Recommended Posts

Posted

Friday I was at a flea market in town and I grabbed a Stanley two tone #4 plane. The first real plane I've ever owned. Recently I've read a couple books on planes and I've been watching, or more so, studying The Woodwright's shop for about a year. So when I saw this plane for $9 I thought what the heck. There were several other planes there varying in price including a pretty nice Stanley #7 for $45. When I got home I took the plane apart, cleaned everything, and spent a decent amount of time sharpening the blade.

First thoughts/questions from having no real plane experience:

I'm actually very surprised by how shallow you set the blade. But it makes prefect sense, though I imagine this varies from plane to plane. You can really gouge the crap out of a piece wood, I've found.

After a while of setting, trying, setting, trying, etc. I was making very nice shavings. I'm testing this on a scrap piece of walnut, though I did try a very hard piece of maple. Kind of surprised myself really. I would say on the walnut 90-95% of the time I get very nice shavings, but this brings me to a question about tear out. How do I stop it from happening? I'm holding the plane at an angle and going with the grain, should i use different technique? I think, and correct me if I'm wrong, if I could make the throat tighter it might help? Now from looking the plane over quite a bit I don't see how to do this. Is there a better or different solution?

Should I just run for the hills now that I've bought a plane and sees how nice, and enjoyable, they are to use? Any general advise for a newbie?

Posted

Welcome to the first step of what can become a slippery slope - plane buying. It sounds like you've done your homework and found a pretty good deal. Web search "smoothing plane" and you'll find great articles from Christopher Schwarz, David Charlesworth, et.al. on how to tune and use your new plane. It is fun and rewarding to get the proper shaving and hear the sound of a well-tuned plane on wood. If you're in a humid area, or just as a good rule of thumb, be sure to wipe down your plane after using with T-9 or another moisture displacer. Happy shavings!

Posted

Look at the back of the plane just below the adjuster wheel. You should see a flat head screw that runs through a U bracket and is threaded into the body of the plane parallel to the sole. This is the frog adjuster. First you will need to loosen the 2 screw under the iron that secure the frog to the sole, then you can advance the froger adjuster screw and it will move the whole frog assembly back or forward thus tightening or loosening the mouth. As with all things in life, too much and it will casuse problems. The more the frog is advanced the less it is supported by the body. Now vibrations can enter and cause chatter which can lead to tearout or just marr the surface. So go easy here. Now that being said, let's back up.

When you have the blade advanced to the point where you are getting fine to medium shavings how much space is there between cutting edge and sole? Fine to medium is in the somewhat transparent to opague yet highly flexible shaving realm, don't get out the calipers or I'll have to smack you :) Unless you are intending to only use this plane for smoothing then you want to be able to set the plane to take a 5-10 thousandths shaving as well as the 1-3 thou gossamers. The mouth gap should equal the thickness of shaving plus the thickness of a gnat's wing. Use this to determine if you need to mess with the frog position in the first place.

Now retract the blade so it isn't cutting, and hit the sole with a straightedge. The degree of flatness required depends on how you want to use the plane but since we are talking about a #4, lets assume smoothing. Lie Nielsen and Veritas grind their soles to within .001" tolerance. That's awesome but not necessary. You want to hold a straight up to the sole with a light source behind it and not be able to see any light specifically in front of the cutting edge, the toe, and the heel of the plane. If there are bits of light creeping in elsewhere no worries. These 3 points should be flat and co-planer to each other. If the area right in front of the mouth isn't flat then the sole is not pressing down on the wood and helping to prevent tear out so it won't matter how tight the mouth is. If this needs attention, put some sandpaper on a known flat surface and lightly lap the sole until those 3 points are in harmony.

Now much hullabaloo is going on about chip breakers and it is all interesting. Let me cut through all the esoterica and say this. You want the chipbreaker to be set as close to the cutting edge as you vision can make out. You want the surface to be clean and polished so the shavings won't have anything to catch on and clog. While polishing, if you want to add a micro bevel to the breaker this will help too. The key is that the underside of the chip breaker should be flat and mate seamlessly with the plane iron when it is tightened down.

Now put the blade back. Sight down the sole from the toe with a light colored surface behind the plane. Advance the blade until you can clearly see the dark line of the cutting edge protruding. Now use the lateral adjuster (the little stick poling out under the iron) to make the cutting edge parallel with the sole. Just eyeball this, don't obesses. Now Now Advance the blade by 1/4 of a turn on the adjuster wheel and keep taking passes then 1/4 turn until the plane starts to cut. This is the best way to set it up to take that wispy shaving. Tear out can often be tamed just by taking a light cut, but 9 times out of 10 the blade needs to be sharpened. The heavier the cut, the more likely tear out will occur, but that is also why we have smoothing planes to clean it up with light passes.

I'm sure I'm missing something here, but this should get you started. Try this and let us know if you are still having problems.

Posted

Thanks for the replies.

After I posted this thread I watched the video on chip breakers posted here:

Then I looked and my plane and my chip breaker was WAY farther back, probably around 3/16" or so. When I took the blade off I found where I could adjust the frog. (The frog is what the blade sits on, right?) There are two screws under the blade that can be loosened and I slid it forward a little bit to close the mouth. I am still getting some tear out after re-adjusting. I will try polishing the chip breaker next and I will lower it even further. I do not have any chatter and from your description I would classify the shavings as "fine", and now that you mention it I will probably take my calipers to them tonight, LOL. The mouth gap is still quite a bit more than the thickness of the shavings so I'll tinker with that some more. I do not think blade sharpness is an issue. I will also check to see how well the chip breaker mates to the blade, I've never thought to look at that.

I had not checked the flatness of the sole yet, or done anything to it, but that is on the list. Should I use any specific grit of sandpaper and just start course and work my way up? Also, do you guys think that $45 for a Stanley #7 is a good buy? I currently do not have a jointer of any sort.

Posted

For a working #7 without having to do much in restoration, that's a steal. For sandpaper grits, it depends on the condition of the sole of course, but generally speaking you can start off with 120 to take off the high spots and finish up with 220. Use a Sharpie on the sole to judge your progess, i.e., draw diagonal lines across the surface and once the lines have been removed (you've more or less flattened the sole) you can move to the 220 grit.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.