if I could help it.

Posted

Thanks for the welcome and input.  I just saw the post about the DeWalt planer and am seriously considering it.  I should have stipulated that price is not necessarily an issue but I have to justify the need with the Finance Department if you know what I mean.  My wife and I agree that you get what you pay for, but with this just being a hobby for now, I'm finding it hard to convince myself to spend too much just yet.

 

Is the jointer as critical as I think it is?

Posted

Thanks for the welcome and input.  I just saw the post about the DeWalt planer and am seriously considering it.  I should have stipulated that price is not necessarily an issue but I have to justify the need with the Finance Department if you know what I mean.  My wife and I agree that you get what you pay for, but with this just being a hobby for now, I'm finding it hard to convince myself to spend too much just yet.

 

Is the jointer as critical as I think it is?

 

You can joint up to the planer's maximum height using a sled/jig. Of the two, I think the planer is the more critical need. You can joint with a planer, but it is very hard if not impossible to duplicate the true function of the planer with a jointer - two parallel faces. One could plane with a router and a sled, but it's a task.

 

This is the best price you'll see on that planer outside of used. The tables and the extra knives are worth about $80-$100 more. I just ordered mine last Friday and it will be here today. I don't anticipate having to upgrade from this for the next 10-15 years, and that's only if I move into a much larger space.

Posted

I have two of the 1617 router kits.  Love them.  Stay far, far, far, away from the bench top jointer.  I had the same one while it was still badged as a Delta.  The short tables was part of the problem.  The fence on it was terrible, near impossible to get 90 degrees to the tables. Getting the tables coplaner was impossible.  I tried face jointing with it a few times, and usually ended up grabbing my #7.  If you can save up for a little longer, I would strongly recommend getting a floor model jointer.

Posted

I'm gonna disagree with cochese and say the jointer decision is more important.  A planer can't joint an edge and make it 90* to a face.  A planer can't flatten a long board.  Adjustments are way more difficult on small or cheap jointers than any planer.  And while yes, you can flatten faces of a board to some extent with a planer and a sled, it's a huge PITA.  On the other hand, any old lunchbox planer can thickness a board, and they're usually around 13".  You're limited by the capacity of your jointer way more than your planer.  I'd spend the big bucks on the jointer and pick up whatever planer tickles your fancy.

  • Like 2
Posted

I was contemplating getting a 14" Jack Plane for now since I don't plan on working on any huge pieces.  I figure spending ~$125 on the hand tool now and saving for a cabinet jointer just might be the wiser path.

Posted

It's looking more and more like the bench top jointer is not a good start.  I'm sure I could handle the jig-thing with the planer, but it seems like it's more trouble than it's worth.  I read somewhere that if you buy wood already faced that jointing wouldn't be required.

 

What would I ask for at a supplier to ensure I'm getting wood that's faced?  I'm not really sure I know what that means but presume it means that at least one side of the board is square.

Posted

"Faced" means S2S or S3S...surfaced 2 sides or surfaced 3 sides.  S3S gives you two flat faces and one edge straight-ripped and 90* to the faces.  At least that's how it is when it leaves the mill.  By the time it travels across the country and arrives in your shop, it's no longer flat and straight.  It's flatter and straighter than rough stock, but it's not gonna be close to dead nuts perfect like it is when it comes off your jointer.  I really feel sorry for guys who either choose to or have to use pre-surfaced lumber.  It must be a nightmare trying to build things square with stock that isn't flat and straight.  "We'll just bend it into shape."

 

If you're thinking you're serious about woodworking, I'd put the jointer and planer in the numbers 1 and 2 priority position.  You can build a lot of stuff that will turn out "okay" with just a tablesaw and a router.  But if you intend to build fine furniture, the jointer and planer are not optional.

  • Like 1
Posted

You don't have to get an 8" jointer but a bench top model is a waste of money and trying to mill lumber by hand can be a PITA at first. You can get a 6" Grizzly jointer for under $500 and they work well set up properly. A lot of folks out there love their 735 planers, I have never owned or used one so I can't say. What I can say is that I would much rather have a Ridgid planer and 6" Grizzly stationary jointer than DW735 and a bench top jointer. I agree with what Eric said.

Posted

I will say this: at least in my area it was a lot easier to find planers on CL than jointers. You may want to scope your area out (I use SearchTempest) and see what the market is like. I found my planer within a couple hours, the jointer took at least six months. People kept scooping up all the decent ones within hours.

Posted

Thank you all for the advice, this is exactly what I needed.

 

If you're thinking you're serious about woodworking, I'd put the jointer and planer in the numbers 1 and 2 priority position.  You can build a lot of stuff that will turn out "okay" with just a tablesaw and a router.  But if you intend to build fine furniture, the jointer and planer are not optional.

 

I don't think I'm to that point yet.  I've got several ideas for small projects to get the feel of things.  I haven't done anything in a shop since I was in school and that was many, many moons ago.

 

I think the table saw and router projects are what I'm going to be doing for a while.  The jointer is definitely moving up to the top slot though.  I don't know how "fine" my furntiure will turn out, but I do know a "fine-ass" woodworker will be producing it.  ;)

Posted

Hey Rick. Welcome to the forum. I agree with  what Eric said as well. You'll never regret the extra money spent on a good jointer. I personally have the Dewalt 735 and love it. You'll love how easy it is to change the knives on it, and for a beginner, that is a big plus. It is also two speed. At the slow speed it really comes out baby-butt smooth.

Posted

I may have found a Ridgid JP0610 for ~$300.  It's not new, but still new in-the-box.  I've seen pretty favorable reviews for it and figure this is a pretty good deal.  Still around the priced range of those benchtop models.

Posted

That's actually a good question because I don't really know what my budget should be.  The benchtop models don't seem to be all that snazzy so it's going to have to be a floor model to get the best results.  I'm not building furniture so I don't think I need a ~$1000 model.  I only saw the 6" Ridgid last night for $300 and thought that might be a good start.

 

With all that being said, I'd say ~$400 is my budget and I could not go over $500 for now.

Posted

If it is really is NIB than I would say go for it. Offer around $250 and see if they bite. The truth is that it could be a couple years before a NIB jointer shows up on CL for $300. You are not going to get any better performance out another sub $500 6" jointer than you would out of that Ridgid. Unless you found a really good deal on an older 8" jointer.

Posted

I haven't pulled the trigger on the Ridgid 6" but now have a line on what I think is an old Craftsman 103.23900.

 

$250 for NIB Ridgid 6" or $125 for a Craftsman (King-Seeley) 6 1/8"?

Posted

Craftsman it is!

 

I went and picked it up earlier today.  This thing is solid and works like a champ.  I've got it dialed down to close to 1/32 I believe.  The indicator doesn't go below 1/8, but I have it fairly close to the "0".  There's a notch half-way between the 1/8 and 0 which I presume is 1/16.  I have it between that mark and the 0.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Who's Online   0 Members, 0 Anonymous, 46 Guests (See full list)

    • There are no registered users currently online
  • Forum Statistics

    32.1k
    Total Topics
    437.6k
    Total Posts
  • Member Statistics

    26,009
    Total Members
    3,644
    Most Online
    Joseph b
    Newest Member
    Joseph b
    Joined