doctormatt Posted May 21, 2012 Report Posted May 21, 2012 How does the performance of a carbide helical cutter head jointer compare to a jointer with conventional 3 HSS knives? Some reviews I've seen mention that the helical cutters can leave a scalloped surface that requires more sanding compared to a conventional cutter head but produce less tear-out on highly figured woods. Is this a problem when jointing an edge for gluing? I am looking to replace an old low end 6 inch jointer with a Powermatic-54 6 inch jointer with either quick-set blades or a carbide helical cutter. Do the carbide cutters actually stay sharp 3-4 times longer as claimed and are they significantly quieter? The ease of changing blades seems like the biggest advantage. Thanks. Quote
Mike M Posted May 21, 2012 Report Posted May 21, 2012 There is a world of difference between straight blades and individual carbide blades. I had both a 15" planer (jet) and 8" jointer (woodtek) with HSS blades. I had to have them sharpened about once a year and then spend half a day reinstalling them and getting them aligned. If I hit a nail, I had an extra sharpening and installation to endure. I replaced them with similar Grizzly machines with the Carbide spiral cutters and am a much happier camper. I haven't even rotated the blades in 3 years except when I hit a hidden nail. In that case I had to rotate 3 of the cutters which took about 10 minutes and I was back in business. The surface quality is as good or better than I got from the HSS machines and the maintenance is much less. The Byrd spiral heads are supposedly better than the Grizzly, but I havent seen the difference in the output. I would also suggest going for the 8" machine. The extra width is worth it. Mike Quote
Eric. Posted May 21, 2012 Report Posted May 21, 2012 I'd rather have an 8" with straight knives than a 6" with spiral. If you can afford both, go for it. Quote
wdwerker Posted May 22, 2012 Report Posted May 22, 2012 Wouldn't we all rather have 8 " ? < grin> Quote
CessnaPilotBarry Posted May 22, 2012 Report Posted May 22, 2012 If you don't already have one, I'd rather have a helical head planer first. Straight knives may tear out a touch, but I only face joint until I get a flat enough surface to properly support the board face down through the planer. Once I plane the other face, I finish by flipping the board end to end with each pass. In other words, my face jointed face rarely makes it to the sanding, scraping, or hand planing stage. As for edges, straight knives have never left me with an edge I couldn't use, or and edge that couldn't be cleanly ripped with a glue line rip blade. Quote
Dan S Posted May 22, 2012 Report Posted May 22, 2012 Wouldn't we all rather have 8 " ? < grin> I'm already planing my upgrade. I have a 6" now, and when I eventually upgrade (many years for now) I'M getting a 12" aircraft carrier with a spiral cutting head. My second jointer will be my last one. Quote
Eric. Posted May 22, 2012 Report Posted May 22, 2012 If you don't already have one, I'd rather have a helical head planer first. Straight knives may tear out a touch, but I only face joint until I get a flat enough surface to properly support the board face down through the planer. Once I plane the other face, I finish by flipping the board end to end with each pass. In other words, my face jointed face rarely makes it to the sanding, scraping, or hand planing stage. As for edges, straight knives have never left me with an edge I couldn't use, or and edge that couldn't be cleanly ripped with a glue line rip blade. That's a great point, Barry...never thought of it that way. I'd always planned on upgrading to spiral in the future on both my machines. Guess I'll amend that plan to just the planer now. Thanks for the tip! Quote
dwacker Posted May 22, 2012 Report Posted May 22, 2012 How does the performance of a carbide helical cutter head jointer compare to a jointer with conventional 3 HSS knives? Some reviews I've seen mention that the helical cutters can leave a scalloped surface that requires more sanding compared to a conventional cutter head but produce less tear-out on highly figured woods. Is this a problem when jointing an edge for gluing? I am looking to replace an old low end 6 inch jointer with a Powermatic-54 6 inch jointer with either quick-set blades or a carbide helical cutter. Do the carbide cutters actually stay sharp 3-4 times longer as claimed and are they significantly quieter? The ease of changing blades seems like the biggest advantage. Thanks. The powermatic quick set knives are actually very easy as far as time is concerned you wont save time, about 10 minutes to change knives. For larger jointers it takes longer with a spiral to change all the inserts. If budget is an issue you can do as Barry suggested. When your HSS knves get dull buy good carbide knives. The quiet part I see it more as just an argument for those looking to argue. Its a wood shop, there is going to be noisy machinery. As far as cut quality goes the cut quality with either is going to be good. With straight knives you have to keep them sharp and you will not see a difference. Once they dull then you see a difference but this goes for any cutting tool. If I had it to do again I would have gone with tersa heads. Don Quote
doctormatt Posted May 23, 2012 Author Report Posted May 23, 2012 Thanks everyone for all the comments. A new Powermatic 8 inch jointer is beyond my budget. I'm considering a used one, 15 years old that was in a highschool woodworking shop. This would not have the quick set blades. Are the quick set blades significantly less of a hassle to replace and align compared to the ones on an older machine? Quote
HuxleyWood Posted May 23, 2012 Report Posted May 23, 2012 Quickset knives index against a reference point, as long as you make sure there is no sawdust there you can change each one in less than a minute, many euro machines use diffrent forms of quick setting knives. Shame modern jointer and planer designs have given up on grinders and jointers, good old ones with large cutting circles leave surfaces better than carbide insert journal heads except on the most "pagan" grain, 'course for that a spritz of water or alcohol and a skew cut is all it takes. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.