nateswoodworks Posted June 28, 2012 Report Posted June 28, 2012 http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/chris-schwarz-blog/reconsidering-chipbreakers-as-not-totally-evil I was really curious on your thoughts as to this. I have always polished my chipbreakers but never a 50 degree secondary. I am probably going to try it this weekend but look forward to hearing any thoughts first. Nate Quote
RenaissanceWW Posted June 29, 2012 Report Posted June 29, 2012 The physics seems perfectly sound. If you think about it, not much different than a bevel up plane as it quickly breaks a chip on a higher angle bevel. Except now the bed angle is already at 45 or 50 and the "second, secondary" bevel of the chipbreaker cranks it up to 11. Quote
PaulMarcel Posted June 29, 2012 Report Posted June 29, 2012 The physics seems perfectly sound. If you think about it, not much different than a bevel up plane as it quickly breaks a chip on a higher angle bevel. Except now the bed angle is already at 45 or 50 and the "second, secondary" bevel of the chipbreaker cranks it up to 11. Ah, so it's the elusive Nigel pitch. Quote
mlehikoinen Posted June 29, 2012 Report Posted June 29, 2012 I haven't tried it myself, but from WIA last year, Graham Blackburn said you should be able to plane any piece of wood in any direction with no tearout by ensuring that:The mouth of the plane is open only as wide as the thickness of shaving that you are trying to take; and,The cap iron is set back from the edge of the blade only as far as that same shaving thickness. Of course, neither are exact sciences, but you get the idea. I like the idea of less clogging by polishing the cap iron. Maybe on my next sharpening session... Quote
pagel Posted June 29, 2012 Report Posted June 29, 2012 The video from Professors Kawai and Kato seems to show the chipbreaker with an 80 degree bevel set at 0.1mm from the cutting edge produced the least amount of tearout - at least from my eyes. The narrator, however, suggests that this is too close to the cutting edge because the flow of shavings are not as smooth as the previous test-distances of 0.2mm and 0.3mm from the edge. I'm not clear on why the flow of shavings is more important than tearout? Is it a concern with clogging? From what I could see, that angle and distance combination compared to the others produced the smoothest cut. Quote
nateswoodworks Posted June 30, 2012 Author Report Posted June 30, 2012 Amazing video, I think it made a believer Out of me and I have some work to do on a chipbreaker and give it a try! I think the question is how far to go with the secondary bevel. I plan to put a bit more than a micro and see the results, then increase and see if the results support going further . Thanks for the link. Nate Quote
RenaissanceWW Posted July 2, 2012 Report Posted July 2, 2012 I'm not clear on why the flow of shavings is more important than tearout? Is it a concern with clogging? When the plane starts to clog it will stop cutting, but it also can introduce vibration and chatter which will mar the surface just as much as tear out. Quote
pagel Posted July 2, 2012 Report Posted July 2, 2012 When the plane starts to clog it will stop cutting, but it also can introduce vibration and chatter which will mar the surface just as much as tear out. Thanks, Shannon. I wasn't sure what the narrator meant (tranlated of course) by the shavings not flowing as smoothly. Looking back, however, I suppose it was obvious that he meant clogging. By the way, I did my own experimenting with chipbreaker distances from the cutting edge but without the 50 and 80 degree secondary bevels. Sure enough, when the chipbreaker was nearest to the edge - the blade edge just barely visible - I got the crinkled-bacon-like shavings that clogged up the mouth very quickly. I'm going to give the secondary bevels a try and see what happens. Hey, repeatability is the mark of scientific vailidity. I just wish I had the testing gear they had. Japanese academics always seem to be doing cool stuff like this - I'm envious. Quote
nateswoodworks Posted July 4, 2012 Author Report Posted July 4, 2012 Well I had a chance to give it a try. Started out at 80 degrees and didn't like the results I had gotten, seemed to clog up the throat pretty consistantly unless I moved the chip breaker back about 3/32 and at that point I figured why bother. After that I went to about 65 degrees and then to 50 degrees so I could see the changes. At 65 I still had to keep the chip breaker back a bit over a 1/16th from the edge to keep from clogging and the results weren't that good. At 50 degrees is a good sweet spot, shavings come out and you are able plane consistantly against the grain without tearout! I do think the plane pushes differerent (seems to push harder) and is tricky to read or hear what is going on but I am sure with some time practicing you will overcome this. I think it is worth mentioning that I did not use one of my good Hock chip breakers, I used an old Stanley chipbreaker and my old #4 so that may be a game changer for the results. It is also trickier to get the angle figured out. I set my bevel gauge to the degree I wanted and while the chip breaker is tightened to the iron I marked the desired angle, if I would have done it any other way the deflection would have altered the angle at the end of the chip breaker. Look forward to hearing the results you all have! Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.