Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Woodworking Forums & Project Advice | Wood Talk Online

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

6" jointer- 8 yr old Powermatic vs new Grizzly or?

Featured Replies

I'm a newbie so be easy on me. This is my first post. I am slowly buying tools and think I want a jointer. On Craig's list is a 8 year old Powermatic Model 54 that I can get along with a Shop Fox mortiser (he said he would throw it in, but I don't know enough to even know if I would use it much) for $500.00. Bear in mind it is about a 6 hour roundtrip to get it plus probably about $140 in fuel at today's prices. Guy was originally asking $700 until I showed him that there are specials on Powermatics for $849.00 right now, so he lowered his price. So would a well cared for 8 year old Powermatic be preferable to a brand new Grizzly G0654 for $505 delivered, or Grizzly G0452 $630 delivered or maybe a Jet JJ-6CS for about $755.00 delivered or just wait for a better deal. Thanks

Powermatic tools in my experience are a lot nicer than grizzly machines. If it were me I would go with the powermatic. What makes it difficult is the driving to go pick up the jointer and the time and costs associated with all that. I would maybe try to negotiate a lower price, maybe tell him to keep the mortiser and offer him $400. That just my opinion. It seems like from all the options though that you should just buy a new powermatic which is not to far from the jet in price. Might I also recommend a 8inch jointer, the two inches make a big difference. just a thought...

I agree that the PM is going to be a nicer machine, I have the 1285 so may be a little biased but they do seem to be better built. Im also not sure about the 6". 6" jointers in general dont hold their value well PM or not. Personally I'd hold out for a bigger machine 8" or larger.

Don

  • Author

Figure I'd start with a 6" before I invest too much and move to an 8-inch if I find I'm hooked on my new found hobbie which got started because I am renovatng a 1967 Airstream which I want to build new cabinets for. Space is a concern, I'm in a 2 car garage. This is another that I found just 20 minutes from me.

http://redding.craigslist.org/tls/2845002596.html

That is one of the origonal geetech and uses the same fence as the newer PM that your looking at. I'd jump on that one quick. FWIW that same jointer was sold by oliver and their QC has always been second to none. The pm your looking at is high as we thought. If you were here in WA you could get one brand new for $650.

Don

  • Author

Claims it only has about 2 hours of use on it. I notice that all the newer ones have at least 1 hp and this is 3/4 hp. Is that not an issue and can I get parts when they are needed?

These are your options.

1. New - 849

2. Used - 640 with gas

3. Grizzly - 500

If you have the 650 for the machine plus gas and you like Powermatic more than Grizzly. Is it worth it to you to pay 200 more and get a brand new machine with warranty and no headaches? You don't know what you are getting for that used machine.

  • Author

These are your options.

1. New - 849

2. Used - 640 with gas

3. Grizzly - 500

If you have the 650 for the machine plus gas and you like Powermatic more than Grizzly. Is it worth it to you to pay 200 more and get a brand new machine with warranty and no headaches? You don't know what you are getting for that used machine.

Guess you would not even consider either Jet new or the used one I found on CL?

That used Jet doesn't look to bad...price seems to be right...that might be your best bet.

I bought a 6" jointer a few years ago, and although it is an excellent machine, I wish I would have saved a bit longer for an 8". Now I need to replace a perfectly good machine with a more expensive one. D'oh!

Imo, you should be able to get a used 6" jointer for $100 - $300.

If you mentioned your area, someone might have a lead on one.

I bought my PM50, 6" jointer from a seller on Ebay. I forgot to bit, as did everyone else, and I called him and offered the starting price of $180, and he accepted it. As a bonus, I found out later, that it had solid carbide knives!

I bought it from a used machinery company, in FL

Imo, you should be able to get a used 6" jointer for $100 - $300.

If you mentioned your area, someone might have a lead on one.

I bought my PM50, 6" jointer from a seller on Ebay. I forgot to bit, as did everyone else, and I called him and offered the starting price of $180, and he accepted it. As a bonus, I found out later, that it had solid carbide knives!

I bought it from a used machinery company, in FL

Is yours an early pm50, if so you got a great deal. I sold a 1961 to a collector for $1500.

Don

  • Author

Imo, you should be able to get a used 6" jointer for $100 - $300.

If you mentioned your area, someone might have a lead on one.

I bought my PM50, 6" jointer from a seller on Ebay. I forgot to bit, as did everyone else, and I called him and offered the starting price of $180, and he accepted it. As a bonus, I found out later, that it had solid carbide knives!

I bought it from a used machinery company, in FL

Imo, you should be able to get a used 6" jointer for $100 - $300.

If you mentioned your area, someone might have a lead on one.

I bought my PM50, 6" jointer from a seller on Ebay. I forgot to bit, as did everyone else, and I called him and offered the starting price of $180, and he accepted it. As a bonus, I found out later, that it had solid carbide knives!

I bought it from a used machinery company, in FL

I'm in Redding, CA...any leads? Going to look at that old Jet right now. I'll report back, never used a jointer so really don't what to look for. I'm fairly mechanically inclined so hope that I spot any glaring issues. Bringing a straight edge and will give it a look.

  • Author

Looked and ran nice, however he would not budge on the price so I'll keep lookin'

Looked and ran nice, however he would not budge on the price so I'll keep lookin'

I wouldnt have either. $325 is a good deal. The quality of that old jet is on par with the new powermatic.

Don

Im with Don here. That is an early Jet. Those are pretty good machines. That is what you can expect to pay for something like that. If you are dead set on going with a 6" jointer, then I think this is your best bet. It is a good quality machine that if you put a little TLC into, when you do decided to upgrade, you might be able to get what you paid for it.

Im with Don here. That is an early Jet. Those are pretty good machines. That is what you can expect to pay for something like that. If you are dead set on going with a 6" jointer, then I think this is your best bet. It is a good quality machine that if you put a little TLC into, when you do decided to upgrade, you might be able to get what you paid for it.

The old ones hold up well. Here is my old one, the big brother version. The only difference is the size and the Oliver sticker vs Jet sticker. Its been through hell, the scrap guy cleaned it up put on a new cord and switch. Its now in my buddies production shop doing fine.

  • Author

Im with Don here. That is an early Jet. Those are pretty good machines. That is what you can expect to pay for something like that. If you are dead set on going with a 6" jointer, then I think this is your best bet. It is a good quality machine that if you put a little TLC into, when you do decided to upgrade, you might be able to get what you paid for it.

Not sure that one is an option as he got pretty testy when I offered him less. Guess I could call and tell him that after looking some more I have reconsidered and with my tail between my legs ask him if he will still sell it.

  • Author

Got it! Now to find a manual so I can check to make sure it is set up properly. Thanks to all for opinions.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Forum Statistics

  • Total Topics 32.1k
  • Total Posts 437.6k

Member Statistics

  • 26,011 Total Members
  • 3,644 Most Online
  • bobtjanitor Newest Member ·

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.