CaseySnow Posted December 23, 2014 Report Posted December 23, 2014 I am looking to purchase a miter saw. I have narrowed my choices to the Bosch GCM12SD and the Dewalt DWS780. I would appreciate advice on which saw is better for me. My Definite future projects: Building a hickory bookshelf Installing crown moulding throughout first level of house ( 5 rooms) installing base board moulding in two bathrooms. Installing fir floor, using reclaimed yellow fir in upstairs bedroom. My Skill level: novice/intermediate ( converted chemistry teacher turning into handywoman) My helper: Intermediate/ advanced saw will mostly be used in my workroom in my garage, or upstairs on site when installing floor. Saw will also double as a chop saw. Any advice would be appreciated. My budget is 500$ I know the Bosch usually sells for 599, but I do have one time discount I can apply only on the Bosch at my local hardware store which brings the Bosch down to 504$ Quote
Eric. Posted December 23, 2014 Report Posted December 23, 2014 For the projects you have listed, either one would work just fine. I hear more good things about Bosch saws than Dewalt. Opinions will vary wildly...watch. Quote
..Kev Posted December 24, 2014 Report Posted December 24, 2014 For the projects you have listed, either one would work just fine. I hear more good things about Bosch saws than Dewalt. Opinions will vary wildly...watch. Eric is spot on! Opinions will vary quite a bit! I have the Dewalt and have been very happy with it. Quote
Vyrolan Posted December 24, 2014 Report Posted December 24, 2014 I don't have a miter saw and have looked at those two as well. I think the Bosch is slightly "better" and is considering the best non-Kapex, but I have to admit to being a fan of DeWalt. I really really like their LED blade shadow targeting system a lot and it feels superior to lasers to me. Quote
bushwacked Posted December 24, 2014 Report Posted December 24, 2014 Will be in the same boat soon so keeping an eye out on this Quote
Jfitz Posted December 24, 2014 Report Posted December 24, 2014 Hi CS and welcome! Both of those saws get good reviews. I have the dw718 - precursor to the 780 - and dust collection on the 780 is supposedly vastly improved over my version. I want to mention a few things you might consider..... - what sort of space do you have for the saw? The Bosch fits tighter against the wall due to the Glide system. One complaint I have with my Dewalt is how far away from the wall I have to keep it. - do you really need a 12" saw? I thought I did originally but if I do replace mine I'm going to consider a 10" saw. Larger cuts can always be done on the TS. Bosch makes a 10" glide saw but you lose a little on the horizontal and vertical capacities. Good luck with your decision and projects! Quote
CaseySnow Posted December 24, 2014 Author Report Posted December 24, 2014 I am not 100% convinced I need a 12" over a 10." The moulding, and the floor definitely do not require 12". My baseboard is borderline being 5 7/8" and 6 1/4". I am trying to match some of the existing baseboard, which is all custom boards and thought the 12" would make that job a little easier. I have an old Makita 10" chop saw, which just died on me. (freak accident involving a moving vehicle and a relative.) My Makita was a little small for some the rafters I was using as I rebuilt the dormers on my second floor. Since I need to replace my old chop saw, I was leaning towards stepping up to 12". Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted December 24, 2014 Report Posted December 24, 2014 I have the Dewalt 715 single bevel 12" non-slider. I got some advice that non-sliders had less slop than sliders. I don't know if that's true, but I've been happy with my saw. Quote
customwood montrose Posted December 26, 2014 Report Posted December 26, 2014 I have 2 of the Dewalt saws and the Bosch one. My install team prefers the Bosch over the Dewalts for the capacity being larger on the Bosch and the different slide mechanism being able to put the saw closer to a wall or object. I haven't used the Bosch much since they take it with them most everyday! I kind of take that as a really good thing. We picked the Bosch saw over a year ago on a project we had in Texas and they haven't complained once about it yet. As with any saw though, good blade equals good quality. Hope this helps. Dustin Quote
CaseySnow Posted December 28, 2014 Author Report Posted December 28, 2014 I was interested in the slider as to make certain cuts easier. For the average home owner/ DIY is the fixed or sliding better? Quote
customwood montrose Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 A fixed miter saw has limitations in its cut width where as a slider has a much larger capacity. My advice for buying equipment, buy the best you can within your budget. I would go for the slider in this case with what you have listed for your upcoming projects. Dustin Quote
..Kev Posted December 28, 2014 Report Posted December 28, 2014 I was interested in the slider as to make certain cuts easier. For the average home owner/ DIY is the fixed or sliding better? Really depends on what your "DIY" work load is. The slider has more capacity on the positive side. The downside to that is that they lose a bit of fine accuracy that we could like when using them for furniture. I have a slider and use it all the time. However, most of the time for those critical fit cuts, I usually use my table saw. Quote
CaseySnow Posted December 30, 2014 Author Report Posted December 30, 2014 The Bosch arrives In 2 weeks... Can't WAIT!! Quote
neoOberon Posted December 30, 2014 Report Posted December 30, 2014 I am looking to purchase a miter saw. I have narrowed my choices to the Bosch GCM12SD and the Dewalt DWS780. Like yourself, when I went to purchase my mitre saw, I narrowed it down to the two you have listed... Short story shorter, if I get divorced, the misses gets the kids and I get the Bosch (the one I choose). To say I love my saw is an understatement. Supposedly 10" is more accurate than 12" and supposedly single bevel is more accurate than dual...but I have ZERO complaints with my saw. Hope you enjoy your purchase as much as me... Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.