Godet Posted March 17, 2012 Report Posted March 17, 2012 Three years into spending a lot of time woodworking and I've finally grown tired of jointing boards with my hand plane and skip planing. I've pretty open to suggestions. I think 8 inches or wider is probably best for. I tried the cheap Jet combo unit and sent it back when it failed to joint boards. I have a Grizzly "lunch box" style planer, and it seems to work fine, so I don't really see a need for a combo unit. I tend to like Jet and Powermatic, but I'm open to others. Would like to keep it under $1200. Considerations: I don't like to tinker with machines. I don't mind setting it up, but I have limited time and I want to be making sawdust, but turning wrenches. I have limited space (I live in a DC row house with a small garage) I tend not to make huge projects--some book cases, but mostly side tables, small cabinets, and things like that. Quote
harleydog Posted March 18, 2012 Report Posted March 18, 2012 With a budget of 1200 you will be hard pressed to find a 8" or larger jointer from Jet or Powermatic. If you like your Grizzly planer then I would look at there jointer's you should be able to get at least a 8" or larger for 1200. Quote
Sac Posted March 18, 2012 Report Posted March 18, 2012 You can get a Griz 8" with spiral head for that.. it wont have parallelogram beds on it, but it will still be an 8" with a spiral head. OR you could upgrade that in the future.Just get one with the straight knives for now and spiral it up later if that was what you are looking for. Quote
Bobby Slack Posted March 18, 2012 Report Posted March 18, 2012 If you have money to invest, I heard the Canadian brand "General" is great and also they support their product very well. These machines are made in the North American continent ... The same company has a off shore brand called "General International". I am leaning toward suppliers who make machines in the US or Canada .... or Germany when I can afford it. So far I don't have a joiner and I use my friend's industrial 12" joiner and his massive 22" planer at his shop. I am very lucky so far. As a rent charge when i use his equipment I go with my Festool vac and I clean up his entire shop. Quote
dwacker Posted March 18, 2012 Report Posted March 18, 2012 As a rent charge when i use his equipment I go with my Festool vac and I clean up his entire shop. Sure wish you come use mt 12" jointer. Shop could use a good cleaning. Don Quote
Bobby Slack Posted March 18, 2012 Report Posted March 18, 2012 My pleasure ... you are a bit far for me, since I live in Southern California. The reason I do this to my friend is because many of my "friends" don't help out after I do them a favor ... if you catch my drift ... lol Sure wish you come use mt 12" jointer. Shop could use a good cleaning. Don Quote
Godet Posted March 28, 2012 Author Report Posted March 28, 2012 Uncle Sam has been good to me and the IRS refund will subsidize this purchase...any thoughts about the JJP-12HH--Jet's combo planer/jointer with the helical head. I originally thought I would pass on the combo unit, but it seems like a great deal, with good reviews on FWW. Budget is now about 3500...I'm open to other suggestions. Quote
dwacker Posted March 28, 2012 Report Posted March 28, 2012 Uncle Sam has been good to me and the IRS refund will subsidize this purchase...any thoughts about the JJP-12HH--Jet's combo planer/jointer with the helical head. I originally thought I would pass on the combo unit, but it seems like a great deal, with good reviews on FWW. Budget is now about 3500...I'm open to other suggestions. IMO to light duty to be a true 12" Don Quote
Vic Posted March 28, 2012 Report Posted March 28, 2012 If you have that much to spend, I suggest my jointer. http://www.grizzly.com/products/12-Jointer-w-Spiral-Cutterhead/G0609X I LOVE this thing!! Be sure to get yourself a bandsaw that can resaw 12", too. Then you're set to work 12" through out a build. 12" also seems to be the sweet spot for lumber prices, before they jump. Quote
farmbag72 Posted April 17, 2012 Report Posted April 17, 2012 it wont have parallelogram beds on it, but it will still be an 8" with a spiral head. I'm shopping for a jointer (probably 6 or 8") right now. There seem to be so many options/variations of machines within each manufacturer's offering. What is the advantage to parallelogram in/outfeed tables? I assume precise parallel-ness?? But are "standard" dovetail sliding tables that much different? What is the skinny on spiral head cutters? Is the extra cost worth paid for in finish quality? Quote
dwacker Posted April 17, 2012 Report Posted April 17, 2012 I'm shopping for a jointer (probably 6 or 8") right now. There seem to be so many options/variations of machines within each manufacturer's offering. What is the advantage to parallelogram in/outfeed tables? I assume precise parallel-ness?? But are "standard" dovetail sliding tables that much different? What is the skinny on spiral head cutters? Is the extra cost worth paid for in finish quality? Dovetails need to be shimmed to get the bed adjusted but you can only shim so far. Parallelogram jointer have the adjustment capabilities. Spiral cutter do well on very figured woods. There are a few varieties of spirals, the better are the shellix type. Spirals are really not worth the extra money unless you work with figured woods. If your working with straight grained woods for the most part you wont see any real difference in cut quality unless you are in the habbit of letting your blades get dull. Where a spiral truely excels is climb cutting on a shaper and where they were origonally used. Don 1 Quote
ALPHApoker Posted May 15, 2012 Report Posted May 15, 2012 I have a grizzly 8" joiner that I like accept for one thing. There is no adjustment to keep the Joiner coplaner. It's promoted as being set exact in the factory and never needing adjustment. The outfeed bed sags about 0.002" and there's nothing I can do about it. I'm perfectly OK with that as long as it doesn't get worse. Time will tell Quote
HuxleyWood Posted May 17, 2012 Report Posted May 17, 2012 If you have money to invest, I heard the Canadian brand "General" is great and also they support their product very well. These machines are made in the North American continent ... The same company has a off shore brand called "General International". I am leaning toward suppliers who make machines in the US or Canada .... or Germany when I can afford it. So far I don't have a joiner and I use my friend's industrial 12" joiner and his massive 22" planer at his shop. I am very lucky so far. As a rent charge when i use his equipment I go with my Festool vac and I clean up his entire shop. Have you checked the price of the Canadian built General 8" jointer? MSRP is over $4,500! Their Asian General International built one is about 2K. But then the General jointer is cheap compared to the only 8" jointer still made in the US, the Northfield 8" medium duty jointer starts over 12,500 before options! Probably the most cost effective non-Asian solution is the Austrian built Hammer A3 jointer/planer combo machines, the 12" starts at about $3k. Quote
Bobby Slack Posted May 19, 2012 Report Posted May 19, 2012 Somebody is gifting me a 6" jointer ... that is the best kind. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted May 20, 2012 Report Posted May 20, 2012 Uncle Sam has been good to me and the IRS refund will subsidize this purchase...any thoughts about the JJP-12HH--Jet's combo planer/jointer with the helical head. I originally thought I would pass on the combo unit, but it seems like a great deal, with good reviews on FWW. Budget is now about 3500...I'm open to other suggestions. The Jet is a pretty decent combo machine for the price, with the associated compromises of a smaller combo machine. The best combo machine in your price range (by a good margin) is the Hammer A3 31. You can get it will the quick set knives for the current sale price of $3K (plus shipping). The knives on this machine are two sided not very expensive (but I suggest getting cobalt ones) and are super quick and easy to set they also give a very good finish for a relatively low cost machine. They will put a Byrd Shelix head in for $800 more. Especially after the updates last year the Hammer is really the king of low cost J/P machines and with the available accessories is more flexible than the Grizzly and Jet machines and as a bonus it is built in Austria not the far east. The Jet and Grizzly are not even close to the quality and engineering of the Hammer. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.