Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Seeing unstained wood appearing where raised panel meets stile

Featured Replies

I have custom cherry cabinets first made & stained in July 2013.  Stain was applied with a black glaze put over the entire stain - the end effect is relatively dark, almost a walnut color.  There were alot of little dark spots on the finish of raised door panels so the manufacturer (an Amish manufacturer in Indiana - I did not deal with them directly - I contracted with a KD/installer who has been doing kichens for 14 years) took the affected cabinet doors back, stripped & restained in November 2013.  I am now noticing in the last couple of weeks that on a couple of doors, along one edge of the raised panel where it meets the stile, there is a vertical line where the stain is missing.  It was not like this at first.  Any ideas on how this could happen?  Is this a situation that would likely be covered by warranty? 

 

Also, any rule of thumb of how quickly with normal kitchen use (maybe even a little lighter than normal use) you should expect to start seeing shallow little chips, where you can actually see the natural color wood?  These chips are fairly small, but with the dark color of the stain the natural wood color stands out.  I am starting to see a few of these as well, on the doors refinished just 3 months ago and also a couple spots along the sharp edges of either the stile or panel on 7 month old doors .  I am also seeing on some drawer fronts (which were not refinished...so they were done in July 2013) the stain seems to be wear off a little in little spots at the sharp edges.  The handle is there but I don't think it's from jewelry scraping.

 

I know things can't stay pristine in a kitchen that gets daily use.  But I'm trying to resolve what might be "normal" wear & tear vs something not being done correctly, especially after just 3 months with some of these doors.  It's hard for me to imagine the vertical lines where the stain has disappeared is normal, but wonder if the chipping and stain ruboff is normal or not too.  My sister has 12-13 year old stained oak cabinets (not custom, no glazing) in a heavily used kitchen &  see very little chipping on her doors. 

I know I'm asking alot of questions and no one can see live what I am seeing. .. and there may be no real answers on some Qs ...but unfortunately we’ve have several problems with the finish on these cabinets (most notable: when first received they neglected to use the black glaze on the inside of the doors & the inside & outside were very different colors.  They fixed & gave a small discount.  I was ok with that.)  Because of this I’m having a hard time trying to figure out if some of this is normal wear & tear (at this time frame) or not and don’t know how to even evaluate that.

 

So.. any input on potential cause for the vertical unstained line appearing in particular would be appreciated.

 

As would any rules of thumb/perspective on normal expected wear, ... or if anything we might be doing could be causing any of these issues  ... would be appreciated before I decide to call the KD

 

I do not have a picture depicting the issues I've mentioned right now (but can post one later) but the attached picture shows the cabinetry color & door construction.  The door to the left of the sink that sits at the counter is actually one of the doors where I've seen the line without finish appear... the right side of the panel where it meets the stile.  (Note: this picture is before that appeared)

Thank you

 

post-14483-0-70141200-1391801248_thumb.j

If the humidity changes and the panel dries out it will shrink, which can expose un stained wood. Sometimes the panel is loose and can be shifted sideways to cover up the unstained wood, but usually there is a pin in the back center of the frame to keep it centered.

If it was one of mine id cover the panel lines under warranty I have no clue if the company you purchased from will cover the issue. Your getting the chipping because of the finish. A glaze goes over a sealed finish so when it chips it goes all the way down to the wood. This is a sign that the wood was not properly sealed and the finish did not bond. Every finish from lacquer to conversion vanishes need the proper sealer to get a good bond or will fail in a kitchen. If you look at the frame where the panel enters the groove if its a 90 degree cut and not slightly curved  this is why you see the line. Your door should have space balls, tube-its or similar.

I'm thinking the re-finisher just did a blow and go. Shot a toned topcoat of something directly over the wood and didn't stain the cherry first. So as the finish chips, your removing the color because your color is contained in the topcoat and not in the wood.

Typically a "stain" is directly applied to the raw wood. It soaks into the raw wood and becomes part of the wood. So as the wood moves, the stain moves with it. Does that make sense? Clear topcoats protect the stained wood from moisture, dirt, etc. And lays over the surface of the wood. Doesn't really get into the wood.

I guess you begin the process with the KD and hope for the best. And if that doesn't' work. The good news is your color is dark and easy to spot fix.

I hope this helps.

-Ace-

  • Author

Thank you to everyone for your replies.  They were very helpful for understanding what might be going on and also gave me perspective that what my gut is telling me is not typical for wear given this amount of time is likely true (& definitely true for the panel lines.)  We had 2 other issues with the finish I didn't even mention, 1 significant one at delivery that was addressed (really 2 in one-the most blatant being the inside of the doors were totally different color than the outside.) 1 more minor issue on the refinished doors that I didn't even go to KD about becuase I was feeling drained by all the issues (light scuffs in the clear coat.)  Very frustrating to have so many concerns, especially with a kitchen I expect to have 20 years and to have so many issues on finish in the first 6 months & given I went with the KD's "best" manufacturer option going with his Amish manufacturer (really chose that to have full flexibility on cabinet sizes & squeeze everything out of our space.)  He swears he's not had problems like I've had in the past... maybe he hasn't.  I know this manufacturer started using a new line of stains & I was the first one of my KDs clients where they were used.  I wonder if there was a fundamental change to the finishing process too. 

 

Oh another thing I just noticed after I posted this ... there is a crack in the top of a cabinet door!  Not where the rail meets the stile either.  Sigh

 

Particle Board: you said if this was one of your kitchens you'd cover panel lines under warranty... how would you typically fix the problem?  New doors? Changes to existing doors?

 

C Shaffer (or anyone):  any idea of the typical process at an Amish cabinet maker?  Do they typically do both the cabinet construction & the finishing?  Or are those 2 things sometimes done separately?

 

Anyone: can stripping doors & refinishing them lead to a compromised finish in terms of wear?  (assuming the stripping/refinishing is done correctly.  And some of the wear concerns are on the original drawer fronts that were not refinished.)

 

(With this thread & other investigation/questions I have learned way, way more about cabinet finishing than I ever wanted to knowl)

 

Thanks again to everyone.  Your input has been informative & much appreciated.

Im assuming we are talking about a Amish cabinet shop? Not a cabinet manufacturer. There is a difference and what you get is always going to be different because cabinet shops dont generally implament the processes that big manufacturers use.

I would rebuild the doors the reasoning is the wood was not dried so it shrank enough to show the finish line. For doors most companies keep pre milled lumber in temp controlled environment for a long time so movement is going to be very minimal at most. Small cabinet shops dont have the luxury of temp controlled long term storage.

When it comes to finish durability there is also a difference. Small shops dont have the luxury of ovens. We rely solely on using the products that produce the best result. Some dont use the better products because they are expensive or toxic. For example using shellac as your sealer will cause chipping because the bond is not very good to the top coat. On the other hand its cheap and fast.  One of the best ways to tell if your cabinets were made by somebody that follows the rules is to look for a KCMA sticker on the inside of the door or an ANSI label could be on the door or the back.

The bottom line is with custom cabinets made by small shops you have to have a different set of expectations. The finish is not sprayed by a computer so its not going to be perfect. Its ok to expect durability and minimal wood movement IMO. There are many that buy their lumber by the job and that is ok for face frames and trim work but door stock should be purchased weeks or months in advance so it can be milled and stored with expectations that its going into a modern home not your damp shop.

I dont know anything about the folks that made your cabinets so most is just pure speculation. Personally I would contact the maker directly and bypass the designer, they are going to be much more help. Designers are a pain in the ass and usually feed more BS to the customer than anything else.

  • Author

Thanks again for the input.  KD & cabinet maker rep are both coming over to see & discuss in a few days.  Appreciate the help!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.