jmaichel Posted May 7, 2012 Report Posted May 7, 2012 I would like to try using Japanese saws for joinery. I have used western saws before and did not like them very much and thought I would give Japanese saws a try. Any recommendations? Any Japanese chisel recommendations while we are at it. James Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted May 7, 2012 Report Posted May 7, 2012 I'm starting down the road but have never 'really' used western saws. I just got mine from Hida tool. I didn't get one of the hard wood tuned models. I got an inexpensive replaceable blade one - for thirty bucks I figured it was worth the risk. So far so good but I only used it to cut a small piece of wood to reinforce a sagging shelf. I also got a Massahige oiire nomi but haven't used it at all (or even set it up). I wouldn't skimp on the chisel from what I've read. When I was looking for what I wanted I emailed Hida, Japan Woodworker, Tools from Japan, and Japan-tool and they all emailed me back extensive answers and wouldn't hesitate to order from any and all of them. Quote
patrick anderson Posted May 8, 2012 Report Posted May 8, 2012 If you go to blowes, they sell a ryoba branded Vaughan but it's actually made by Z saw. For $20 iirc it's a great place to start. As for chisels, if you don't mind a bit of fettling the set from grizzly $150 ish is tough to beat and has had good wrtie ups. Quote
jmaichel Posted May 8, 2012 Author Report Posted May 8, 2012 If you go to blowes, they sell a ryoba branded Vaughan but it's actually made by Z saw. For $20 iirc it's a great place to start. As for chisels, if you don't mind a bit of fettling the set from grizzly $150 ish is tough to beat and has had good wrtie ups. I don't live near a Lowes and would rather avoid buying a saw from their. From my understanding I can get a decent Japanese saw for under $80 which is significantly cheaper than buying a decent western style saw. I have seen the Grizzly chisel set but would rather buy one or two high quality chisels now and add more later. James Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted May 8, 2012 Report Posted May 8, 2012 I would call or email Hida and talk it over with them. They will steer you in the right direction. I called on a Saturday and talked for 30 minutes or so with Milford there. They'll steer you in the right direction. Quote
patrick anderson Posted May 9, 2012 Report Posted May 9, 2012 I was thinking that you were starting out and didn't want to go spending a lot of money. Hida is certainly a good store to use certainly more so than JW. Quote
wilburpan Posted May 9, 2012 Report Posted May 9, 2012 I remember your first foray into using hand tools on WTO. And of course I'm happy that you're going to give Japanese tools a try. But instead of giving you a shopping list, do you have an idea for a project you want to build? That way you'll get tools that you will actually use, and that will be much more useful than a "go get these tools" list. Even if it's a relatively simple project like a dovetailed drawer. The other thing is a method for sharpening the chisels. What do you have right now? Quote
jmaichel Posted May 10, 2012 Author Report Posted May 10, 2012 I remember your first foray into using hand tools on WTO. And of course I'm happy that you're going to give Japanese tools a try. But instead of giving you a shopping list, do you have an idea for a project you want to build? That way you'll get tools that you will actually use, and that will be much more useful than a "go get these tools" list. Even if it's a relatively simple project like a dovetailed drawer. The other thing is a method for sharpening the chisels. What do you have right now? Hi Wilbur, Thank you for your reply. Yes my first venture into hand tools was kind of a disaster, I was ready to quit. Since then I have changed my tooling, got rid of most of my "western style" hand tools, picked up a TS55, MFT 1080, ETS 150, bandsaw, router plane, a couple mortise chisels, lunch box planer and a few layout tools. My next couple of projects is going to include dovetailed drawers, grooves, rabbets, mortises and dados. I currently only have grinding wheel and DMT duo sharp coarse/fine. Thanks again Wilbur! James Quote
wilburpan Posted May 11, 2012 Report Posted May 11, 2012 So let's go with a dovetailed drawer. Here's what you'll need, Japanese tool-wise: I'm going to assume you'll be milling the boards with machines. So then you need to make the dovetails: 1. Saws. Personally, I tend to use a 210 mm ryoba (two-sided Japanese saw with rip and crosscut teeth). The problem is that it's somewhat hard to find one in this size. A good alternative would be to get a pair of rip and crosscut dozuki (Japanese saws with a back). Gyokucho makes these, models #370 for the crosscut and #372 for the rip. These have replaceable blades, so when they get dull, buy a new blade. 2. Chisels. You'll just need a couple: a narrow one chopping out the waste between the tails, and a wider one for chopping the waste between the pins. A 6mm and an 18mm chisel will do here. 3. Layout tools. You already have these. So now you need to cut grooves for the bottom in the side pieces. There is a Japanese plow plane that will neatly cut a 1/4" wide x 1/4" deep groove, but they are kind of hard to find unless you go on eBay. There is an alternative to using that plane to cut a groove, and that's to saw the sides of the groove, chop most of the waste out, and clean it up with your router plane. Or use a corded router. Finally, you'll need something finer than your DMT duo sharp coarse/fine diamond stone for sharpening. An 8000 grit waterstone would be nice. If you can swing a 12000-15000 grit waterstone, that would be better. That should be a good start. Quote
jmaichel Posted May 11, 2012 Author Report Posted May 11, 2012 So let's go with a dovetailed drawer. Here's what you'll need, Japanese tool-wise: I'm going to assume you'll be milling the boards with machines. So then you need to make the dovetails: 1. Saws. Personally, I tend to use a 210 mm ryoba (two-sided Japanese saw with rip and crosscut teeth). The problem is that it's somewhat hard to find one in this size. A good alternative would be to get a pair of rip and crosscut dozuki (Japanese saws with a back). Gyokucho makes these, models #370 for the crosscut and #372 for the rip. These have replaceable blades, so when they get dull, buy a new blade. 2. Chisels. You'll just need a couple: a narrow one chopping out the waste between the tails, and a wider one for chopping the waste between the pins. A 6mm and an 18mm chisel will do here. 3. Layout tools. You already have these. So now you need to cut grooves for the bottom in the side pieces. There is a Japanese plow plane that will neatly cut a 1/4" wide x 1/4" deep groove, but they are kind of hard to find unless you go on eBay. There is an alternative to using that plane to cut a groove, and that's to saw the sides of the groove, chop most of the waste out, and clean it up with your router plane. Or use a corded router. Finally, you'll need something finer than your DMT duo sharp coarse/fine diamond stone for sharpening. An 8000 grit waterstone would be nice. If you can swing a 12000-15000 grit waterstone, that would be better. That should be a good start. Thanks for the recommendations Wilbur! I found a 210mm Ryoba at Hida for only $27, is this going to be a good enough? I was looking at the stones that Hida had but am unfamiliar with the brands, can you recommend one or two? Thanks Quote
Tony Wilkins Posted May 11, 2012 Report Posted May 11, 2012 I got the stones they recommend which were King brand 6000 and the Hida Brand 1000. I got the same saw that you did. Quote
wm_crash Posted May 12, 2012 Report Posted May 12, 2012 Woodcraft carries the Chinese natural stone, 12K+ grit: http://www.woodcraft.com/Family/2004920/Natural-Polishing-Water-Stone.aspx cheers, wm_crash, the friendly hooligan Finally, you'll need something finer than your DMT duo sharp coarse/fine diamond stone for sharpening. An 8000 grit waterstone would be nice. If you can swing a 12000-15000 grit waterstone, that would be better. That should be a good start. Quote
wilburpan Posted May 12, 2012 Report Posted May 12, 2012 Thanks for the recommendations Wilbur! I found a 210mm Ryoba at Hida for only $27, is this going to be a good enough? I was looking at the stones that Hida had but am unfamiliar with the brands, can you recommend one or two? Thanks I'm assuming you mean the Gyokucho 210mm ryoba. That should be a good saw, with the caveat that I haven't personally used that particular 210mm ryoba. I have other Gyokucho ryobas. One tip: if you go with the 210mm ryoba, and are sawing dovetails, even though people say that it's a rip cut, try the crosscut side of the 210mm ryoba if you are having issues with the rip side. With the sharpening equipment that you have, I'd add on the Shapton Professional 8000 grit stone from the selection that Hida Tool has. This is what I have. The description says to soak it for 5 minutes, but you don't have to do that. I spray it with water from a spray bottle and go. Having said that, I've also tried the Naniwa and Kitayama 8000 grit waterstone, and that's a nice one as well. The other 8000 grit waterstones that Hida Tool has all have good reputations. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.