Pwk5017 Posted March 25, 2016 Report Posted March 25, 2016 I finally decided to give up on my quest for a used 20" planer at the end of February after 10ish months of combing craigslist nationally. Either an acceptable tool would show up a few states over and the freight quote would kill the economics of the deal, or a straight knife machine would show up within a 3 hour drive, but the truck rental+byrd head would kill the deal. Pretty frustrating period of time on the used market. I fear my search for a band saw might end in similar fashion. I ended up purchasing the straight knife PM209 during the 10% sale through my local shop, bought a new byrd head from my friend for $500, and should end up with a PM209HH with warranty and delivery for $3400. The other nice aspect is the 12 month free financing I received. I know there was some discussion on financing tools awhile back, and I think it is one of the only upsides to buying new. This is my first new tool purchase for the record. Now for the reason for the thread title, I STILL DONT HAVE THE MACHINE. Gah, I feel like it has been December 24th for the last 3 weeks. Powermatic didn't ship the machine until late last week, and my local shop received it a couple days ago. Hopefully I am down to a few days of waiting for them to swap cutterheads and drive it to me. I don't know how these people handle buying Felder or whatever and waiting 6-8 months for the thing to come in via Ellis Island. I sold my Dewalt 735 last week, and I am kind of dead in the water for the time being. Just bought a LN #8 for $225 off CL that I could use in the mean time.... As a major proponent for buying used machines, this was an interesting breakdown for me. I just couldn't justify spending $2500, rental truck, and 5-6 hours on a used grizzly G1033x. Other than the 1-2 grizzlies I passed on, the grand for a byrd head and installation made the break point about $1000 or less for a used 20" straight knife Taiwan machine. Good luck buying a used 20" machine for that much that hasn't been beat to death in a shop for decades. I am curious to see what Powermatic is all about when I finally get this thing in the shop. I don't own a Powermatic machine, but I do own two grizzly tools. In the end, the byrd head from a friend is what sweetened the deal and forced me to go with Powermatic. Grizzly only offer the 454 in a straight knife version, and I was worried to go with a "budget friendly" planer. If they offered the G1033 in a straight knife, I may have considered it over the PM209. As it stands, the grizzly 1033x to my door would be $3550 versus less for the Powermatic through my dealer. I have looked at these machines quite a bit and read review after review after review. I sincerely don't believe there is much difference between the pm209 and the G1033. I might get torched for this, but I have seen them both in person and it is hard to discern the difference. I guess my point is there is a reason both tools are so close in price point after PM's sale price. I am confident both machines would perform well for me. In the end, the PM allows you to save by installing the byrd after the fact(plus, it IS a byrd head, say what you will about grizzly's cutterhead, I want the real deal helical head), it comes with built-in mobile base which saves a bit(heard the casters suck though), 5 year warranty versus the 1, and I cant deny Powermatic's resale value is better. Not saying I want to sell this machine 5 years from now, but if I have to, I am confident to recoup most of my money after 5 years of price hikes. I wouldn't be surprised if the 209 sells for $5k 5-7 years from now, and my used machine would fetch 3000 pretty easily. Cant wait to get it in my basement. Quote
Cliff Posted March 25, 2016 Report Posted March 25, 2016 I personally prefer new. I like having a warranty and knowing it hasn't been abused. It takes a hell of a deal to get me to buy used. So far every used tool I've bought has been anywhere from 1/4 to 1/2 of new price. Very hard to say no to. If I could swing it I'd buy new PM anything. Period. I say enjoy your new thing. Quote
andrew-in-austin Posted March 26, 2016 Report Posted March 26, 2016 Finding good deal on used wood working equipment is hot or miss. I would suggest to anyone wanting to find used equipment to expand their search to online auctions (beyond ebay), ones typically for surplus or plant closings. For example, I won at auction a Jet 208 20" planer from a high school for $600. Eventually I will add a helical head, but I'd like to see if Grizzly puts the the Shelix on sale again for $750. However, if you want the tool -right-now-, then there's really no other option than to order new. I think all of the 4 post 20-inch planers will probably last a hobbyist many decades. I held out for a long time on getting a large jointer, and looking back, I should have picked up a 6" jointer right at the beginning of my hobby. There are, however, a few good deals out there on some tools that come up often. The ones I see are: 1) cabinet saws for around $500-1000 (older Unisaw & Powematic probably being the most desirable) 2) 6" jointers for under $300 3) radial arm saws for $50-200 (older Dewalts and Rockwel/Deltas are great) Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.