STL Woodguy Posted July 8, 2012 Report Posted July 8, 2012 I just had a very scary incident involving an old jointer which I purchased last week (that I successfully saw demoed). I've got it home and reassembled it. With the help of a friend with electrical experience, I got the machine's motor running safely on 220v off my dryer outlet. The beds were adjusted to one another, the fence adjusted 90 degrees. The knifes were adjusted with a magnetic jig, all bolts on the gibs were down tight. The only other thing I was concerned about was the worn belt, so I replaced it with a link v-belt. I hooked the belt up to the motor and started turning everything by hand, all blades cleared the tables, the operation seemed smooth and nothing looked or sounded out of the ordinary. Satisfied and figuring I had covered all the bases, it was time to give it a test run...I put on safety glasses, hit the switch and quickly moved back near the power outlet. Things went extremely bad as I suddenly heard a ton of banging, metal scraping and something trying to force it's way out of the jointer's guard. I darted to pull the power and once everything had spun down, I pulled back the guard. The ends of the knives were completely ruined and and the gibs had taken damage. One gib had somehow gotten forced out and shot down the dust chute with enough force to break through part of the flange, the gib completely bent. Thank god I had the guard on and was standing at an angle on the opposite side of the jointer. However, it didn't make ANY sense what happened, certainly anything that wouldn't had cleared or was loose would had been discovered when I ran it by hand. https://dl.dropbox.c.../cutterhead.jpg https://dl.dropbox.c...099329/gibs.jpg To make a long story short, I discovered that the bolt (closest to the operator) that held down one end of the cutterhead had somehow come completely loose...perhaps loosening all the way when the machine came on. I assume that the loose side of the cutterhead shook up and hit the guard, and the force was enough to dislodge the gib, causing further disaster. I can't believe I overlooked that bolt, but it would have been hard to know about unless I had been changing the cutterhead. Lesson learned, just need to replace the parts. That loose bolt that cause this whole mess is certainly going to be replaced, I tightened it back down but it continues to turn at the end, no good. I need new blades and those are easy enough to find. The one gib is completely bent and ruined, two of the corners of the cutterhead that house one blade / gib are slightly bent. Maybe that could be filed down and it would work fine with new gibs, but I don't trust that and it's an old cutterhead anyway. So roughly how much would a new cutterhead with straight knives set me back and where do I find an aftermarket one, are they fairly universal between units? I Googled around but all I could find was pages talking about / selling spiral aftermarket upgrades. Which might make for a better upgrade if I have to replace the cutterhead anyway (and wouldn't have to buy blades), but that all depends on the price difference between the two. Quote
croessler Posted July 8, 2012 Report Posted July 8, 2012 First questions would be what is the make and model of the unit? Quote
STL Woodguy Posted July 8, 2012 Author Report Posted July 8, 2012 Powermatic Model 60. First thought I had after posting this was "Duh, call the company," but will have to wait until tomorrow at least. Not sure if the cutterheads on their current models would fit the older model 60, depends on how little or much they may have changed the design on their current stuff. After looking at the cost of (decent) knives and thinking the cutter head and gibs may not be cheap, great possibility it might be more cost effective in the long run to go with the Byrd spiral or whatnot. Once I get the loose bolt replaced, I will likely use the current cutterhead sans blades/gibs as a guinea pig to verify everything is tight and working before I place the spiral in, if I go that route. Quote
croessler Posted July 8, 2012 Report Posted July 8, 2012 The thing about getting a new head like a byrd or one of those is, at least I think, that they come with new bearings and everything. Might be something to consider. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted July 8, 2012 Report Posted July 8, 2012 The cheapest approach will be to place WTB ads on OWWM and larger woodworking forums. You should be able to get a deal on a journal head since so many of them get replaced with Byrd heads. A quality set of knives for that jointe should run about $30 shipped in T-1 steel but you may get a completly servicable set with a used head. Compare that with a Byrd at right over $400. It would be a good time to upgrade but I am betting with a little work you can be back in business for under $150. Quote
STL Woodguy Posted July 9, 2012 Author Report Posted July 9, 2012 Here was officially the culprit: It's possible that the threads got stripped out during the above incident, but I honestly don't think so as that should NOT have happened if the bolt was secure in the first place. I just replaced it with a brand new bolt (and replaced the rear bolt for good measure), reinstalled the naked cutterhead and (nervously) powered the jointer on. Worked just fine, no issues, only sounded as noisy as the motor. Upon further investigation of the cutter head, **IF** those odd corners on the one blade area could be filed back down perfectly flat, the blades should sit fine on them again, the rest of the cutterhead is fine. Two of the blades are still in fine condition (but need resharpening). Two of the gibs are in decent condition; one is just a little nicked on the end. The casualties include the third blade - way too chipped and not worth resharpening - and the bent gib is obviously ruined and needs replacement. Huxley: Fine idea...I might do something a little different than the online boards and hit up the local woodworking guild instead. Someone there must have done the spiral replacement and/or has an extra gib sitting around. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted July 9, 2012 Report Posted July 9, 2012 Local is always a good idea. If not either OWWM other boards or Redmond Machinery in Newnan, GA. Quote
TimV Posted July 9, 2012 Report Posted July 9, 2012 Glad to hear you're ok. Grizzly sells spiral cutterheads if you're interested: http://www.grizzly.com/catalog/2012/Main/48 Quote
STL Woodguy Posted July 9, 2012 Author Report Posted July 9, 2012 Glad to hear you're ok. Grizzly sells spiral cutterheads if you're interested: http://www.grizzly.c...og/2012/Main/48 Had a night to sleep on it and I 'really' don't like how that knife / gib got ejected from the machine, adding a big selling point on the spiral side. Let's say I did go spiral...the price of the Grizzly is a little easier to swallow, can that be fitted into an old Powermatic? EDIT: I ended up finding a very nice coupon code for Holbren which knocked the price on a Byrd spiral (for my machine) only a little more than $50 than the Grizzly one, and with free shipping, was a no brainer. Still costly, fortunately I have almost $200 in the change jar sitting around to eat that cost. But honestly I think this is the quickest - and SAFEST - way to get back up and running and get the benefits of the spiral to boot. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted July 9, 2012 Report Posted July 9, 2012 I think it is the best overall move and would have mentioned Brian and his coupon had I known you were leaning that way. While I consider the OEM journal head to be safe, you found a way it isn't but one can do that for anything! In the end you will have a better and easier to use machine. Quote
STL Woodguy Posted July 10, 2012 Author Report Posted July 10, 2012 Actually, I should have taken a closer look at TimV's link (my mind is in a million places at work): at first I thought those were just Grizzly's own spirals for their machines. What I didn't know is that they were a dealer for Byrd. I only noticed this when I just opened up a mailed catalog from Grizzly that came in the mail...anyway, the catalog says it will fit my Powermatic jointer and they're on sale for much less than even Holbren's coupon. Grizzly is south of here and I've been looking for an excuse to hit Springfriend / Branson, so I think I have that excuse. Or even if it's shipped, it'll get here super quick. EDIT: Meh, false economy on shipping price + tax, only about $10 cheaper in the end (but still fast). But pickup is still $40 cheaper. Quote
HuxleyWood Posted July 10, 2012 Report Posted July 10, 2012 I would have mentioned the few Byrd heads Grizzly carries are usually cheaper than Holbren but I got the impression it was already ordered. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.