Sara Young Posted June 28, 2025 Report Posted June 28, 2025 Hi everyone, So I’ve been browsing for a new solid wood coffee table for our living room, and I keep getting ads for these online-only custom furniture stores. Some of the designs look amazing—clean lines, real hardwoods, made to order, But I’m a little hesitant. I’ve never bought furniture online that wasn’t from a big-name store (IKEA, West Elm, etc.), and those you can at least return if something goes wrong. These custom ones? Not so much. One company even wanted 60% upfront with a 6–8 week delivery time. That just feels risky, especially when I can’t see or touch the piece before buying. Has anyone here actually gone through the process of ordering custom or handmade wood furniture online, From Etsy sellers or smaller independent shops? Did the final piece meet your expectations in terms of quality, joints, finish, and stability? Would you do it again? Also, is there anything specific I should ask before placing the order, Like about the type of joinery, finish used, or wood treatment? Quote
Sara Young Posted June 28, 2025 Author Report Posted June 28, 2025 On 6/28/2025 at 4:54 AM, Sara Young said: Hi everyone, So I’ve been browsing for a new solid wood coffee table for our living room, and I keep getting ads for these online-only custom furniture stores. Some of the designs look amazing—clean lines, real hardwoods, made to order, But I’m a little hesitant. I’ve never bought furniture online that wasn’t from a big-name store (IKEA, West Elm, etc.), and those you can at least return if something goes wrong. These custom ones? Not so much. One company even wanted 60% upfront with a 6–8 week delivery time. That just feels risky, especially when I can’t see or touch the piece before buying. Has anyone here actually gone through the process of ordering custom or handmade wood furniture online, From Etsy sellers or smaller independent shops? Did the final piece meet your expectations in terms of quality, joints, finish, and stability? Would you do it again? Also, is there anything specific I should ask before placing the order, Like about the type of joinery, finish used, or wood treatment? I’ve been looking at everything from coffee tables to Loveseat sofa sets lately, just trying to get a feel for what’s worth the investment when buying online. Appreciate any tips or stories Thanks! Quote
Popular Post Von Posted June 28, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted June 28, 2025 I've never heard of such online makers, but my advice, which would be the same with any custom furniture maker, is to ask for references to past customers who can speak to their work. 3 Quote
Beechwood Chip Posted June 28, 2025 Report Posted June 28, 2025 Try to have an actual conversation with the references, not just reading a review they wrote. Even so, call me paranoid, but any references you check remotely could just be the seller or a friend or family member. If at all possible, take a road trip and see their shop and some of their previous work. Video is a not the best way to appreciate wood work; it's best to feel the seams and edges and finish. Especially if it's a piece that will be touched, not just looked at. The contract should include species (oak, walnut, etc), what parts (if any) are not solid wood (epoxy, plywood, OSB, MDF, particle board, etc), what finish they will use, and what joinery they will use (screws, mortise&tenon, rabbets, box joints, dovetails, miters, etc). 2 Quote
Popular Post wtnhighlander Posted June 28, 2025 Popular Post Report Posted June 28, 2025 Regarding the 60% up-front, and 6-8 week delivery, that is on par for someone trying to turn their hobby into a business. Materials are a significant portion of the cost, and the time required to produce a truly "custom" piece often includes a week or two just locating and obtaining the right stuff. I wouldn't be turned off by an Etsy seller making those requirements, if building to order. But the advice regarding references is spot-on. 3 Quote
Ron Swanson Jr. Posted June 28, 2025 Report Posted June 28, 2025 Maybe you've tried this but is there anyone in your area who could take on this build? Local craftsperson or maybe a woodworking guild or club? Heck there's probably someone in this forum who is not too far from you! I can't tell you how many times i bought a product online and when it showed up, it was not what i was expecting at all. Good luck to you! 1 Quote
gee-dub Posted July 1, 2025 Report Posted July 1, 2025 I agree that checking in your local area would allow you to directly interact with the craftsperson. You might post your general location and someone here may be near or know someone near you. 1 Quote
yulisa Posted November 15, 2025 Report Posted November 15, 2025 On 6/28/2025 at 3:54 PM, Sara Young said: Hi everyone, So I’ve been browsing for a new solid wood coffee table for our living room, and I keep getting ads for these online-only custom furniture stores. Some of the designs look amazing—clean lines, real hardwoods, made to order, But I’m a little hesitant. I’ve never bought furniture online that wasn’t from a big-name store (IKEA, West Elm, etc.), and those you can at least return if something goes wrong. These custom ones? Not so much. One company even wanted 60% upfront with a 6–8 week delivery time. That just feels risky, especially when I can’t see or touch the piece before buying. Has anyone here actually gone through the process of ordering custom or handmade wood furniture online, From Etsy sellers or smaller independent shops? Did the final piece meet your expectations in terms of quality, joints, finish, and stability? Would you do it again? Also, is there anything specific I should ask before placing the order, Like about the type of joinery, finish used, or wood treatment? I have ordered furniture online before. But in my experience the quality is only acceptable, far inferior to the quality of furniture I ordered directly from the carpentry workshop. Quote
houstonboy Posted June 24 Report Posted June 24 I recently ordered a piece of custom furniture online and asked plenty of questions about joinery, wood treatment, and return policies. Also, checking out reviews and local workshops can help ease concerns. By the way, for outdoor comfort, I've been loving my double egg chair. It's been a perfect addition for relaxation. Just ensure any store you choose offers clear terms and good communication. Quote
JustAnotherGuy Posted June 25 Report Posted June 25 This a very old one but I think the recent reply is very timely. If you are near Boca or Fort Lauderdale, my daughter just purchase a patio from your Patio Store. Store is closing down and is giving away up to 80% disc. 2 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.