SirGreggins Posted March 25, 2012 Report Posted March 25, 2012 I know there have been some of these topics already posted but I as read forum after forum I still don't have a good answer. I was looking at a Grizzly 6" Benchtop Jointer for $250 or so. Some people say for the luthierie stuff like necks and jointing bookmatched wood it'll be fine since I dont have anything over 25". Other say that becnhtop jointers are complete junk. If the fence lines up right (not warped or bent etc) then why are these benchtop ones getting such a bad rap? What makes them bad? Do they not cut well on hard woods like maple and even ebony like i will be using? Or are they simple too small for large pieces of wood. Like I said with building guitars I just need something that's going to give me a good clean cut on maple, walnut, mahogany, ebony, etc. I need to get the scarf joint of the neck nice and flush and square. I have a small shop in my grandparents basement they let me use so a big machine would be ideal and there is space but I just dont have the budget since i do this on the weekends just as a hobby. One day I will have a $700-800 Nice jointer. Please help me out. Thanks guys. Quote
rodger. Posted March 26, 2012 Report Posted March 26, 2012 Have you considered a jointer plane? Or even a smaller plane with a jointer fence? Quote
SirGreggins Posted March 26, 2012 Author Report Posted March 26, 2012 Any suggestions? I have done enough research on them to decide. Got any info on the differences, or why use one over the other. Thanks for the help. BTW cool profile pug pic Quote
Jfitz Posted March 26, 2012 Report Posted March 26, 2012 SirG - there have been a number of posts here and on other forums regarding the benchtop jointers. I think it all comes down to the fact that they are limited in size and power - and possibly alignment and accuracy, but I have no direct experience with one. The limitations need to be understood, and if the woodworking you do falls within the envelope of performance for those machines, then it sounds like a reasonable choice. Quote
rodger. Posted March 26, 2012 Report Posted March 26, 2012 Any suggestions? I have done enough research on them to decide. Got any info on the differences, or why use one over the other. Thanks for the help. BTW cool profile pug pic My suggestion would be for the Veritas bevel up jointer plane, with optional fence. I have a decent size power jointer (6"), but I am going to buy one of these planes for edge jointing longer stock (7 feet and up), and flattening table tops. http://www.leevalley...t=1,41182,52515 If you are going to be working with relatively shorter stock, you may get away with a jack plane and magnetic jointer fence. http://www.leevalley...t=1,41182,41716 The longer I work wood, the more I enjoy hand tools. Just make sure that you know how to sharpen the plane irons well. These hand planes don't come cheap, but you will really appreciate their quality whrn you use them. You can take a course from lee valley on handplanes, and get a chance to use them. The courses are not expensive, and they usually provide coffee and snacks. It's a nice afternoon. If you want to use a power planer, you should skip the lunchbox style. I think you will be dissapointed with it's performance, especially if you are making fine quality musical instruments. Woodworking is my hobby, and photography is my wife's hobby. She took that picture of our dog with her fancy-smancy nikkon camera. I'll pass on the compliment to her. Quote
sancho Posted March 27, 2012 Report Posted March 27, 2012 had the delta for years worked great. Even for longer pieces of stock like 10ft long pieces, just made a infeed out feed extension for it. It had pretty good dust collection to. I did dell it for a 6" Jet. But I did a lot of good work with that little bench top Quote
suiciedchild Posted March 28, 2012 Report Posted March 28, 2012 i have a 6" delta benchtop jointer, works great , the longest piece i have run through it was about 5 feet long , with no problems, iv made tables and boxes and bookmatched woods like goncalo alves , ipe , and brazilian cherry , woods that are much harder than maple without a problem. you should be fine , the only drawback i have noticed with the fench is that it doesn't seem to be as solid as the larger versions , so if you lean on it too much it will move, but if your just holding it along the fence instead of putting alot of pressure agianst the fence , it works great. 1 Quote
SirGreggins Posted March 28, 2012 Author Report Posted March 28, 2012 Thanks for all the advice guys. Sorry if I was annoying but I have to get as much direct info as I can before making a move. Floorboard and Sancho thanks a million, I'll be using super hardwoods like African Blackwood and ebony, as well as Ipe and if you had no problems I'm sure I won't either. And Franklin Pug, thanks for that link too. thats another great tool. Maybe i'll jig that up with my shooting board for the soundboard and backs, and use a small jointer for the neck. Quote
dwacker Posted March 28, 2012 Report Posted March 28, 2012 What is the widest that you think you will want to joint? Are you just doing edges? Don Quote
mikem Posted March 28, 2012 Report Posted March 28, 2012 I have the Delta bench top jointer, where the table is cast aluminum and the fence extruded aluminum. To be honest, I hate it. It is simply not long enough, and takes a lot of work with a roller stand to make sure I get a straight edge. I very rarely use it for face jointing, I have gone to using my #7 to do that. I will say the new Grizzly bench top APPEARS to be a step up with the cast iron top and fence. That may help some if it is more precisly setup. However, I would seriously consider spending the extra money and getting a stand alone jointer with a longer bed. Quote
suiciedchild Posted March 28, 2012 Report Posted March 28, 2012 If he is doing more instrument building I would guess just edge jointing more than face jointing, I use a hand plane or my lunchbox planner, have used it a couple times for that , dont remember haveing an issue. Quote
dwacker Posted March 28, 2012 Report Posted March 28, 2012 If he is doing more instrument building I would guess just edge jointing more than face jointing, I use a hand plane or my lunchbox planner, have used it a couple times for that , dont remember haveing an issue. If all he's doing is 2" and smaller then a router table with split fence would do a better job and have many more uses. Don 1 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.