Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Screwed Up

Featured Replies

So, I finally finished a large top table, 70x48". It's going to be a kitchen table. I applied mini wax spar urethane as a finish. I think it sucks. Should I sand it all off? Sand it down and use general finishes arm r seal? Or should I set the thing on fire.

==>^^

Fire... Definitely fire... :)

 

As you discovered, spar urethane is not really a great finish for kitchen tables... Outdoor dining tables are another story...

 

Kitchen tables can can get light use (two adults), heavy use (family of four) or REALLY heavy use (Cub Scout pack)...

 

If it gets fairly light use, then Arm-R-Seal should be OK. If you expect heavy use, then you might look into Rock-Hard-TT-Varnish

 

If you can spray, there are other options...

  • Author

Maybe briwax on top to reduce the friction? I'm so mad at myself right now. I should have driven the 25 miles to rocker for the arm r seal. @&$:;$%#%!!

Maybe briwax on top to reduce the friction? I'm so mad at myself right now. I should have driven the 25 miles to rocker for the arm r seal. @&$:;$%#%!!

If you don't like it fix it. Lesson learned. Spar is just flexibly poly that won't crack as wood expands and contracts with extreme changes. Really nothing special applies like regular poly. Go bang your head on the table and start striping. :)

Seriously what is wrong with it. You may be able to buff it out.

  • Author

I can live with the shiny look. It feels wet, friction. That's why I thought briwax might be the answer. I don't know. Gonna give it a day or two before I decide it's fate.

Give it a week. Let it cure....hit it with a good sanding. 120 then 220. Then apply a min wax poly or tt poly. Light thin coats

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

==> Then apply a min wax poly or tt poly

Once you've got spar down, you're really limited on what you can apply over it... Anything that would make a durable kitchen table finish may (read as probably) have issues over spar. The issue with spar base is that problems may surface months down the road when strip/refinish is much more problematic...

 

The safest course of action is to strip and start over... 

 

The real lesson learned here is to finish some scrap prior to your project...

 

==> Seriously what is wrong with it. 

The real issue with spar on a kitchen table is that it scratches like crazy -- even cured. In my experience, kitchen tables are kind of the catch-all horizontal surface in the home -- it becomes the 'base of operations' for kid's homework, craft projects, Cub Scout meetings, etc -- with requisite ware/tare.

 

==> arm r seal

It's my favorite wipe-on finishe. BUT, it doesn't take lots of abuse. If the table is only used by adults, you're probably fine. With kids, pets, etc you're better-off with RHTT.

==> Then apply a min wax poly or tt poly

Once you've got spar down, you're really limited on what you can apply over it... Anything that would make a durable kitchen table finish may (read as probably) have issues over spar. The issue with spar base is that problems may surface months down the road when strip/refinish is much more problematic...

 

The safest course of action is to strip and start over... 

 

The real lesson learned here is to finish some scrap prior to your project...

 

==> Seriously what is wrong with it. 

The real issue with spar on a kitchen table is that it scratches like crazy -- even cured. In my experience, kitchen tables are kind of the catch-all horizontal surface in the home -- it becomes the 'base of operations' for kid's homework, craft projects, Cub Scout meetings, etc -- with requisite ware/tare.

 

==> arm r seal

It's my favorite wipe-on finishe. BUT, it doesn't take lots of abuse. If the table is only used by adults, you're probably fine. With kids, pets, etc you're better-off with RHTT.

:) we know the drawbacks to the finish he used. The issue sounds more like an application issue. Arm r seal is an easy out. Rhtt I think the op would have the same application issues. A drunk monkey can apply arm r seal, that's why it's popular. Spar is a long oil which is softer. So I guess officially is the "wrong" finish but that being said what's done is done. It may be repairable. Personally I'd just strip it and go for a WB poly. The benefits of RHTT is not that great to make it worth the effort. The difference between RHTT and modern Quality WB poly are so little it's not worth the work. Unless you're going to jump to a 2k or a CV its hard to beat today's WB polys.

==> A drunk monkey can apply arm r seal, that's why it's popular

:)

 

Count me as one monkey... That's exactly why I like it -- quick, easy and looks good... If the piece is small, doesn't need a bunch of protection and I don't feel like spraying -- it's Arm-R-Seal time...

 

 

==> :) we know the drawbacks to the finish he used.

Oh, I agree --- some of us know, but maybe not the OP...  and maybe not folks thinking about top-coating over spar... :)

 

==> WB polys

Didn't think of that... What your go-to WB poly?

 

==> WB polys

Didn't think of that... What your go-to WB poly?

I don't have one I'd use a 2k on a dining table. But if I had to just spray or brush one with WB poly I'd jus run to HD and get Min Wax. It test as well as as GF stuff and with a squirt of floetrol brushes and sprays better.

==> I'd jus run to HD and get Min Wax. It test as well as as GF stuff and with a squirt of floetrol brushes and sprays better

Thanks, I'll give it a whirl...

  • Author

I'm going to sawzall the thing into pieces and chunk it into the chipper.

  • Author

In your opinion what's the best way to apply urethane so that it is even.

In your opinion what's the best way to apply urethane so that it is even.

Spray but high quality brushes help if spraying is not an option.

--> A drunk monkey can apply arm r seal, that's why it's popular

 

now I understand why I like it so much. 

Hate to sound like a broken record here, but Crystalac has some really good finishes for this application..  I've used their 2000 premium on my Daughters stuff (which has taken a severe beating) and no failures..  I believe this particular concoction is spray only, but they do have other more durable finishes which I believe are brush on.   Water based and easy to apply.  :P. 

 

Worth looking at IMO....

I agree that top coating spar is not a good idea. Sorry if I made it seem that way. Sand to bare wood. Then hard poly that is what I meant by 120 then 220.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Author

Thanks for all of your input. I don't have a sprayer. I'm going to sand it down and reapply the spar as evenly as possible and just deal with it. I'll put a coat of briwax on the top to reduce the friction.The table And benches are a gift for my brother in law. He came over yesterday and said he liked it. It will get hard use. Grand kids, desk....etc. lesson learned.

Use the spar if you must, but you can get a good finish with regular old minwax oil based poly and boiled linseed oil from the home center.   Spar varnish is really no more durable than regular poly.  It is just softer (hence that gummy feel you don't like) than poly so it will expand and contract with changes in humidity.  It doesn't give you any  more protection against grand kids or even water spills, in my opinion.   

 

This article gives you instructions on how to do it.  It is basically poor mans arm r seal and like PB said, a drunk monkey can do it.  I used the same on my kitchen table over a year ago and I have two boys under 10, a baby, and a wife who doesn't know a coaster from a caster.  Still looks good. 

 

Copy/paste isn't working for me, just google "wood whisperer oil varnish blend" and you will get an article from Marc's website with instructions. 

 

I brush it on, wait for it to soak up, wipe off the excess and repeat a few times. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,009 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Joseph b Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.