Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Extreme steps to control dust in basement shop.

Featured Replies

Hello to everyone!

I am getting ready to set up shop in the unfinished part of a walk out basement.  The house is about 20 years old.  I will have about 500 sq ft of space but there is no way to put windows in the part of basement that I will be using as shop.  I am just a hobby woodworker.

 

My wife is very sensitive to fumes and dust and I am looking for suggestions on “extreme” steps to take to control dust and fumes.

 

Here is a list of the basic things I am already planning on doing to help:

  • Fully insulate and drywall the walls and ceiling of shop
  • Use my existing 1-1/2 HP Jet dust collector with canister filter
  • Use my existing Festool CT26 vac on hand tools such as sander, router, domino, etc
  • Install Norfab ductwork to each of my major machines
  • I plan on spraying only water-based finishes, but will wipe on oil based stains and the occasional shellac via brush.

 

The existing HVAC and hot water heater are 20 years old and I plan on replacing them with high effeciancy gas fired units that will both vent out through PVC pipe and get combustion air from the outside via PVC pipes.  I may enclose the furnace and water heating in their own 8’x10’ space.

I live in Kansas City MO so I need both heating and cooling in the shop for maximum comfort year round.

Admittedly, I was hoping to use the same HVAC system to heat and cool the shop that will serve the rest of the house.  I will probably cut in 1 or 2 cold air returns in the shop and then cover those cold air returns with air filters of some sort to stop most of the dust from entering the HVAC system in the first place.

I was also going to probably set up some sort of exhaust fan in the area where I would do the finishing with fresh are coming in from the outside somewhere and use this when I am doing finishing.

Fortunately, I have enough money for this project that I don’t have to worry about cost (within reason) so I am looking for suggestions and or brand names of products used by others who have taken these kinds of extreme steps to control dust and fumes in their basement shops.

 

Thanks in advance for any input.

 

David in Kansas City.

Hi David, and welcome!

Those all seem like reasonable steps, except I would be concerned about cutting in some returns into your forced hot air system, as any fumes from finishing could also get sucked in. Maybe you could cover them up when finishing so that the fumes do not get circulated to the rest of the house.

I'm in a similar situation - I have a basement shop, I use a 1.5HP delta DC piped in to all my machines, and with its 1micron filter it seems to to a good job. We recently replaced our mechanicals with high efficiency units the draw in combustion air from outside, which alleviates any concerns about down drafts or combustion. Insulating and dry walling the ceilings is a good plan and should help a lot with brightening your space.

One item I don't see mentioned is an air cleaner - the best approach is to trap the dust at its source but an air cleaner is very helpful when dust is hard to totally collect, like from hand sanding or from a miter saw.

For controlling fumes from finishing, I mounted a small window fan into a box which slides into the casing of one of my basement windows. When needed I open the window and slide the fan in, blowing out, and I open a window on the other end of the basement in the kids' playroom. This cross ventilation seems to do a good job of keeping the fumes from permeating the house.

What are you planning on insulating with?  Spray foam insulation may give you another level of protection?

How do you plan to vent the basement? What machines are you running, generally a 1.5hp dust collector is not one that would have enough power to be ducted.

Is there anyway you can vent the shop atmosphere to outdoors?  Several benefits jump to mind:

- If you can exhaust your dust collector outside, perhaps you don't need to push the air through a 1-micron filter.  This would make filter replacement cheaper and you'd gain back some CFM's.

- At some point, you're going to have to do a total cleaning of the space.  By far the easiest technique is the leaf blower method that Marc demonstrates in episode 28.

You need to work out both exhaust and intake, as well as be prepared to separate the shop atmosphere from the rest of the house so you're not wasting heat or A/C.  But this would be the first thing I'd explore.

  • Author

Hi David, and welcome!

Those all seem like reasonable steps, except I would be concerned about cutting in some returns into your forced hot air system, as any fumes from finishing could also get sucked in. Maybe you could cover them up when finishing so that the fumes do not get circulated to the rest of the house.

I'm in a similar situation - I have a basement shop, I use a 1.5HP delta DC piped in to all my machines, and with its 1micron filter it seems to to a good job. We recently replaced our mechanicals with high efficiency units the draw in combustion air from outside, which alleviates any concerns about down drafts or combustion. Insulating and dry walling the ceilings is a good plan and should help a lot with brightening your space.

One item I don't see mentioned is an air cleaner - the best approach is to trap the dust at its source but an air cleaner is very helpful when dust is hard to totally collect, like from hand sanding or from a miter saw.

For controlling fumes from finishing, I mounted a small window fan into a box which slides into the casing of one of my basement windows. When needed I open the window and slide the fan in, blowing out, and I open a window on the other end of the basement in the kids' playroom. This cross ventilation seems to do a good job of keeping the fumes from permeating the house.

 

 

John,

 

Thanks for your thoughts, let me respond (I hope I am responding correctly). 

 

  1. Regarding cutting in 1 or 2 cold air returns in the shop area although I am not an HVAC expert, I was under the impression that in any enclosed space that you need both air supply vents and cold air returns to make the HVAC air flow in a circle. It would certainly make sense to cover those returns while finishing so fumes don't get pulled into the HVAC system.  Actually I had even thought about turning off the furnace blower during my finishing episodes which usually last less than 30 mins.
  2. Regarding an Air Cleaner, yes I have a Jet Air Cleaner that I failed to mention so I will be running that most of the time in the shop.
  3. Regarding using a box fan.  Half of the basement will be my shop, the other half is a rec-room and although I could set a box fan in the doorway of rec-room of the walk out basement, there are literally no windows that can be opened back in the shop part of the basement so I don't know how effective that would be.  That was why I was thinking about using some sort of exhaust fan in the "spray booth" with some sort of piped in fresh supply of outside air.

Thanks for your thoughts.

  • Author

What are you planning on insulating with?  Spray foam insulation may give you another level of protection?

 

Hi Tiods,

 

Three of the walls are concrete.  I was going to insulate them with 2" XPS Ridged foam (Foamular Brand) glued directly to the concrete and then build stud framed walls with sheet rock over the foam.  Ceiling along with the one wall that is common to the existing rec-room will get Roxul  sound proofing insulation with sheetrock.

  • Author

Is there anyway you can vent the shop atmosphere to outdoors?  Several benefits jump to mind:

- If you can exhaust your dust collector outside, perhaps you don't need to push the air through a 1-micron filter.  This would make filter replacement cheaper and you'd gain back some CFM's.

- At some point, you're going to have to do a total cleaning of the space.  By far the easiest technique is the leaf blower method that Marc demonstrates in episode 28.

You need to work out both exhaust and intake, as well as be prepared to separate the shop atmosphere from the rest of the house so you're not wasting heat or A/C.  But this would be the first thing I'd explore.

 

 

Hi Rob,

 

I don't think I could get away with exhausting the dust collector to the outside.  This is a community of patio homes where the houses are only about 10' feet apart so I think I would be asking for trouble if I starting spewing saw dust (even small amounts) to the outside.  However I was hoping to coming with an exhaust fan to run to the outside only when I am spraying my water based finishes.  I was hoping someone else here in the forum was doing this type of exhausting in their basement shop and could give me exhaust equipment recommendations.

  • Author

How do you plan to vent the basement? What machines are you running, generally a 1.5hp dust collector is not one that would have enough power to be ducted.

 

Hello Particle Board!

 

I need to make a correction, I actually have a 2HP Jet DC1200 Dust Collector with a canister filter.  In my current shop, I have a dedicated line to my table saw, one to my 6" jointer, one to my band saw and then a fourth leg that attaches either to my drum sander or my lunchbox planer depending on what I am using.  Surprising, even though I did a really bad job running the 4" pvc drain pipe as the ducting, the 2HP dust collector with the aid of a home made trash can separator does a surprisingly good job.  Of course I use blast gates.  In the new shop, my hopes are that if I step up to Norfab duct work and actually pay attention to how I lay everything out that I should be able to get even better results from the DC.

John,

 

Thanks for your thoughts, let me respond (I hope I am responding correctly). 

 

  1. Regarding cutting in 1 or 2 cold air returns in the shop area although I am not an HVAC expert, I was under the impression that in any enclosed space that you need both air supply vents and cold air returns to make the HVAC air flow in a circle. It would certainly make sense to cover those returns while finishing so fumes don't get pulled into the HVAC system.  Actually I had even thought about turning off the furnace blower during my finishing episodes which usually last less than 30 mins.
  2. Regarding an Air Cleaner, yes I have a Jet Air Cleaner that I failed to mention so I will be running that most of the time in the shop.
  3. Regarding using a box fan.  Half of the basement will be my shop, the other half is a rec-room and although I could set a box fan in the doorway of rec-room of the walk out basement, there are literally no windows that can be opened back in the shop part of the basement so I don't know how effective that would be.  That was why I was thinking about using some sort of exhaust fan in the "spray booth" with some sort of piped in fresh supply of outside air.

Thanks for your thoughts.

  1. Stick furnace filters over the HVAC return vents to keep dust from getting into the system.  Do your finishing in a separate room that pulls fresh air from the house and exhausts smelly air outside through a pipe.  In general, if you pull frsh air into the shop then you'll be push shop air into the rest of the house.  You want to go the other way.
  2. Run the air cleaner for a few hours after you leave the shop, on a timer.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Who's Online (See full list)

  • There are no registered users currently online

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,010 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • Lolli4 Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.