Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

milling - top glue up help

Featured Replies

Ok after my rough milling I realized that several of the boards are slightly twisted. I used the second method so I am not sure if I just did not realize there was twist initially or if they twisted after milling.

My question is what to do next? I am at 4.5 inches in width on each board and most boards have 1 7/8" thickness so I have some room to play with. I could try re-milling some of the wood but I am not sure what I would end up with size wise, and I dont want to leave myself with no extra to mill off the slab. I have a 12" jointer so I could glue up the slabs and joint and plain them afterwards. They would just be hard to deal with.

Should I remill the boards or the slab.

Alex...........Sometimes when you plane boards down you can realease tension in the wood, depending on how much your depth of cut is in your planing. Did you mill your boards and than let the sit around or did you go right to the glue up? If you left them sit around, that could be your issue. After planing you can have some bow, but you should not be getting much twisting. As far as re-milling or gluing up and than planing. Determmine how drastic the twist is. If it is greater than 1/8" you are going to want re-mill beforre glue up. You do not want to introduce that type of stress to the glue joint.

Please describe your milling process to the forum to see if there is something you can change in that process to avoid this issue in future mill ups.

KAISER OUT !!!

  • Author

I started by skip plaining both faces. Then I went to the jointer and jointed one edge then planed the other. There was about 24 hour period from the face planing until I was done with the edge planing and looking at glueing them up.

When I was determining which planing method to use of the two techniques Mark talked about I just sighted down the edge of the board and tried to determine if it was twisted. They did not look bad at the time so I decided to go with the less accurate skip planing method. I am guessing that I should have use winding sticks to check this.

This is my first really large batch of milling I have done. I think one of the things I should have been doing is checking more frequently during the milling that the boards were square and that everything was going well.

How do I measure the twist to determine if its more then 1/8"?

If I'm understanding your milling procedure correctly, it sounds like you are jointing one edge, and planing the other edge and both faces. Is that right?

You need to joint an edge AND a face before you go to the planer, otherwise the planer will follow the twist of the board.

  • Author

I normally would follow that procedure, joint face, joint edge, plane face, joint or TS edge but I was following the build advice from the roubo milling video.

Hey Alex. Generally speaking, twist is bad news. As I showed in the video, cups can be dealt with. But a twist will give you a huge headache down the line. My advice would be to take these twisted boards and joint them to remove the twist. You'll lose some thickness, but I think this is far better than incorporating a twisted board into your slab.

And keep in mind the skip planing method only works if you have an untwisted board. The straighter the better. If there is a twist, it should become even more obvious after a couple passes through the planer. If you ever notice that, I'd say you should go back to the jointer and mill out the twist. Then return to the planer.

Although you do have a 12" jointer, a twist is going to be very tricky to remove from a slab of that size. So I wouldn't count on being able to do that. Get it right from the glueup stage and you'll be a much happier woodworker. :)

definitely recommend replacing. I had one board in my bunch that was bowed and twisted. I kept milling and milling to clean it up and it ended up the runt of my boards and still was not stacking up nicely as I would have liked so I took an extra board and replaced it. Definately made my glue up a lot easier and I ended up with a mostly flat slab that took only a few passes on the jointer to flatten followed by a few passes in the planer to get to a bit more than 4 inches. I left a little on to flatten by hand.

  • Author

Well unfortunately I seem to have a slight twist on many of the boards. I don't know how to measure how much though. Little enough so most of them dont look twisted when I sight down the length. Looks more like a small amount of cupping. I can see it though when I use the winding sticks. Is there a way to check the by eye that will let me see the subtle twists rather then looking down the edge and the face?

I think what I am going to do is this weekend when I get the chance is joint and plane these and see what I end up with. I have several additional boards that were going to be for other parts of the bench that I can mill if I need to add more thickness. Worst case as several of you have mentioned I can go back to the mill and pick up some more.

I will post a follow up after I have done this to let you guys know how it went.

Mark, when you say that "If there is a twist, it should become even more obvious after a couple passes through the planer." How obvious do you mean? With winding sticks or just by eye? I want to know so I deal with this problem in the future as soon as it rears its head. Also do you guys generally check rough stock for twist with winding sticks before milling?

Just some feedback - I just completed my glue-up for the front slab - Tried biscuits and during the dry-fit there was too much movement. Used dowels (4 per joint about in the mid-point of the slab height) and it was rock solid. During the dry-fit alignment was off only about 1/32 off and this was more to the jig I used to drill the holes. With the dowels the glue-up went very smoothly. For the rear slab (more boards) i am going to revise my jig to try and get the accuracy better for the dowels (any suggestions?)

Hey Tom. One suggestion might be to try making your jig from different materials. The more rigid the jig, the more likely it is to register properly and eliminate the error. Metal jigs like the DowelMax are a good example. Obviously making one out of metal might not be on the menu. Perhaps using a block of high molec. weight plastic?

Well unfortunately I seem to have a slight twist on many of the boards. I don't know how to measure how much though. Little enough so most of them dont look twisted when I sight down the length. Looks more like a small amount of cupping. I can see it though when I use the winding sticks. Is there a way to check the by eye that will let me see the subtle twists rather then looking down the edge and the face?

I think what I am going to do is this weekend when I get the chance is joint and plane these and see what I end up with. I have several additional boards that were going to be for other parts of the bench that I can mill if I need to add more thickness. Worst case as several of you have mentioned I can go back to the mill and pick up some more.

I will post a follow up after I have done this to let you guys know how it went.

Mark, when you say that "If there is a twist, it should become even more obvious after a couple passes through the planer." How obvious do you mean? With winding sticks or just by eye? I want to know so I deal with this problem in the future as soon as it rears its head. Also do you guys generally check rough stock for twist with winding sticks before milling?

Alex to measure how much twist you just lay it on a known flat surface and see how much it rocks corner to corner....You did say you have a lot of twisted boards..........re-mill all of them! 1 or 2 out of a slab that is 7 wide would not be a big deal as the 1 or 2 boards will have enough strength to influence the other 5, but if you are in doubt about the amount of that are twisted, just remill all of them and save yourself the headache. There is a famous quote that goes something like this....."If there is any question, then there is no question" meaning in what should be done next.

KAISER OUT!!!

I normally would follow that procedure, joint face, joint edge, plane face, joint or TS edge but I was following the build advice from the roubo milling video.

Alex if you have a 12" jointer, as I do, always plane or joint face and then dimension... Excuse my terminology as I find the american names for these machines to be confusing. I call a jointer a planer or jointer and a planer a dimensioner as they do in Europe. Hence a planer makes a true face or edge and a dimensioner makes a parallel face or an equal dimension. I have always found it makes more sense. We don't call a handplane a jointer and even a jointer plane was originally called a "TRY" plane, due to it's nature of making a boards edge or face "tried and true".

KAISER OUT!!!

I started by skip plaining both faces. Then I went to the jointer and jointed one edge then planed the other. There was about 24 hour period from the face planing until I was done with the edge planing and looking at glueing them up.

When I was determining which planing method to use of the two techniques Mark talked about I just sighted down the edge of the board and tried to determine if it was twisted. They did not look bad at the time so I decided to go with the less accurate skip planing method. I am guessing that I should have use winding sticks to check this.

This is my first really large batch of milling I have done. I think one of the things I should have been doing is checking more frequently during the milling that the boards were square and that everything was going well.

How do I measure the twist to determine if its more then 1/8"?

My philosophy is don't ever skip plane if you don't have too. You have a 12" jointer/planer and don't have to skip plane a 41/2" board....DON'T
  • Author

Ok a preliminary report.

Took one of the boards which looked like had the worst twist across the face and remilled the faces, jointing one face first and then planing the other. Its now very straight and I only lost 1/8" inch on the depth. Not as bad as I was worried about.

I have not fully milled it by doing the edges yet but I am not so worried there because I have 1/2" that I can lose before I get to 4".

Now I just need to batch mill all the other boards.

More sawdust.

Will report back tomorrow with the results.

Thanks for the help everyone.

  • Author

Well I am now all done with the second pass of the rough milling, and other then the extra 8 or so hours everything went well. I did not have to use any additional boards and I am still at 4 1/4" on the width of all the boards.

I am considering this a valuable learning experience. Spent much more time on the second pass making sure things were as I thought they should be instead of assuming they were. Seeing as how I only lost some time I think it was a good education for cheap.

Now I am going to do the final milling. Have to drop about half an inch from the front slab in width and about a inch from the rear. Going to leave these dimensions about 1/4" oversize and rejoint and plane them after the glue up. I know that Mark suggests going to the exact size now but I am less confident then he is that I can do this and still end up with the edges of the block being square to the faces after glue up and milling of the faces.

Again thanks for everyone who gave advice.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.